Rated 4.61 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review HOLY GRAIL
All I have to say is that if there is one thing I know - it's eyebrows. I've been obsessed with brows for like over ten years. This product is hands down, the absolute BEST eyebrow product I have ever used. The formula is light years ahead of the ABH Brow Definer. It is highly pigmented but also buildable, which is incredible. It made my light blonde, thin/sparse brows look full, defined, and perfect (in combo with Gimme Brow) and took me less than five minutes. I received this as a Platinum Perk (Thank you Benefit & Ulta, you are so good to me!) and I will be in line when Ulta opens on June 24th to purchase another one.
Most Helpful Critical Review Not what I expected!
Love how the wand makes it easy to apply but I felt the product too creamy which made my eyebrows look very oily by the end of the day.
Reviewed by 11006 customers Finally have brows
zelda from Waltham Vermont
Spent the extra money and am glad I did. Pencils are too rough. My brows are gray, and this makes me have brows. Creamy and goes on smooth great color, Great auburn color.
MJ from Asheville NC
Absolutely the best eyebrow pencil I have ever used. Thin and precise lines
It's a good brow pencil.
LS from FL, USA
This is a nice thin pencil that allows for precision, and I chose a better matching shade than I usually go for. The color also doesn't seem to totally wipe away when I put the Benefit clear brow setting/laminating gel on top - something I have found to happen with other brow pencils and gels. (Admittedly, Benefit's brow gel isn't in clear packaging, so I can't see if it's getting a bit cloudy. I do see the shape/color that remains on my brows, though.) I'm not sure it's worth the full price, I was glad to try it via the bogo mini sale. I do like and find it works better/better with brow gel than several drugstore pencils I've tried before, but you can find something that works if you want to/can't afford this. If you can and feel like paying for this, I'd say go for it. I'll consider repurchasing sometime.
easy to apply
mary from Oshkosh wi
At last, a gray brow pencil that is really gray. However, it's still darker than I would like. My brows are gray and white. My hair is white (74). My brows look darker than I want them to even though I use very light strokes. It's better than taupe though. It's not too soft. Well made.
SMOOTH and SASSY
GG from GA
Goes on so well, defines, stays on and looks natural. Love it!
I would not purchase this item again. I returned it
Beau from Colorado Springs
I got the same results using a wet and wild eyebrow pencil. Too expensive and poor results.
This is a must-have!
AC from MO
I love this fine line pencil!! I got it one as a sample a few years ago and I cannot do without it now...it blends beautifully where I need a little a little fill in and looks natural - not like "drawn on eyebrows". There is a lot of product in this easy twist pencil and will last you a long time!
Suze from NJ
Was good but not great. The NYX Pencil is much better and cheaper!
RH from Miami
This is one of my favorite brow pencils. I have very thin and light brows (hello nineties tweezers!) and don't want to do micro blading. I like to use this: the tip is very fine and looks natural. It is very touch-proof. I use 2.5 neutral blonde, good neutral color (light). One thing I don't like: it uses up very fast (seems not to have too much product in it).
Judy from Magalia, Ca
I went into ULTA to check out this eyebrow pencil. I had to try this on my own, it made perfect thin lines the beginning of brow and the flat part fill in. I have always used Benefit Precisely my brow pencil but wasn't getting the fine lines I needed. I finally tried the Goof Proof waterproof easy shape & fill eyebrow pencil in the store. Love it. Try it. I need to finish up the Precisely pencil. Try it
Definitely a repeat purchase!
Vale from Okc,Ok
Absolutely love this pencil, used to use ABH brow wiz but I noticed because it was so dry/waxy it was pulling out many brow hair every application. Switched to this and love how it's just creamy enough but not so creamy that it comes off so easily with my oily skin. Still set it the clear brow gel and my brows last all day.
Rae from Bismarck
I like the thicker tip. too thin brows look drawn on
My favorite brow pencil
Anon from Chicago
I've used this pencil a few years now and I can't find one that compares. The design is great and the brow brush is my favorite part. The color stays all day and applies easily. I love that the caps are different for the pencil and the brush unlike Anastasia's pencil. I highly recommend this pencil!
My favorite pencil because the shade is perfect!
Diana from Virginia
This pencil is great, I received it in an Ipsy bag and had to order another one because I don't want to use anything else for my brows. The neutral medium brown shade is a perfect match for me, usually I can never find a brown that's just right but this one is it.
My favorite brown pencil
Primp from Nc
Best brow pencil ever
I like it, but...
rmalva from Bryan, TX
I like that I have better control when filling in my eyebrows, but there isn't a lot of product for the money. I also don't think it's waterproof as stated by the brand (it smudged); it is very hard to find an eyebrow product that is truly waterproof and long wear, at least in my experience.
Quick and Easy
DC Blue from DMV
Quick brow fill in and shaping
Joan from Northville MI
I have been using for years! With sparse brows I rarely use the brush on opposite end 😆. Very natural and easy to achieve 👍🏻
This color has alot if grey in it
Frankie from Carrollton ga
This color is too grey looking. It doesn't look brown at all.
The best eye pencil. A must have .
Lexy from Brooklyn
This is a great eye pencil. A bit expensive but it's worth it .
Alexis from SD
Thee best brow pencil ever! Seriously can't find one better than this one.
Best Eyebrow Pencil!
Hannah from NV
I love this eyebrow pencil! I've tried a handful of different brands from drugstore to high end, and this is the best! It goes on easily, but can be applied harder for a more defined brow! Can't recommend enough!
My go-to brow product
Bri from Pennsylvania
I have very sparse and very light brows so I basically need to draw them on. This product is the easiest to use and the best out of all the ones i've tried! Even color, buildable, blendable, and lasts all day. Holy grail of brow pencils!
Easy to appy!
Kim from Huntington
I love how it is so easy to apply on eyebrows, it's really precise and I don't have to spend too much time on putting my eyebrow makeup! Thank you!
Easy Eyebrow Pencil
Elizabeth from Connecticut
I use it daily as part of my makeup routine