Rated 4.43 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Best eyeliner!
I love this Milani eyeliner so much. It's so much similar to my Kat Von D tattoo eyeliner. They are both very easy to apply since it's very pointy which is great for me whenever I'm in a hurry to go somewhere. I feel like now I should buy more Milani Cosmetics since they're worth the money, especially the eyeliner. I had no problem taking it off either. It says that it's waterproof but most of the time the waterproof eyeliner are hard to come off but not this one! I just simply use my makeup remover wipes and it came off easily. This eyeliner is better than most of the brand I tried and similar to the one I have. I would totally recommend this to everyone who loves liquid eyeliner like me.
Most Helpful Critical Review Definitely not what I hoped it would be
I gave it 2 stars because it was super easy to apply. I'm a winged queen. I aways need my wings before work or any day for that matter. I'm a nurse that's running around all night and I was looking for something that was quick and easy to apply and and wouldn't sweat off. I saw this and got instantly excited. I tried it the first night and I couldn't even get through 2 hours of work before my eyelids where sticking. Then I went to the bathroom to see a hot mess above my eyelids. It definitely melted. I'm super OCD when it comes to my liner and this ain't it chief.
Reviewed by 46 customers I mean.. it looks good but...
Dawn the face tattoo artist from Florida
It was on my face for three days because I couldn't afford remover after day 3 I had scabs in the corners of my eyes from tryna rub it off
I would definitely buy this again.
Hope Is Dope from Lake Elsinore, CA
I've always had a hard time finding an eyeliner that didn't smudge. I have very oil skin. But using this, I had 0 problem. I love this product.
Not great for sensitive eyes
Mel from North Carolina, US
It was very pigmented, but it irritated my sensitive eyes. It also dries quickly, so it was not very beginner friendly. But, if you don't have sensitive eyes and are use to eyeliner, would probably be great!
Lloydielui from USA
The color is very black, so smooth to apply and could easily go over any lines to straighten your line. Stays on all day with no smudging. Even when I washed my face it surprised me that my makeup remover removed all makeup except the eyeliner. So definitely is waterproof. I applied more face wash to my eyes & I was struggling to remove it. I don't want to be rubbing my eyes harshly so now I use my eye makeup remover then the face wash and problem solved. I will definitely buy again!
Deanna from Undisclosed
I love all my Milani products. I can't tell what this one is? Anyway I am glad to have found such reasonably priced and good quality products.
I would buy this again
Christina from Undisclosed
love how this liner stats put all day!
Carla from Undisclosed
Great and sharp tip to make great Eyeliner
Will definitely buy again
bmt223 from Tulsa,OK
This product is amazing. It goes on so easily and is wry easy to use. I'll definitely be buying this as long as they make it! I've already recommended to several friends and colleagues.
Not smooth. Messy application.
Ashley from Alaska
I was excited about the new tank design but this eyeliner is thick and hard to get a smooth line. When you curve over back to get the cat eye it takes off the liner thats already there. The wet and wild skinny does better and its even cheaper. It is pigmented and black but not in a usable way.
not bad, better than average
Jackie from CA
i like the formula. my eyelids are super oily. i hate these kind of brushes cause it does clump up. takes a while to get off so i know it stays for a while. after like a long while is when it smudges. would probably repurchase but hoping they come out with this but not felt tip & more like a brush tip.
Jess from Georgia
Great eyeliner! It's dark and I am able to do a great line with it, it's not runny and stays on for a decent amount of time
One of the best Eyeliner ever
Artegm from Forney, Texas
Like I said on my title this is one of the best Eyeliner i've tried . The waterproof part actually surprised me, it totally worked!
Sorry for the late review but I wasn't able to try it on the past days. Thank you so much for letting me try this product for free! I'm in love
Kia from Milwaukee
Easy to work with
Bree from Albany Ga
Very easy to work with. I just put a small amount on my lid and it came so smooth and nice and it dry's very quickly. I love it
Worked really great!
Guille from Arizona
I loved it a lot!
Marce from Miami
I absolutely love this eyeliner, it was really easy to use and super opaque from the beginning. Gave the perfect amount of pigment so I didn't have to go over and over with it.
Can't wait to incorporate it in more looks!
bri from Tampa
The Milani Cosmetics Tank Liner is amazing. It is easy to use. Last all day and is waterproof.
Lexi from Dallas
This is truly amazing and stays on all day!
Best makeup ever!
Jae from New orleans
I used it as soon as I got it and it was surprisingly smooth and lasts long. I liked the fine point so it was easy to get on and waterproof.
EYELINER IS AMAZING!!
Duck from USA
Me and my mother both tried this eyeliner on and it really complimented us both. The eyeliner was easy to apply and easy to take off. It also didn't smudge or anything. WE BOTH HIGHLY RECOMMEND IT!
I honestly loved it
Michelleasamar from Duluth GA
First time trying this product and I absolutely loved them !!!
The eyeliner is just perfect and it works really good I highly recommend
Persh from Calexico
Its so pigmented , so dark and bold, easy to manage its like a kat von d dupe
Dianita from Florida
Honestly it's amazing so easy application
Not very opaque or long lasting!
DNash from Alabama
I'm not an expert at eyeliner, but I do have hooded eyelids and prefer a very thin line. This eyeliner has a felt tip that should be precise and easy to use, but the formula is the problem. The black is quite thin and not opaque, so it takes several layers to even get a black line. Otherwise, it looks gray and blah. It also smudges throughout the day, definitely not sweatproof or long lasting. I prefer Nyx Vinyl Liner, which is more precise, opaque, and long lasting.
mkb234 from USA
This is the smoothest eyeliner I've ever used. It stays the whole day and looks great! Definitely would recommend!