Rated 4.16 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Favorite Eyeliner!!
Love love LOVE this eyeliner! Super pigmented and easy to use ! Reminds me of Kat Von D Tatoo liner except more affordable and in my opinion a little better!
Most Helpful Critical Review Not bad! A little liquidy...
I normally use Kat Von D Ink Liner, but I was out and low on money, so I bought this. It's a good product and stays on a long time, and does create great, precise lines. However, if you've got a shaky hand or are inexperienced with eyeliner, I probably wouldn't recommend it. It's super liquidy, and can easily get in your eye, and if you're not super careful, it can kind of get everywhere. It does this weird thing where it kind of flicks off my eyelashes and gets all over my face. If you're a makeup person and know how to use liquid liner, I'd recommend this, but if you're inexperienced, I'd try something else.
Reviewed by 2342 customers one of the better ones i've bought
huh from nc
i've cried multiple times wearing this eyeliner and it doesnt move. it's probably the best liquid eyeliner i've used, not streaky or anything like that. my only issue is that the current one i have is leaking a lot. i've never had that issue with other liners but it seems i'm not the only one who's having this problem with this specific liner
KimMUA from NYC
I decided to give this eyeliner a shot since I love nyx and my go-to liquid liner was always the nyx matte liquid liner. This one had good reviews and I prefer a pen-style applicator tip BUT I was sadly, sadly disappointed with this one. I have hooded eyes and this liner transferred to my top lid so much, even with primer/eyeshadow/setting powder/etc. Nothing works to keep it from transferring and the whole claim for this eyeliner pen was that "This smudge proof eye liner is waterproof, so it won't smear, budge or smudge" LIES, ALL LIES NYX!! I will stick to my matte liquid liner unless they adjust this formula.
Best Drugstore Liner
NR from Stafford VA
I fell in love with it all over again. I had it a few years back, ran out of it and started buying other brands to try out. Bought it again recently, and I am obsessed with it. It's super easy to use and precise. I have very oily lids, and watery eyes (especially when wearing contacts) and it did not budge! i sually have the liners run on me near the inner corner of the eye, sometimes even water proof ones. Definitely worth its price, and works better for me than some of the high end liners.
💕 from sf
It literally frays at the tip and it makes it impossible to use. It doesn't last for more than an hour and you need to do multiple layers for it to look right.
has my heart
lari from dtx
the best liquid liner i've ever used. it's really pigmented and i love the felt tip because it's easy to use. i recommend :P
For a beginner, I would reccomend
Ally Winsere from Manhattan, New York
I really like this product and am able to get precise pigmented lines. I would recommend this because it's a pretty good product ( the black colored eyeliner ) and it's at a really good price. I touch my face a lot but this stayed on 7+ hrs with minimal smudge.
Its love it
Sumaiya from Denver, CO
I love this product. I am hooked and buying again
I would recommend the eyeliner
Penny from Prattville AL
The best liquid eyeliner I've ever used it stays on a long time.
Bold color and goes on smoothly
Em from the midwest
I've had awful experiences with liquid eyeliners in the past, so I was a bit hesitant about buying this, however, I'm glad I decided to take the risk! It glides in sooo smoothly and the color is absolutely gorgeous. It's very resilient; I've worn it to work all day and have even cried with it on, but it doesn't smudge even in the slightest! Very easy to take off at the end of the day.
No liquid liner comes close
Sonia M from North Hollywood, CA
My go to look is a black wing and mascara with a red lip. I've tried a lot of black liquid liners and this is by far the best. I even did a test on the back of my hand of all my black liquid liners. After washing my hands with soap, this one still held up. The black is super opaque and there isn't any smudging under my eyes. (The only time I get under eye smudge is with non-waterproof mascara.) The felt tip is the perfect applicator. Smooth lines every time. I will say that after months of use, it does start to leak a little, so sometimes I need to use a tissue to clean up the felt tip. I've never ran out of ink with this, I usually replace it once the leaking gets really bad. But even at that point it's still 100% usable.
Allie from Elmhurst,Illinois
Don't waste your time. It literally melts off your eye in the heat. Becomes a sticky sweaty mess
Best waterproof - stayproof
SB from South carolina
Daily use. NO raccoon eye with this eyeliner. Better than the more expensive brand eyeliners
New favorite liner
Nic from Ohio
Used to only use kvd liner, but the last few times I had issues. I bought this and fell in love. Long wear and doesn't transfer
This is great for graphic liner!!!
Jynkx from Alabaster, AL
I used this for a lot of detailed eyeliner and it worked like an absolute dream
What I'm looking for
Kass from Pennsylvania
This is the perfect merge of KVD liner and Haus Labs liner at 1/3 the price
Jolie from FL
I loved this eyeliner when I first bought it. It's very pigmented and since it has a brush tip instead of the felt, I find it doesn't dry out as quickly. After a month of having them, both the brown and black started leaking a lot. I end up with a lot of ink on my hands after I use them.
Aski from 120 Weldon street
This is the best eyeliner ever 😳 I'm surprised by its quality. I promise you won't regret just go get it!!!!
V from Dallas,Tx
I bought this after seeing video of people trying it on and was very excited to try it on but I am kinda disappointed now that I got it. It said it was waterproof but it wasn't even after I let it dry for 5 mins. And if I rub it, it also came off
Loved this product before it frayed.
Laraby from San Diego, CA
The shape and application of this liner is perfect. I bought two on the same day and have only had them for a few weeks and both now have frayed tops. I'm not sure how to fix it or how it even happen because I'm very careful when closing and opening the cap. Would rate this 5 stars if that did not occur.
Keeri from Colorado Springs, CO
I was recommended this product by a friend who has impeccable cat eyes every single day, she said she only uses NYX so I thought I'd give it a try since my last liquid eyeliner was a flop as well. This liquid eyeliner is a hot mess! It leaks out of the sides of the felt tip and often spreads and leaves a horrible inky massacre around my eyes for me to clean up. I'm definitely no pro at makeup but I do at least know how to apply liquid eyeliner but after using this marker I definitely look like I've done my eyeliner in the dark or tried to apply it underwater! I'm cheap and will continue to use it until it dries out (who knows when that will be with all the excess eyeliner I get) but definitely am going to stick with what I know and like and stop being adventurous with products.
I would definitely buy again!
DJ from Austin, TX
This line creates a great cast eye look.
Not good for oily lids
Brianna from Ohio
I have oily lids and this transferred everywhere after only 2-4 hours. Do not recommend :(
easy to use
Susan B. from Miami
I've had this for 2 weeks and it's pretty good! my only tip would be to get the black color instead of brown i don't feel like it's pigmented enough
Not the best
Kate from Philadelphia
I got this thinking I could save money instead of buying the more expensive brand and it was good for the first few times I used it. It then started to leak and made it impossible to draw a nice line. I bought another one thinking this liner was defective but the same thing happened in both the black and brown liners. The only good thing was that it did stay on throughout the day but the leaking made me just have to splurge on the more expensive one.
good but leaks a lot its not a one time purchase issue
emily from tn
its good but trust me if i could upload photos it just starts leaking after a while and its just terrible when it starts to do that and when you first open it the pen is always dry trying to apply.. i've actually bought it several times and the same thing happens and i hate that because it leaks all over my fingers