Product Reviews Rated 4.77 out of 5 stars
606 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review A great buy! I bought this set at the same time as the Spongebob Makeup Eraser set. I waited a few days to get both sets in to be able to use them side by side to compare. I washed both sets in the laundry first as instructed, did my makeup, and used each type on one half of my face. The Garnier pad was not only softer, but it was also easier to work with and took product off better, faster, and with less pulling and tugging. After cleaning off my makeup and washing my face, I put on the Peter Thomas Roth 24k gold face mask. Anyone who has ever used that mask knows what I mean when I say it is almost impossible to get off all of the gold flakes and sparkles. I again used one on each side to wash it off. Garnier for sure got more of the sparkles off. For 3 of these makeup pads at this price, it's awesome. However, if you have dry skin, I would definitely recommend using a moisturizer with this product because my skin did feel a little stripped of moisture. I would almost certainly recommend getting this over the Makeup Eraser, but don't forget to wash it right out of the package and to moisturize afterwards!
Most Helpful Critical Review I love makeup remover cloths but just not this one I was very skeptical of makeup remover cloths that only need water. I found this on sale and picked it up along with some micellar water. The cloths definitely remove makeup wonderfully and absolutely do not need the micellar water. Garnier is just trying to make a little extra cash by getting you to purchase two products (the cloth and the water) instead of just the cloth. I won't be purchasing these Garnier cloths again though. The two sides of the cloth are separate pieces of fabric that are only sewn together around the outside edge so they slide around on top of each other while I use it making the cloth incredibly difficult to maneuver. I end up folding it into a tiny ball which is still unwieldy but better than trying to use it flat. I will 100% buy another brand and use a makeup cloth daily. I do not recommend this brand.
Reviewed by 606 customers They work 5
Ari0 from La
Takes makeup off.
Removes waterproof eye makeup 5
Rae from Seattle
My first time buying this, but it's great so far it removes all my stubborn eye makeup.
So glad I bought this! 5
Walker37 from Indiana
I use this with Garnier Micellar Water to remove my makeup, and I love it. The reusable pad is very soft against my skin and doesn't irritate it. I'm able to get all of my makeup off very easily. I'd recommend these to anyone.
Great Product 5
Emily from Washington
I like that these are reusable and that you can just throw them in your washing machine. They get my makeup off nicely. After time they can get stained if left alone for long, but I wear lots of black makeup so it did get stained.
love this product 5
jordan from ms
takes my makeup off with ease and doesn't irritate the skin
Would buy again! Less consumption, hope to save planet 4
Juliete has a gun from IL USA
Product is great. Long time wanted to try reusable make up removal pads. Those are big, soft, many (3). Satisfied about my purchase. Thought mascara stains remains. But again, less cinsumption, less garbage, if it helps to save the planet, I will buy it again :)
I love makeup remover cloths but just not this one 2
Shannen from California
I was very skeptical of makeup remover cloths that only need water. I found this on sale and picked it up along with some micellar water. The cloths definitely remove makeup wonderfully and absolutely do not need the micellar water. Garnier is just trying to make a little extra cash by getting you to purchase two products (the cloth and the water) instead of just the cloth. I won't be purchasing these Garnier cloths again though. The two sides of the cloth are separate pieces of fabric that are only sewn together around the outside edge so they slide around on top of each other while I use it making the cloth incredibly difficult to maneuver. I end up folding it into a tiny ball which is still unwieldy but better than trying to use it flat. I will 100% buy another brand and use a makeup cloth daily. I do not recommend this brand.
Amazing quality and great price! 5
Reggieboo from CA
I use these to take off makeup usually with micellar water or after using makeup melting balms or oils. They are way better than makeup wipes because they don't strip the skin, and they are more environmentally responsible!
Love!! 5
madi from Alabama
These are so gentle. Works so well with the Micellar Water to get my makeup off. Will be buying more!
Everyone should have these! 5
Riley from Arizona
These are so so SO soft on the skin, they melt away makeup with the micellear water, it's so simple to just clean with soap and water after you use them right before you wash your face, surprisingly durable, makeup washes off of it really easy so it doesn't stain (even mascara!)
Absolutely Amazing 5
Bex from CT
These surpassed my expectations. I use them as a replacement for makeup wipes, and to help take off my eye makeup, and as a substitute for cotton rounds. They are softer than any other cotton substitute I've used. They're absorbent enough, but not so absorbent that you end up wasting cleanser. They're also easy to clean. despite the fact I've had them for several months and they've taken off my mascara almost every day, they still look beautiful and have held up well through multiple trips through the washing machine. These are just perfect! They are a staple in my skin care routine now.
Love it! 5
Hannah from Rochester
I'm using these as a replacement of standard makeup wipes. I like that I can reuse these. I quickly wash one every time I use it (which is daily). it's usually dry by the next day, so I don't have to worry about a soggy pad! the makeup I use does stain it, but it's not a big deal to me.
Magic! 5
Megan from San Diego
These reusable rounds are my new favorite item. I have bought reusable rounds before, but they lost their softness quickly and tend to feel rough on my skin. These Garnier rounds are so gentle and they really get the job done! I'm going to buy more!
SkinActive Micellar Cleansing Eco Pads 5
LC4508 from FL
I love these pads! I now, no longer need to continue to purchase the cotton pads as I have in the past to use with my micellar water. These pads are easy to clean and soft to the touch. They are not harsh or scratch the face. Truly a great purchase (that I never thought I needed).
Perfect 4
Renee from San Pedro, CA
I loved the sizing it was just right
Gets job done but bad quality 2
Molly from Michigan
This gets the job done, but these pads are not seen together in the middle making them feel cheap and hard to use. There are definitely better reusable pads, but these are good enough.
Great! 5
Allison from Illinois
Does a great job at removing the makeup and easy to clean
Underwhelmed and a little disappointed 2
Marissa M. from Hixson, TN
After reading 5-star review after 5-star review, I was really excited about these. I feel like I go through the disposable cotton rounds really quickly, so I was excited to find something more sustainable. Personally I have found these difficult to use. One side is pink, the other white, and the two layers are sewn together around the edges, only around the edges. The two layers slide around in the middle since they're only sewn together around the edges and I found it difficult to cleanse well. I'd saturate the pad with micellar water and go to wipe my face and have difficulty getting the pad to move like I wanted because the two layers just slid around on top of each other. I would end up having to fold the pad and try to rub that way and it wasted the water.
I'll continue trying to use them for the next few days and see how I feel about them, but I'm just not thrilled so far. I also feel like they take way more micellar water to saturate then because they're so absorbent and it makes it seem as though I'm wasting water or going through it too quickly.
Overall it simply didn't live up to the 5 star hype that it seemed to have gained.
Easy to use 5
Megan from Indiana
This is a great product. Washing it after every use gets annoying, but the makeup always washes out. Very impressed by the quality for that low of a price.
Stain Easy but worth it 4
Gabi from Orange County
These are awesome! After a month of usage, they definitely have their stains, but it's not like anyone else sees these, so they're totally worth it to me!
Super soft and reusable! 5
Nezuko from Yuma Arizona
I highly recommend these. Comes with 3 cloth pads that are white on one side and pink on the other. They are perfect for micellar water or whatever else.
Love!! 5
Ang. from Anchorage, Ak
Say goodbye to wasting so much cotton pads and money on them!! I love these eco pads & you don't need that much micellar water as you would with using a bunch of cotton pads. Also another plus is that it's super soft so you don't have to tug so much on your face. Of course these do stain a little but that's not really a problem for me.
Great at removing makeup 4
Coachey from Virginia
I like how compact this is and that it's reusable. I noticed that I didn't have to use as much micelles water as I would have using a cotton pad. I don't like that even after cleaning with soap they stain pretty bad, although I wouldn't think it to be that much of an issue.
Must Have! 5
Shirley from Chicago, IL
I've been using cotton rounds for several years, and I got tired of purchasing to replenish so often since I use at least 3 pads a day (2 for eyes, 1 for face). I use Garnier Micellar Water to remove my eye and face makeup, and I'm so happy I purchased these! They're so soft and gentle on my skin, and they effectively remove makeup without harsh rubbing or having cotton fuzzies left all over my face and lashes like the disposable cotton rounds did. These also work perfectly to remove stubborn waterproof mascara. I would like to see these come in smaller sizes too, but it's nice you can use one large round for your whole face. Only con is having to wash after every use... or at least I do.
Garnier resizable cotton pads 5
Blackbarbei from Atlanta
Recently purchased them and they have are such a good size. Very soft and look forward to using them at then end of the day.