Product Reviews Rated 4.39 out of 5 stars
8598 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review I love you, mascara I tried Bad gal and it was immediately a definite no go. I was then recommended this little baby, and OH YES! A must have from now on. It does give me a little curl, but not to the point where I don't use an eyelash curler. Length and volume is perfect!
Most Helpful Critical Review not bad So let me start by saying I have long but stick straight lashes and if i want curl, it'll be me and my eyelash curler in front of the mirror for half an hour. I have used every mascara invented and finally gave up and got extensions. I am currently taking a break from them to give my eyelashes a rest so I've had to go back to mascara. I was glad to hear Benefit came out with rollerlash and it was the first thing I bought after removing my extensions. Curling is the best I've seen...but that's not saying much, just look at the pic. But it is the best I've used without an eyelash curler. As far as clumping, it's awesome. I didn't need to use anything to separate my lashes which is usually a problem.
Reviewed by 8598 customers Fav mascara for YEARS 5
Nb from Midwest
I've been using this mascara for the last 5 years. Not much has compared… besides maybe the Bobbi brown one. I tried but was way pricier
Mascara 5
Mascara from TX
I love, the way the brush is shapes
Returned 2
CheeryCherry from Nowhere
It separates nicely and curls but it is not water resistant. It left streaks down my cheeks after crying. The reason I bought this mascara is because I thought it wouldn't do that. MAC's Extended Play mascara separates and lifts better than this so I'll stick to that one and still hunt for a good mascara that doesn't run.
I would never buy this mascara again! 1
Kiki from Santa rosa
This mascara was horrible and didn't keep my lashes curled. When I first applied it my lashes went down. If you have long and straight lashes that aren't easy to stay up curled then I wouldn't recommend this for you!
Disappointed 3
Amu from Texas
I didn't notice great added volume or any lift. I also despised the wand. I still try it every once in awhile thinking I'll suddenly love something about it. But I just don't.
Elmers glue 1
Bailey from Maryland
I was excited to try this mascara because I've read and head so many good things. Unfortunately for me it is not my favorite. It does a good job lifting however i feel like this mascara never completely dries down. It makes my lashes feel sticky and it rubs off on my eyelids and lower lash line through the day. Not to mention it is so hard to wash off at the end of the day.
My favorite mascara, hands down! 5
Beth from Kansas
I have thin eyelashes and this product really makes the most of what I've got.
good mascara 4
Stacy from MN
the formula is fine and definitely lifts my lashes. I'm not a big fan of curves wands on general, so maybe it this was a straight applicator, I'd like it more.
New favorite mascara 5
Eden from Belmont, CA
Literally my new favorite mascara. It's so easy to apply, is pretty natural looking, and lasts all day. I even forgot to take it off before a shower once and didn't come out looking like a raccoon. Easy to remove too! The brush shape is perfection.
Not living up to the hype 3
Isa from North Dakota
I have long lashes and have issues with my lashes clumping so I thought I'd give this a try. I was disappointed as it requires many coats to even look like I have mascara on. It does keep my lashes separated really well but I won't be buying again. Glad it works for others!
Life Changing 5
Grace from Seattle WA
This is, hands down, THE BEST mascara i've ever used. I have naturally long lashes & this mascara adds just enough volume to make them look flawless. i get asked all the time if i'm wearing fake lashes, they're always surprised when i tell them no, it's just mascara…of course i have to put them on to this amazing product ☺️😇
Fantastic 5
Alex from US
Some of my eyelashes enjoy sticking together whenever I apply mascara to them, I end up having to use a lash comb to try and separate them. This mascara separates my lashes while still coating them in product, it's fantastic. Also feels lightweight and I experienced no flaking even after 11 hours of wear time, some of which was spent in upper 80 degree weather
Great Product! 5
KC from PA - Pennsylvania
I honestly love this! when i run out, will def buy in full size.
Might buy again 4
Galaxy21 from South Gate
Product delivers longer looking lashes but it doesn't dry well
Not bad! Not my fav! 3
Catie from NC
I like the they're real! from benefit, and will probably stick to it. This one does not go on as thick as I like, and it always comes off on the top brow bone and under my eyes. I have naturally long lashes so they touch the top of my brow, if that makes sense. I love the length it provides! I don't notice a lot of extra curl.
Love it ! 5
Love it from Georgia
I love this mascara and it looks amazing even why I have glasses on .
I've used it for a long time and will continue to. 5
TJ from Granbury, Texas
Always goes on smooth
Mechanical problem but great mascara 4
Gigi from Oregon
I love everything about this mascara except 3 of my wands broke off the cap when the mascara was still relatively new. First time I just thought it was a fluke, 2nd time assumed it was operator error, 3rd time realized it was poorly made.
Meh 3
Jrich719 from Texas
It's okay. I do not like it by itself one bit. It does absolutely nothing. If you want an extremely subtle look then it's good but I don't. I do love the brush though. So I use it to finish my lashes with.
Finally found my holy grail 5
Luna from Seattle WA
I was looking for a mascara that would become my daily staple for months before finally trying this one. I am officially on my second purchase because I ran through the first one so quickly !
Pros:
-Lengthens
-You don't get spider lashes, the bristles keep them nice and separated
-Lasts all day
Cons:
-Please be careful wearing water resistant mascara with a lash lift/tint , my lashes were falling out allot more than normal when I used the mascara during the first weeks of the lift/tint appointment.
Great length & curl, transfers to my concealer 3
JustVal from Chicago
Benefit mascaras are great, overall. I've tried They're Real! and might go back to it. Rollerball really lengthened and curled well, but after an hour or two would transfer to my It! Cosmetics concealer and settle into the fine lines under my eyes. I tried primer and/or setting powder over the concealer and neither worked.
Absolute Favorite Mascara 5
Cami from Pennsylvania
Favorite mascara ever! I have very short straight lashes and this mascara makes them look gorgeous!
Best Mascara Ever! 5
Bean from San Diego, CA
The first time I bought this, I did not have high hopes. I typically go for a volumizing mascara with a much thicker wand and hadn't had much luck with drugstore mascaras with a wand similar to Roller Lash. Boy howdy, was I pleasantly surprised! As soon as I tried it, I ran around my house making everyone else try it on too. After my first tube, I went back to drug store for a little bit but didn't even finish one tube before I broke down and bought another one of these bad boys. I'm now on my fifth one with a backup in my drawer and can't fathom what I'll do if Benefit ever decides to discontinue the blessed Roller Lash.
Don't have to use a lot for a stunning look 5
Tev from Fresno
I love this product because it literally takes 3 swipes and you're done boom your lashes look amazing. I'm the type of person to sit there with any mascara and do continuous coats until I achieve the look I want but this mascara is so easy and quick to get exactly what I want. I would definitely recommend this. Also no clumps at all and I've tried a lot of mascaras.
Perfect for small lashes 5
Girl with small lashes from Seattle, wa
This mascara is perfect for small lashes.
