Rated 4.47 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Unbelievable
I'd heard people raving about They're Real! I mean, who hasn't. But I didn't believe it. There was no way a mascara could create such incredible results. So when I recently bought a Beauty Score from the Benefit Kiosk in the Las Vegas airport, I was elated to see the They're Real! tube in the bottom of the box. I'm sold. Game over. I don't see myself every buying another mascara. They're Real! makes my lashes long and thick and with no flakes! Just amazing. It also helps that the wand is like perfection. The end is great for getting those thin lashes and the design certainly helps separate the lashes.
Most Helpful Critical Review Burn baby burn!
Once my 30th birthday was a few months away, I decided it was time to get proactive about my under eye care. Previously, I used whatever heavy moisturizer I used on my face. This seemed to be something that would be up my alley. I'm African-American with very sensitive and dry skin. I do not have any fine lines or wrinkles. Nor do I have any dark bags. At least, I didn't UNTIL I started using this product. But, before I list out all the horrible effects I suffered from this "potent" product, I will say that the one issue I had before starting this was that I have a toddler so I'm sleep deprived. I also am a trial attorney, so am extra sleep deprived. That's it.
The first time I used this, it burned. I wasn't sure if hey it's a "tingle" or a burn, so I decided to try it again. I told myself it must be potent! No aging here! I even told my 35 year old brother to try it, and he yelled that it burns. Whoops. In addition, I developed dark black bags under my eyes, and scaly dry patches. I thought this was supposed to moisturize!?! Obviously, I discontinued use, but after a week of using it once a day, my eyes are tender, sore, have scaly dry white patches, and black underneath. It hurts to blink!
Reviewed by 39757 customers Love!
Mo from LA
Easy application and wears well all day with almost 0 smudging.
"At last..the best mascara has come along"
April from Texas
Never need an eyelash curler again!
Love this one
Tam from Rockford
I would not buy
Bun from Oak Island, NC
I need a smaller brush. My friend bought this product and found it difficult to remove.
iz from ky
i've been using this mascara for over a year now and literally the best mascara ever. it doesn't clump and it's easy to work with. i definitely recommend getting it !!
Clump Crusher from CoverGirl
Lexi from Clearwater
Got this product as a sample in a box of four other Benefit mascaras. I'm a die hard Better than Sex Mascara from Too Face fan but wanted to try it. Don't recommend this mascara due too it's identical for the Clump Crusher mascara by CoverGirl.
not what I had hoped for
Rockin Robin from Waterbury, CT.
I thought it was entirely overrated for the price
Holds up to anything
malaughtman from Missouri
I sobbed for over 20 minutes twice in 1 day and it literally did not move or get into my eyes. I'm never buying a different mascara again
Shella from Mi
Been using this brand for years. Great mascara
Love the mascara… hate the wand!
Madi from Michigan
I swear by this product and have for the last 4 years! I have ONLY used this. It's amazing, it stays on, doesn't smudge, makes my lashes full and fluffy. But I'm the last year 2 of the applicators have broke on me. Back to back! Augh the handle snapped right off both of the wands! How strange! I love this product I just think they changed to cheaper materials and it's not working out😔 I'm not sure if I should look at different products or just try and buy another new one. Btw the purchases and breakage were in 1 month of each other both times!!
Love this blush
Annie from Plattsburgh NY
I use this on my cheeks every day
LASH LASH LASH
love the best from minneapolis, mn
No nick name from Ohio
I would not buy this product again.
Jackie from New York
I was looking for a replacement to my Becca blacklight primer as the company is going out of business. I purchased this product in hopes of getting that illuminating shimmer the Becca product provided; however, this product did not even come close to delivering. My pores were slightly blurred but my skin was not illuminating. I will be looking for a better replacement. I gave this two stars because my makeup did stay on all day and the product feels like silk.
Didn't think I'd like it but I do!
Lor4 from Gilbert, AZ
I really like this! I have blonde eyebrows and eyelashes and this really helps to darken them. I have to dye my eyebrows and use it conjunction with other eyebrow products but this really helps to define and shape them.
Keeps those brows in line !!
Chrissy from Key west
Sets the brows perfectly
I would purchase this item again
Ann from Warren, Mi
Very easy to apply
Anna from Colorado Springs, Colorado
My first time using it, I cried and it didn't even smudge! 10/10 recommend if you're looking for a great waterproof mascara!
Simple to use - a must brow buy!
Susie from Vienna WV
simple to use for someone not very experienced with makeup application. Looks very natural.
My one and only!!!
a.b from fl
I used to swear that drugstore mascaras were the same but this blows everything out of the water for me. Nothing curls and separates like this one and it makes me look like I have falsies on!! Only thing is, it can be hard to remove (at least on me) so use a good eye makeup remover!! This mascara and a good lash curler will have your lashes looking amazing. I've been using this for over 3 years now!! Don't ever get rid of this :D
I would buy this product again and again.
Julucky1 from Chicago
I would buy this product again and again. I love this product.
Bookworm from Pittsburgh
Love Benefit eye products. Consistently does as described and easy to apply for a beautiful application.
Kay from Atlanta
Why even question it ?? Absolutely best mascara ever.
Pair this with they're real magnet first and youll never got back!
Brianna from NJ
I've never reviewed anything but I feel this product deserves it considering I'm on my 3rd tube. This is the best stuff ever. I wear it every single day as I don't wear much makeup for summer and it acts as a great holding gel. And it promotes hair growth. I honestly don't think I'll ever stop buying this 🙌🏼🙌🏼
Lucy from TN
Love this product