Rated 4.65 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review HIT BY A CAR... BROWS STILL ON FLEEK.
I was hit by a car while out on a run. I walked away with multiple broken bones a broken nose blood everywhere annnd perfect eyebrows. if you are considering getting this product BUY IT. - @chloeoliviamusic
Most Helpful Critical Review Serious Quality Issues
I am writing to you as a loyal customer of your Anastasia Brow Wizard. I have loved this product for many years and have faithfully spent my money purchasing it. However about a year ago or a little over, you changed the plastic you use to make this product. You lengthened the brush side to match the pencil so the user cannot easily tell which end is the brush and which is pencil. I understand that was probably more cost effective. But the worst result of your "cost cutting" is that the brush piece now breaks off after only a few uses. I have now bought 5 new brow wizards and every single one has this problem. You have a quality control issue and I wish you would correct it. I will no longer purchase Anastasia products and I will leave this review on every makeup site where I have purchased your brow wizard until you correct this quality problem. That makeup product is not inexpensive and your customers deserve better.
Reviewed by 18524 customers Terrific brow pencil
Val D from Mission Viejo
Great eyebrow pencil. Goes on smoothly. Self sharpening, no need for sharpener. Highly recommend.
great color choices
prys from chicago
I love the color choices from Anastasia. I can dye my hair and find a color that can compliment it anytime. also its great for more control on your brows especially for those with sparse light brows.
Good color long wearing
Fairanna from Savannah
I love the color blonde it is perfect not too light and dark enough to accent my brows. This product is long wearing and smudge proof. A must have I. Your makeup kit!
Annette from Oklahoma City, Ok
This was my first time purchasing this product after trying a variety of brands- benefit, nyx, maybelline (honestly one of the best), revlon, and elf (also one of the best). I had such high hopes but was SO disappointed after using it several times. The taupe color however is a perfect match for my dark ashy blonde brows. I will give it that.
Unfortunately, the formula itself, is incredibly dry. I have to press hard to get any color. I'm used to a brow pencil that goes on much smooth and blends well with a brush or spooly. I feel as if I have to used twice as much product to completely fill my brows in. Wearability is good in that I'm not worried it will smear.
Overall it did not meet my expectations and I will return to my tried and true brow pencils that are well under $10.
Favorite brow product
Olivia from Missouri
I love how it is very buildable. I don't like dramatic brows and this is my favorite thing I've tried.
Catlady555 from NJ
I have been using Brow Wiz for several years and I really like it. I've tried many other brands in the past but this is the best. It's easy to use so you don't end up with funky-shaped brows and the Blonde color is perfect for me.
Key🎀 from Tyler, TX
Love this product! I've tried other brow pencils but this ones the best!
Not worth the hype
Ctorres2 from Algonquin
Purchased based on the reviews and seeing it's a fan favorite. Honestly, for the price i should've went with a basic pencil brow. Don't recommend at all. The pomade is better.
That's how a product should perform!
lala from buffalo, ny
Ive never left a review for a product before, ever. But I feel I have to comment on this in case there is someone, like me who is thinking about trying this for the first time. This is how a higher-end product ought to perform. first of all Ive never had an eyebrow product be a true match to my eyebrow color. this is a dead-on match. I have in it ebony. This just does everything you want it to do without having to force anything which is the BEST thing ever bc so many products dont! I'm obsessed and will be repurchasing
Have bought in the past and will buy again
Cyndylou from Acworth Ga
Finally they make a color that is just what I was looking for. I have a light golden brown haircolor and the new Strawburn is the perfect shade for me.
I will buy this product in this color again and again!
Brow Now from Aberdeen, MD
I have used Anastasia brow products for years and they are fantastic! Brow Wiz is my favorite. It is easy to handle and you have great control. I have super sparse brows and Brow Wiz allows me to create quick brows ie. darting to the stores, and facilitates the creations of full dramatic brows for nights out with the husband. I usually order dark brown but it was sold out and I ordered Granite instead...Wow...this is now my go to color. It is perfect!
Has broken twice the last two times I have gotten it
Liv from Michigan
The product part either comes lose and falls or the twist doesn't work to bring more product up
Makes a Beginner Look Like a Pro
Mom3shell from Whittier, Ca
Really easy to use, makes my sparse in areas brows look great.
The Tried and True Best Go-To
Carolyn from Boston
I have been using this brow pencil for over 15 years, when it first arrived on the market. I have used many other brow products (dips, creams, mascara-like wand products), but I always come back to this one due to its simplicity, and the granite shade that perfectly matches my black brows. I can fill in my sparse brows and perfect my arch in under 30 seconds. I have fewer brow hairs now in my early 40s, after being a 90s over-plucker, this pencil is my holy grail. The best part is that I do not have to sharpen it, the twist-up feature saves so much time and is much cleaner than other pencils. I accidentally bought Anastasia's other brow pencil which requires a sharpener and while it works great, I don't have extra time for sharpening in my day. Only con is that with daily use, I buy 5 of these per year, which adds up. Darn you 90210 for making me think thin brows were cool as a teenager! ;)
Preezy from Savannah
This product doesn't need any more praise but I've tried most pencils out there and this is the most natural and long lasting pencil out there. Must buy.
Best brow crayon/pencil!
Aki from Arizona
Great product! I use it with the Anastasia brow gel and get perfect brows :)
Nice but too expensive
Bird from Dallas
Cant trust that it's not broken
Jaymari from California
Ordered this online. I love all how ABH has a variety of colors and shades for all their makeup but this particular product can be problematic. It's so thin that you never know if the product is broken. I opened the product and the whole crayon popped out of the component. During the pandemic, I really don't want to be having to drive to the Ulta store to exchange. Product is basically rendered useless.
Very nice product
Lisa from TX
Holy Grail Alert: Makes the most beautiful, hair-like strokes. I wondered what all the fuss was about, so I took the plunge. Now I know - and yes, it was worth it.
I always use this product
Mel from Palm Beach, FL
I like two colors taupe and the medium brown. Excellent eyebrow pencil. Fills in bare spots too.
It's good if you have the money.
s from NC
It's really good and blends like a dream but not worth the price.
Alexia from Huntsville
The thin applicator is my favorite! Does not make brows look heavy and it's great to touch up sparse areas. The formula does not move either. Recently I have switched to a much more inexpensive dupe that is extremely similar... But if it's worth the money to you, it's a good product!
No I wouldn't buy it again
Ang from MD
If you have thin eyebrows, it takes a lot to fill in and then I would have to go over spots a few times and still would look like it was missing color. This is the worst eyebrow stuff I've ever tried and used.
TWeb from Kabsas
Makes my brows look very natural
Must have been a bad batch
K Bell from Purvis MS
Never purchased it before but it had good reviews. Took a long time to receive it after ordering. When I twisted it to come out nothing came out. After a while I got something to come out and as I tried to use it it crumbled into tiny pieces. I clearly got a bad batch.