Product Reviews Rated 4.52 out of 5 stars
3587 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Amazing And Easy I received a sample of the Loreal INFALLIBLE Flash Cat Eye Waterproof Brush Tip Liquid Eyeliner, Black, from Viewpoints for my honest feedback. I've been wearing eyeliner since the 7th grade, Im now going on 32, I'm not very artistic to making the eye cat look. Everyone is doing the cat eye nowadays its extremely popular, but I can never get mine to turn out right. Thanks to this product I can do it in seconds and it always looks perfect. The most important thing to know about the eyeliner is that the stencil slides up and needs to be detached from the cap, an easy-to-use removable wing stencil, super convenient. I did learn that the hard way. I have never used Liquid Eyeliner before this mission. I have always used the twist up stick or a regular eyeliner pencil. The waterproof liquid brush tip eyeliner has a precision tip, it really does helps achieve wings in a flash, glides on super easy. Flash Cat Eye has a waterproof formula, the eyeliner never smudged or faded. I love wearing my eyeliner underneath my eye-shadow. The pigment is strong enough to push through my eye-shadow color. I used this while I was in my pool and enduring the extreme heat we are having that results in a lot of sweating. I am completely satisfied with how it holds up, it's 100% waterproof. I love that it gives me confidence every time I wear it. Absolutely love it! I will become a returning customer and I definitely recommend.
Most Helpful Critical Review Not for my eye shape I was super excited to try this L'Oréal Infallible Flash Cat Eye Waterproof Brush Tip Liquid Eyeliner. I have hooded eyes, and I struggle to do winged liner. I thought that the stencil would really help. Unfortunately this stencil just would not work for me. I could not get it to lie flat on my skin close enough to my eye. I tried multiple angles, but it never would work. The actual eyeliner is pretty good. It's nice and pigmented and glides on smoothly without feathering or smudging. It stays put well, and is actually a little difficult to remove. I will continue to use the liner, but the stencil was a fail for me.
Reviewed by 3587 customers Great for hooded eyes! 5
AmyDinoGirl from Santa Clarita, CA
I have hooded eyes and can't draw a wing to save my life. This works amazingly well, and the liner lasts all day, even on my oily lids. I'll absolutely buy it again.
Hooded Eyelids 5
AngelEyes from Las Vegas
Worked great for me. I can't do a cat eye look to save my life. But this product made it so easy.
Ultimate favorite 5
Liz from Wayne, NJ
This eyeliner has the best tip for making thin lines to thick lines. It glides on and dries fast. The stencil on the cap is removable and easy to use. I can go from a day look to a night look using the same eyeliner. The rich black color never smudges and stays put until I take it off with makeup remover. I have been using this eyeliner for years and don't intend on using any other kind.
Love this eyeliner! 5
Laura Mae from Los Angeles, CA
I love this product. It doesn't bleed like a lot of other eyeliners I've used and is great for a slight hood I have on one eye. Builds really well and makes a good fine point for winged eyeliner. Is waterproof so it doesn't budge which is amazing but can be a little annoying to remove if you make a mistake. Highly recommend!
No 1
Mom38 from Tennessee
The eyeliner wasn't that great and the stencil is ridiculous
Works on watery eyes 5
WateryEyeball from Dfw
My right eye gets so watery it's hard for any eye liner to stay on I can't even wear lash strips bc my eye waters so much the adhesive ends up coming off. However this eye liner does not budge. Super pigmented the only complaint I have is that when stored upside down it leaks but that's user error. It's so easy to use I never used the stencil though
Dry 2
Lo from Memphis,TN
Very dry
Don't understand the hype 3
Overhyped from Florida
The tip is bristles … it frays after a few uses. I don't understand the hype. The product tends to run, it's not super black, you find yourself going back over it multiple times. Just not that great of a product.
Absolutely love it except… 4
GrandmaShorty from Kelso, Wa
I love it, very pigmented and the stencil is a great help because I'm horrible at doing my makeup, but I feel like I'm going to remove my eyelids trying to remove it even using coconut oil which I use for the rest of my makeup.
HORRIBLE SMUDGE 3
Kait from Salt Lake City
Seriously bad upper eye smudging despite primer and concealer. Highly disappointed.
Pretty Good 4
Arianna from Murrieta
Honestly it has a really nice application and gets good little details done well. It has a perfect pigmentation cuz its not horribly dark but its still black. The only two complaints I have about it is that its not waterproof and the tip started to split after quite a few uses. It didn't dry up too fast so thats good ig. Overall its pretty good and I would recommend.
Smudges BAD 2
Mads from Michigan
After only a few hours, my wing will smudge all over my eyelid. Really disappointed because the pigment and the glide of the application was great.
Not waterproof 2
Elle from California
Definitely not waterproof. I used it several times and each time It got on my upper eyelid.
Felt tip always gets messed up 1
Cuddley from Beverly Hills Ca
At first this eye liner allows you to make fine lines or rich thick lines But after a while the tip starts to get messed up and I bought this two separate times and the same thing happened. The tip becomes undone and I think it's so unfortunate because the formula is long wearing and very matte which I like
Long lasting 4
Sahar from Nj
This eyeliner is very good it is long lasting
Price is good
not waterproof 4
SkrippaStories from New Orleans
So, first of all, I actually really like this liner. The brush is great, and the formula itself sits really well. The only thing is, is it's *not* waterproof. My eyes are pretty watery from seasonal allergies, and I have to be careful not to put this on spots that will get runoff from my eyes, or it bleeds everywhere.
Love this eyeliner, BUT 4
Sunni from Houston
This is the best eyeliner I've used in a long time; it doesn't smudge and after some practice, I've gotten great at the winged look. However, as other reviews have mentioned, after a few weeks of use, all of a sudden a large amount of the liquid will start to come out (right under the brush, there's a little hole) during use, getting in my lashes and on my fingers. So frustrating when this happens. If they would fix this packaging flaw, this product would be the best eyeliner on the marker. That being said, I love it so much that I keep buying it and just replace it once it starts coming out.
All day wear 5
KNM from Okeechobee florida
Great product! Love the built in guide!!
Waste of my money, horrible eye liner 1
Lily from Virginia Beach, Virginia
I looked at the reviews for this and a lot of ppl said this was rlly good and I went to my local RiteAid and bought this in brown. When I first tried it out, it was pretty good but after 3 days of using it (a total of 3 times, once each day) it started to get dry. After a week of having and using it, it was rlly dry and I had to layer it for it to show up. When I tried to layer it, it removed what was there and was balling up. Then the tip started to bend and break. The only thing a like about this is the stencil bc it's actually rlly helpful for me. I was rlly hoping that this would be a good liner for me but sadly I was wrong, I guess I'll have to continue searching for a good liner. Save your money on this, sadly I have wanted my money on this. I would recommend you save your money on this rather then wasting it on this like me.
So far so good 5
L Hunt from 71653
I've used it once and it worked very well for me BUT I don't recommend using the stencil on the side if you like a thinner wing. Others have said it hasn't lasted a month but I guess I find out soon
Confused why so many good reviews 1
Rose from Newport
I put on just to try it out, I haven't applied liquid eyeliner in forever. It didn't last two hours on my face and I was just sitting on the couch. I got up to go the bathroom and it was gone. The wing had faded almost completely and the line was barely even there
great liquid eyeliner 5
A from Croatia
PROS:
+ easy to apply
+ does not smudge
+ intense shade of black
+ suitable for watery and sensitive eyes
+ I don't cry very often - but when I'm out and it rains, never smudged on my eyelids :-D
CONS:
+ plastic drawing attachment useful only for beginners, otherwise it just confuses and you certainly can't get that sharp end that looks nice (I can't actually put this claim here 100 % because for some people it might be useful, who knows) - to me it's great for precise application of eyeshadow along the edges, so it has some purpose but don't expect miracles
Compared to Too Faced Better than sex liquid eyeliner, Maybelline pen eyeliners (tried them all), Rimmel liquid eyeliners, Benefit eyeliners etc. - this is the best one so far. I think it's suitable for sensitive eyes since I experienced very bad reactions - usually with drugstore brands and felt that "burning" sensation on my eyelids when I applied some cheaper eyeliners just to try them out. This one is a safe bet in my opinion. ;-)
fav 5
alex from wa
literally my favourite eyeliner
It actually does work 5
Carina from Reno NV
I can't do the cat eye look on my right eye without Messing it up but this product actually helped! Worked really well
Disappointing 1
LTMNSD from Minneapolis, MN
I am a KVD & Stila user and thought I'd try to find a different cost-conscious option. It was great the first few applications, but then, I somehow bent the bristles. I didn't know that could happen with eyeliner, but it did. It is a bristle brush applicator. Then, it stopped working altogether after than less than a month of use.