Rated 3.91 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Great liquid eyeliner, perfect for creating wings
I was very excited to receive this eyeliner when I ordered it during Ulta's 21 Days of Beauty with their $15 shipping minimum. It arrived three days earlier than it was initially predicted to and in pretty good shape. The felt tip is really great for creating precise lines and my wings were super sharp. I got a few compliments (I didn't see a lot of people given the whole quarantine situation, obviously), and they lasted for ~5 hours before it began crumbling.
The crumbling was limited to where I'd applied the liner along my eyelid; the wings stayed in good shape until I took it off a few hours later. Maybe I didn't apply it thick enough on my eyelid? The liner has a bit trouble with opacity and I had to layer it in some places to fill a few gaps.
Overall, I was pretty happy with it and I will probably buy it again. It's a decent liquid eyeliner with a great felt tip, decent color deposition and a fairly affordable price. If you're looking to try out liquid eyeliner for the first time but don't want to drop money on Fenty or KVD just yet, this is a great thing to try.
Most Helpful Critical Review After the first week, 5 stars. A month later, dunking
Feeling mixed about this, because I love Colourpop and all the vibrancy, especially since another brand killed my favorite orange liquid eyeliner. Initially this was a new potential favorite, minus the fact that I don't love the inflexibility of the nib--which is fine, I can get used to that.
BUT: I've not had these more than a month and they're drying out. Not sure I'll repurchase, because I've had Stila ones for much longer that still work for me.
I am adding a star because hopefully Colourpop will cause everyone else to up their game and get in on more hot-colored ink! Black, blue, and brown are not the only colors.
Reviewed by 247 customers Eh
Melody from Texas
Could be better. Good for the price. Sticky needs powder or black eyeshadow to set.
Mel from Houston
It goes on well but very sticky. Does not set alone you have to apply black eyeshadow on top or just regular setting powder.
Wonderful for my eyebrows
Jillian from Ohio
I have pink hair and this is perfect to use to fill on my eyebrows to match it.
Works perfect BUT dried out quickly
Mandy from Columbia, MO
I love Colourpop and was so excited to use their eyeliner, it was clean and slick, applied nicely on the eyelid.
I've only had it for a month and now it is drying out on me and not applying anymore. The tip is now sticky and doesn't allow any of the pigment on my lid at all. Was really excited and now just disappointed.
Would buy another one, but if it dries quickly again, I will stop purchasing.
Silvia from Los Angeles, CA
I bought "Try me" at an Ulta store, fell in love with it, the I ordered "Crzy", thinking that it was going to be like "Try Me", because this one looks like in the showed picture, but "Crazy" came reaaally darker that the color showed, I'm a little bit disappointed, maybe I'll try with "The Hills" next time.
makeupmomma from Ashland
I don't like this at all, it was easy to apply but it kept transferring into my upper lid. I'd wipe it off, and before you know it, I looked like I had put black liner under my brows. will not buy or recommended
Best Eyeliner Pen
Tay from Florence SC
I use this eyeliner pen everyday of my life! It's the smoothest application, it's never dried out, the finish is beautiful with makeup or without. I'm just obsessed! I think this is my 3rd one and I've gotten about 4-5 months of use out of each one!
A love hate relationship
Lynaea from Minnesota
I use this product daily! Although it smudges at the end of the day, this can easily be fixed with setting powder. This lasts me four months or so and is better than essence or elf.
anu from Medford
its pointy,easy to apply and stay really well...
Great liner...but dries up too fast.
Jalisa from Columbus, OH
This is a very good liner. It's pigmented and applies well but the downfall is that it dries up way too quick. When it does dry, the pigment becomes very flaky and it's hard to work with. For me personally, I would still keep it in my beauty bag just because it works so well when you first buy it.
Lasted all night!
Cori from Chicago, IN
I am a big colorpop fan and this liquid liner from them did not disappoint! I was nervous purchasing because I couldn't test it out (COVID) but I definitely will be buying again!
Pidge from South Carolina
This eyeliner is so amazing. I have the black,brown, and pink and I love them all. It's so good and for the price it's my go too. Definitely recommend more than Stila or Kvd beauty
Not my favorite.
Sara G from Virginia Beach
I wear eyeliner every day and usually I prefer a flexi tip with a handheld felt tip or bristles. This was not my fav. It was hard to use and draw wings outwards since it naturally drags your skin with it. I was able to get my wings drawn on and it looked good throughout the day,but would not buy again. Personal preference.
Bre from PA
I really wanted to like this liner.. it went on great, smudge proof, and very pigmented. But after a few hours went by I did notice it would transfer to my eyelids. And im wiping off like every 20 min after that. Idk if i have oily eyelids or what, but i never had this be an issue with other liners.
Not worth full price
D from Westminster, CO
Line fades and disappears in a couple of hours
The best liquid liner I've tried
Kate from Oregon
I am a restaurant manager who oftentimes finds herself in the kitchen either cooking, prepping, or washing dishes. Sometimes my days can be stressful and I shed a tear or two but this liner stays THRU IT ALL! I come home and my wing is still sharp enough to cut anyone who decides to cross me.
Best white liquid liner!
Mara from Los Angeles
I don't understand the low reviews here, that wasn't my experience. I've tried every white liquid liner out there, and they all crumble and dry up on the skin and crack even with a thin layer. Until I tried the BFF Liquid Liner in Graceland! It glides on smoothly and with plenty of pigmentation, and you can easily layer it to get an even more opaque white and it still doesn't crack! I love using it with colorful eyeshadows to give an extra fun touch and add a graphic element to my look. The green shade, The Hills, is also great and really truly pigmented, and is perfect for a 60's graphic liner eye look. Overall love these and definitely want to try more colors!
it was okay
j from california
it dried out on me in 3 months suddenly... not the best eyeliner but the color payoff is nice. does flake like others have said
I want them all!
Mal from San Antonio, TX
Love it! I have a green shade and it last all day, is bright and gorgeous and soooo easy to put on. Literally takes less than 30 seconds for both eyes and I AM NOT an experienced liner person. I want them all!
yoyo ma from NorCal
I dunno what's up with other people's liners but I have all the colors aside from black and they've all been great for more avant garde and editorial looks. My gripe with them is that they're felt tips and not brush tips. I haven't had issues with bleeding, smudging, or eyeshadow bleeding into the liner. I store 'em on their side and only store them upright if I'm planning a look with that specific shade. Honestly one of the better colored liquid liners I've found. All the other ones I've tried have been too watery, sheer, and dried funny, but these ones work pretty well for what I want.
Kat from Portland OR
I regret buying this
Very difficult to use
Cyndi from Las Vegas
Yeah good luck trying to do any graphic liner over your colored eyeshadow. Also it drys really fast and crumbles, and mine dried out after one use. I'm so disappointed.
Linda from Plano
I swear every positive review is a LIE. No way this horrible eyeliner actually works for people
How does anyone like this?
Nikki from Fayetteville
I looove pen eyeliner and this one has a great tip but omg this doesn't even last 5 minutes. Literally transferred all the way to my eyebrow. First time wearing this I went out with friends and one of them told me to go to the bathroom to check my eyeliner. Boy was I shocked how gross my eyes looked. Funny how it transferred so easy but was near impossible to wipe off my lids and brow bone.
Mommy1030 from Azusa, CA
I was excited to use this eyeliner . I love the label it has very fun ! I have used other colour pop products but , won't be buying this one again . The eyeliner smudges after using it for an hour. I do have a bit of oily eye lids. Maybe that can be the case why it's not compatible .