Product Reviews Rated 4.16 out of 5 stars
37 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Best waterproof eyeliner PERIOD Being a person who loves to put on a cat eye look everyday, I know eyeliners, and I've tried EVERY one of them. I use both a liquid pen eyeliner and a regular pencil style eyeliner everyday. They've got to be waterproof cuz I wear them all day, like 12-16 hrs a day, and my eyes tear up sometimes. This ELF retractable (cuz ain't nobody got time to sharpen everyday) pencil eyeliner is awesome. It stays put, costs only $3-4 (wow!!! that's cheap), is well pigmented, and glides on easily. It doesn't tug my eyes (I can't have that cuz I don't want more wrinkles at my age). I can't say enough about it. The only drawback, which is totally fine, is that it doesn't last long, so I usually buy 2-3 at a time cuz I go thru them quickly, but I wear A LOT of eyeliner. If you don't wear a ton like I do, you wouldn't need more than one at a time. With that price, though, I don't care that I have to buy a few more. I used to pay $12-30 for pencil eyeliners that I didn't even love as much. As for ELF's liquid pen eyeliners, they're not as great, so I can't recommend those. Definitely get this pencil one, though. It's bomb!!!!
Most Helpful Critical Review Disappointing I'm like Cinderella in a search for a great brown, mechanical eye liner. That one's too soft. That one's too waxy. That one doesn't stay on. I have yet to find one that's juuuuust right. My goals are simple, or so I thought: I want a pencil for tight lining and my waterline that goes on smoothly, evenly, and that requires minimal touch up throughout the day. This isn't that product. The search continues ...
Reviewed by 37 customers I would buy this product again. 4
Eyeliner woman from South Dakota
The price is exceptional, applies easily, and seems to last as long as much higher-priced eyeliners.
Kinda love it 4
Jamsandjellies from Minneapolis, MN
Brought this on a whim in navy and charcoal. Mask wearing changes which eye makeup products I choose. This is not smooth to apply or luxurious in any way. But it does not budge, run or fade. Recommended it to many people.
Would not buy again 1
No nickname from GA
Not really for people of color. Not able to see it.
Yes I would buy this product again 5
Beca from Pleasant Hill
Great product does exactly what it said it would do. Very smooth easy application.
The best 5
MONA from South Carolina
I use as a precision eyeliner.
Eyeliner did run 4
Suncast46 from Ohio
For me, eyeliner just runs. I have yet to find some that doesn't that isn't too expensive. This said "no budge" so I was hoping it would be better but is the same as all others. I will continue to use it because other than that, it is great.
elf lover 5
mguerrero3177 from Brownsville, Tx.
I have used this product for one year already it is my go to. I have used elf products for like 7 years already love that the come out with new economic products.
Best eyeliner every! 5
Cocoharley from Kalamazoo, MI
This is by far the best eyeliner I have ever purchased in my entire life. I have very oily skin and all the other eyeliners I have used, even the expensive ones, run all over the place no matter what I do (use all types of oil control products, setting powders, makeup setting sprays, etc.). Also, I have trouble applying eyeliner on the outer corner of my eyes (nothing would stick smoothly and evenly), but I have no problem with this one. It goes on nicely without making my eyelids sticky like some other eyeliners! It is also easy to smudge during application. :)
I will definitely purchase this product again ! 5
PB from OHIO
Use this product daily! Saw it used on a model on YouTube and they highly rated It!
I was surprised at the low price and decided why not? I was soo happy I did!
Not impressed with this eyeliner 1
Tina from Sherman TX
Eyeliner on eyes smudges bad!!!!!!!!
Spend more money, get an eyeliner that stays in place. 1
Rachel S. from KY
For a product that has "no budge" in its name, it sure has trouble staying in place on my face. I used it once, I'll probably throw it away. :( Which is pretty wasteful when you think about the resources that went into making and transporting this piece... But if I can't use it, I can't use it.
Love Elf 5
Lindy from Keystone Heights, FL
Elf is inexpensive. I purchased the retractable eyeliner. Very smooth and stays on pretty good...
Great 5
SirenGlam from Texas
Works incredibly well.
Doesn't go on well 2
Hailey from United States
I was super excited to receive this in the mail, because I have been in the search of a good eyeliner that goes on solid. This is not it.
Great eyeliner no smudge 5
CYNTHIA from Alabama
Love that it doesn't smear, goes on easy and doesn't irritate eyes
Need backups!!! 5
Lizzy from St. Petersburg, FL
Cry proof for winged eyeliner: 10/10
No budge: 10/10
100% repurchase this!!
I got this in a sample when ordering from Ulta Beauty, I don't really like elf cosmetics but this eyeliner is everything. From the moment I've tried it on, I fell in love. I have worn it throughout the day and it looks the same. It's affordable and for a good amount of product you won't regret it. It makes winged eyeliner for me so much easier!!
Amazed 5
Ki from Orlando
Love how creamy the product is, doesn't smudge even with force
Good as usual 4
Kim from Md
Good product. Can get slippy if not primed
😍 5
Jodi from Atlanta
This eyeliner goes on dark and doesn't smudge yet comes off easily when I wash my face! Love it!!
Disappointing 2
Anne in Little D from Denton, TX
I'm like Cinderella in a search for a great brown, mechanical eye liner. That one's too soft. That one's too waxy. That one doesn't stay on. I have yet to find one that's juuuuust right. My goals are simple, or so I thought: I want a pencil for tight lining and my waterline that goes on smoothly, evenly, and that requires minimal touch up throughout the day. This isn't that product. The search continues ...
Best waterproof eyeliner PERIOD 5
Savvy Sue from Memphis, TN
Being a person who loves to put on a cat eye look everyday, I know eyeliners, and I've tried EVERY one of them. I use both a liquid pen eyeliner and a regular pencil style eyeliner everyday. They've got to be waterproof cuz I wear them all day, like 12-16 hrs a day, and my eyes tear up sometimes. This ELF retractable (cuz ain't nobody got time to sharpen everyday) pencil eyeliner is awesome. It stays put, costs only $3-4 (wow!!! that's cheap), is well pigmented, and glides on easily. It doesn't tug my eyes (I can't have that cuz I don't want more wrinkles at my age). I can't say enough about it. The only drawback, which is totally fine, is that it doesn't last long, so I usually buy 2-3 at a time cuz I go thru them quickly, but I wear A LOT of eyeliner. If you don't wear a ton like I do, you wouldn't need more than one at a time. With that price, though, I don't care that I have to buy a few more. I used to pay $12-30 for pencil eyeliners that I didn't even love as much. As for ELF's liquid pen eyeliners, they're not as great, so I can't recommend those. Definitely get this pencil one, though. It's bomb!!!!
I would buy again. 4
Older lady from VA
Like that it is retractable and goes on smoothly without tugging.
Need this in Black too! 4
SamIam from RI
I needed a new gel eyeliner and this one works well. When my local Ulta has the black in stock I'll be buying that one too.
Love it! 5
Paula from Oklahoma
This eyeliner is great! It glides right on over my eyeshadow and looks great. I'm able to get a thin eyeliner because it goes on so smooth.
Staying Power 5
Mrs O from Troy
I use it on my lower lash water line. Very long lasting and does not clump in the corner of the eye. Non-irritating, as I wear contact lenses. Highly recommend!
