Product Reviews Rated 3.86 out of 5 stars
135 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review I bought this a few... I bought this a few weeks ago and I can say I love this eyeliner. I have tried so many different ones even expensive brands and it just doesnt do the job like this one. I was in the pool for 3 hours, jumping in and out many times and swimming under water and this liner did not come off or smudge at all. I was honestly so surprised how it stayed for so long that I went to the store last weekend and purchased 3 more.
Most Helpful Critical Review Doesn't appeal to eyeliner or eyebrows Today I bought this product from a dollar tree in Vegas and I was greatly disappointed, because I tried to do my eyeliner and it didn't look like the color the pencil depicted. And I tried it as a eyebrow pencil and it still didn't look like the pigment that was shown on the bottom of the pencil.
Reviewed by 135 customers Worth it 5
Ayopppoopoocheck from nj
Makes me look dope or whateva
Love it. Great price! 5
Lynn from Greenville SC
Never go out without my eye makeup. Love the navy color.
Pretty good for the price 4
Erin F from Monrovia
I use this to tight line and line my eyes. It's pretty black. It's a little skippy on my lid but I just run my pinky along the edge to smudge/smooth it out and it's fine. Stays on all day. I have hooded monolids so some eyeliners transfer on my lid but this one barely did, and when it did it wasn't very noticeable and it was easy to smudge away even with eyeshadow underneath. I do notice a little bit of grayness under my eyes towards the outer corners but pretty much all eyeliners do that with my eye shape. Again, it's not that noticeable and I can wipe it away with a damp finger or a q tip and micellar water
No Budge Retractable Eyeliner 5
Laurajankowski from Seven Hills, Ohio
This is a great product a good value and does exactly what it is supposed to do.I stays on util you take it off. No smudges, even if you rub your eye accidentally still stays beautiful. It been cold and the wind blows and makes my eye water sometimes, no worries there either. Its a good product.
Love this eyeliner! 5
KP from Oklahoma
This eyeliner stays on for hours, great buy, especially for the price! I bought black and charcoal, which I really like. Not too dark or light, perfect!
Too hard to apply 1
Luna1019 from Michigan
I was very disappointed in this eyeliner. It was too hard to apply to my eyes without hurting myself. When I rubbed the point against the back of my hand, there was very little pigment.
Dried Out- Don't waste you $ 1
Devon from Roanoke, VA
Pencil seemed dried out and I would have to apply a lot of pressure to make a mark a that is not acceptable around my eyes.. I threw the eyeliner away after first attempt to use .. complete waste of money 😩
Good 4
product review. from USA
Doesn't last as long as I'd like in my water line but very pigmented and applies great.
Great Eyeliner 5
Becka47 from Pennsylvania
Great white liner ! Goes on smoothly! Great value!!
Its great 4
NikkiK125 from Harvey ND
I bought this a few weeks ago and I'm not sorry! Its a great product!
Great 5
Hina from Toronto Ontario Canada
This is a really great liner, even though it's mechanical and I usually don't prefer these. The color is incredible, Jet Black and it works fine. Not rough and I like it
Bought as a gift and... 4
AAMCD from undisclosed
Bought as a gift and it's a hit! She says it stays on well.
Excellent eyeliner but....... 5
Midnight999 from Wales, UK
I bought lots of these in Charcoal about 18 months ago because they're fantastic.
I bought them because, previously, I'd been buying a different make of eyeliner and decided I no longer liked the sparkle in it. This has no sparkle and I LOVE IT!
Unfortunately, E.L.F have discontinued providing the Charcoal colour at all, so I will have to scour the internet for another grey waterproof eyeliner, simply because black is too harsh for me.
Below, where it asks about eye colour it doesn't give enough options.
I have one brown eye and one blue eye.
Very affordable but smudges 3
Angel47 from New York, NY
I was looking for an affordable eyeline that doesn't smudge in my lashline and waterline but sadly this was another addition to the products that do. This eyeliner still works perfectly as a normal eyeliner on the lids though.
Stays put! 5
KJM11 from Santa Rosa, CA
This eyeliner is easy to apply and it actually DOESN"T BUDGE. I smudge it a little and it stays all day. Love it.
Nice application but runs off 3
Amelia from New York
it'll look good for the first two hours, but then it starts running off in the outer corners of my eyes. I'm not crying or getting the area wet, but it smears a lot
Very pigmented!!! 5
H from Tx
Loved it applies easily very smooth application and very pigmented!!
Super Love! 5
BettyRubble from Maricopa, AZ
Super love this eyeliner! So smooth and stays in place. Great purchase!
Its the constant runoff/smearing/melting for me. 2
Oriana from Florida
I was really excited about this eyeliner but I am so disappointed. Yes it applies easily and a little comes a long way but it just melts from your top eyelash Line to your lower waterline so easily and quickly. At first I thought it was the humidity outside but as the weather gets colder ill walk out of the house looking good and 30 mins later I look in the mirror and Ill look like a panda with eyeliner smeared on my waterline. So bottom line if you don't mind going to the bathroom and wiping off runoff/melted eyeliner from your bottom lid every 30 mins then sure this is the product for you. Will not be buying again.
Glides across the eye 5
gshoes1 from Pittsburg, CA
I am so very pleased with this product. It easily glides across the eye lid. It is long lasting and stays on all day.
Affordable and easy-to-use 5
Pandoragirl from Cali
I got this in brown but I'm going to get black too. A must buy. Affordable, easy to apply and maintain. Eye pencils need to be sharpened and I usually break the tip, and with liquid eyeliners, once you make a wrong line and have to clean it, it gets smudged. This is just perfect for me.
Great eye liner 4
Abeera from undisclosed
I just bought it and i am definitely in love with it. Going to use it for my trendy makeup looks.
Garbage 1
Viv7609 from Pulaski, VA
I just got this product yesterday and the entire thing just broke! It's absolute garbage and I'm sure it's made not to last so I can keep spending money on it. I'm so upset. I expected so much better.
Stats on all day! 5
Gen1 from Ruidoso NM
After several orders of different eyeliners this eyeliner is the best, stays on all day and so easy to use. Recommend highly!
Stats on all day! 5
Genb from Ruidoso NM
After several orders of different eyeliners this eyeliner is the best, stays on all day and so easy to use. Recommend highly!