Rated 4.61 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review HOLY GRAIL
All I have to say is that if there is one thing I know - it's eyebrows. I've been obsessed with brows for like over ten years. This product is hands down, the absolute BEST eyebrow product I have ever used. The formula is light years ahead of the ABH Brow Definer. It is highly pigmented but also buildable, which is incredible. It made my light blonde, thin/sparse brows look full, defined, and perfect (in combo with Gimme Brow) and took me less than five minutes. I received this as a Platinum Perk (Thank you Benefit & Ulta, you are so good to me!) and I will be in line when Ulta opens on June 24th to purchase another one.
Most Helpful Critical Review Not what I expected!
Love how the wand makes it easy to apply but I felt the product too creamy which made my eyebrows look very oily by the end of the day.
Reviewed by 10946 customers I have tried many eyebrow products and this is by far my fav
Britt from Albuquerque NM
I use this product on my eyebrows everyday and it's always been easy to apply.
Love this eyebrow pencil
MMW from Philadelphia
I really enjoy this eyebrow pencil and have purchased and used several over about 3 years. The natural color of the pencil itself, the slightly softer brush, the length of the device is comfortable to use, it all works. I do wish the packaging of the pencil had a better design, it feels a little clunky, I don't get the exaggerated trim details and the lettering/packaging always rubs off so don't forget what color you have! but I can look that over. Especially when the tried and true ABH mechanical eyebrow pencil is feeling flimsier lately, this is a great alternate.
Simply The Best Eyebrow Pencil
LauraG from Naples Fl
This eyebrow pencil is so easy to use and it's angled in such a way that makes it so easy to apply. And it Never Needs sharpening !
I have used this for many months now and like it
Laura from Fairhaven ma
I fill in my brows with it
megan from georgia
my favorite eyebrow pencil. but this price is ridiculous!!! sorry caint pay this anymore.
Carol from Newtown, ct
Great product for eyebrows. Poorly designed holder No way to tell if pencil is almost at the end and you can't refill so you have to throw away the holder.Very bad environmentally! I like this product but will be seeking out a different one in the future.
There's no comparison!
Brit from Wi
This is my favorite brow pencil I've ever used! There's really no comparison to other brow products for me this one knocks it out of the park!
KRatliff from TX
I've been using this brow pencil for 2 years now and I'll never change! It's SO user friendly and dummy proof for someone like me who's not great at brows. Lasts all day and looks super natural.
Best, most natural pencil if you use feathery strokes.
Chicks from Paducah KY
Being older, my brows have thinned and this pencil really adds the definition and color, without looking drawn on
Would buy again and again
Di from KCMO
Love the color hard to find gray or charcoal!
Goof proof brow pencil
Pooh from Sarasota
I've been using this product for about 4-5 years. Love the ease of it and how it makes natural looking brows.
Love Love Love
Lisa Lisa from Forney, Texas
Draws and shapes my eyebrows Beautifully before I fill them in❤️
I received this as a gift 6 years ago & Im still purchasing
Monnina from Overland Park, KS
The name says it all
I would buy again!
Kasey from State college, pa
I would buy this again, maybe the full size product so it comes with the brush too!
Sarah from Georgia
I really life this item. It's goes on smooth & soft. Ayer a few minutes it doesn't come off easily. I will definitely buy it again.
The best waterproof eyebrow definer
Nancy from Rochester, NY
I have been a fan of this version of the Benefit brow line for a long time. I love the fine point tip; it makes it very easy to define my eyebrows. It lasts all day. I have used other products, but I always come back to Benefit.
LoriSR from Santa Rosa, CA
Great eyebrow pencil that is easy to apply and stays on all day. My eyebrows were never the same after chemo 13 years ago and this product fills in and enhances my brows. :)
Sav from Pennsylvania
So quick and easy to use!! I've been using this brow pencil for about 5 years now and I've only had to buy 2! I'm still using my second one- bought in 2019 and now it's the beginning of 2022. If you use a clear brow gel on top, it lasts the whole day and doesn't smudge. Highly recommend!
Love this and doesn't smudge off
Stargirl from Mi
This works great even on my oily skin. You never have to fear looking in the mirror to find half of your eyebrow smudged off. It really stays put! Love this product and color choices are good.
A from Cary
People rave about this tool as well as the one from Anastasia. While it works, the nyx one I usually buy works just the same. I find it pointless to spend more money on something I can get for a cheaper price.
I would by this again
ranggg from NE
I haven't found very many eye brow pencils I really like. Something about this one that is so much easier to use... at least for me. Color is perfect. It 's a very thin pencil so it goes on more precise. LOVE IT
R from Atl
Genuinely one of the best brow pencils on the market. It stays all day and it glides on easily. It never dries out and lasts a long time even when I use it every single day.
Skai from California
I use this product when I am in a hurry to leave the house. The product I normally use is Anastasia Dip Brow Pomade, but i recently got sick and am a little bit lazy when it comes to my make up now, so this product is what I have been using more often lately.
I love it but doesn't last long!!
Lily from California
I love this product but its very expensive for how little product it has! I have the mini pomade and it lasted over 5 months compared to this pencil that lasts max 1-2 months
Love this brow pencil
Kayakgirl from Columbia SC
Other eye pencils tended to look unnatural where this one blends in with natural color and looks very natural