Rated 2.77 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review 24 hours 100%
I got this in place of urban decay's nude waterline eyeliner & i have to say the nude makes your eyes pop when used on the lower waterline... i havent used it on my upper waterline because i usually do a cat eye but I am looking into getting the same product in black to test the top waterline for waterproof capabilities. This product goes on better than NYX white liner & does NOT budge. I have been wearing it constantly and it brightens my eyes so much. Super happy with this product. Will buy more colors.
Most Helpful Critical Review This product needs more R&D: won't sharpen
I bought this product a month ago and was very excited to see it last all day, didn't smudge, but I could use it with other products. Until the tip wore down. I know how to sharpen a pencil, which this essentially is. The plastic casing around the color is too brittle, I spent 20 minutes this morning cleaning up the casing that shattered all over my dressing room and on to my blouse. In the bathroom to clean up the mess I had to SCRUB my hands to get the liner color off my fingers, which then left my bathroom sink stained. Will anything be done about this? I get it, first world problems...but an element of this product is terrible. I believe that those that haven't complained may have not have tried to sharpen the product yet.
Reviewed by 537 customers Quit twisting out more product after a week :(
salesgales from FL
When you open there is a very little tip exposed, so I tried twisting the bottom to make more come out when that got low...basically stopped working. The tip is hard plastic so not sharpenable. Went to hubby's tool kit for a wire-cutter and opened the pencil - full of product and no way to get it out!!! Bad design...
It goes on easily
Grandma6 from Kingsport, TN
I like the way it goes on. It is a thin line and you can correct your booboos.
Not worth it!
Yanata from Aliso Viejo, Ca
I like how the eyeliner glides on smoothly. However, it does not stay on. I was hoping that this waterproof eyeliner would be a keeper.
I like this eyeliner....
amarhikyann from undisclosed
I like this eyeliner. I like that it is waterproof! Ive been looking for a waterproof eyeliner for the longest. It has great quality.
quality is normal
luzdiazb6be8f7b from undisclosed
You cant go wrong with this eyeliner' it does its job. As any other waterproof eyeliner this lines falls a little bit on the dry side but you can still make it work on top of any eyeshadow that you might have already apply on your lids before
noora53 from undisclosed
Its so smooth and easy to apply also waterproof stayed on all day for me no smudges or anything
akhdao from undisclosed
I have always loved this eyeliner pencil. It literally takes so much for it to even budge. I gave up on tight lining my eyes until I purchased this about a year ago and Im so happy I got one through this voxbox!
My new favorite
michalaz from undisclosed
I really love this liner a lot! It is soft and goes on so smoothly. I was using a different black eyeliner before this and it just didnt do the trick like this one does. I highly recommend this liner!
eyeliner oh eyeliner
violetp3 from undisclosed
This might be one of the best cheap eyeliners, I do t like eyeliner because I want to wing it and I never can so I give up unless I want to get frustrated. But I loved this it was so easy to use beautiful rich black color and I swear stayed on ALLL day, no nasty little smudges on your eyelids.
sharonchoii from undisclosed
I think this eyeliner is really nice. It has a long wear. The only thing I would change is it kinda smudges.
Dramatic with staying power
Faith from Portland, Oregon
Dissatisfied from Tx
I tried several makeup pencil sharpenera and it will not Sharpen. I really only got a one time use on it. Such a waste.
Will not buy again
Mary from Mentor, OH
Unfortunately, probably one of the worst liners I've tried. The eyeliner itself is so soft that, even when sharpening with a cosmetic sharpener as recommended, the eyeliner is so soft that it breaks off and gets stuck in the sharpener. Same thing happens upon application, too soft to apply without it breaking or "smooshing" into my lid, regardless of how gentle I am with it. I only gave it 2 stars due to the fact that it is long lasting, and didn't smudge or smear for 24hrs. Although the cons greatly outweigh the pros for me, it was FAR too difficult to work with, will not buy again.
Sherylann from Cincinnati
I have searched for yrs, I'm 52, for that perfect color for hazel eyes and a pencil last will not slip off after a moment's wear. This pencil delivers without fail. The IVY color makes my hazel eyes pop. A subtle color for a natural look. This pencil also wears all day with a little touch up in needed for going out in the evening. I literally have bought every high end makeup line and this drugstore find is a gem. I loved so much I went and three more to stash. Btw, the Voluminous Original Mascara in Deep Green works amazing for hazel eyes as well. Another product that lasts all day for a natural look.
No way to sharpen!
redhead50 from ohio
Nice color (bronze), but there is no good way to sharpen this. Regular sharpener does not work. It doesn't have its own sharpener. No instruction on packaging. I'm going to try a paring knife. I won't buy this again. Any suggestions?
Absolutely would buy every time!
Wildfire from Cleveland TN
I have used eyeliner since I was about 13 years old on my water line, but always ended up with raccoon eyes, I actually stopped using eyeliner because I was never able to find one that worked UNTIL I found this eyeliner and now I use it on a weekly basis!
Wasteful design for a great product
KJohns from Salem, Or
Being a religious Infallible eyeliner user, I have tried this product twice thinking the first time was my fault. I wear full PPE at work and even the infallible (able to advance at bottom) waterproof eyeliner smears, and stamps my top lid. This product does no such thing while still coming off with eye makeup remover! But, use it past the product just visible at the tip of the pencil and it's gone. I have a L'oreal makeup pencil sharpener and no go. Please make this advancing with a twist at the bottom and you will make hand over fist with this great formula! Would recommend to a friend with the disclaimer that it is not cost effective at all.
Great product if you could get product out
nicolehidblan from Louisiana
I loved this product although the horrible twist up makes it impossible to get the product out. I'm a loyal L'Oréal customer but this purchase was a total waste!
Love these pencils!!
Laulau from Dedham, MA
I bought bronze, brown, black, charcoal shimmer and aubergine! These are fabulous! Also, I use a Trish McEvoy sharpener on them, works fantastic! I use a primer because I am oily....and these last soooooo good!!! All day! I'm happy because of the money I save buying drugstore especially when the product is so good!!!
I have no new favorite
Bugb from Troy mi
Does not advance with more liner! Lasted a little over a week . Will not be buying again .
Kate from Ohio
Love this product and the price! I was nervous about it being a pencil but it does not tug the skin at all! It is more of a gel pencil. Long lasting!
waste of money
LTBOW from rochester new york
this pencil could not be sharpened. A ridiculous amount of money for 3 weeks of use. I eventually cut it with a knife and it still couldn't get it to sharpen. will never buy again
Great product poor design
Angiebell from Crown point
Too expensive for a two week supply bought one thought is was faulty product. Purchased two more all are the same. Talked to one of my friends she had the same problem. Come on L'Oréal don't put a twist bottom on a pencil that you have to sharpen.
KT55 from Knoxville Tn
Eyeliner was long lasting and did not smudge but no way to advance the stick up. Lasted about 10 days then had to throw it away. After reading all the complaints about this product it should be pulled from the shelves. Big disappointment.
impossible to sharpen
Pam605490 from Boston
I would not buy again, it's impossible to sharpen. not happy with the product.