Product Reviews Rated 4.07 out of 5 stars
967 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Perfect!!! I bought the black lip-liner to go with a black lipstick (which I was struggling to find a liner to go with) I bought for Halloween. Me being me, I had to test the liner with the lipstick as soon as I got it (picture is of my trial run with the lipstick). I have absolutely no complaints. It was easy to apply, no dragging or looking too dry, and it matched the shade of lipstick perfectly.
Most Helpful Critical Review I love the shade range... I love the shade range of these pencils! Since they are automatic and affordable they are almost impossible to ignore for being a great value! The color payoff is great and they do an honorable job of lining your lips and keeping whatever you put on top of them in place. I will say that these can be a bit drying and can tug on your lips (or require some work to get the color payoff that they are capable of), but for the price that's really not a problem. I know that if I wanted a smooth-as-silk lip liner I would be buying it from a high-end line like Dior or Armani. These really are great for the price and it can be a good thing that they need some tug to go on: it means that once they're on, they aren't going anywhere!
Reviewed by 967 customers Beautiful 5
lip liner from NC
Such a great formula - creamy and stays on nicely!
Sand Color is Great! 5
glossy from NC
This was my first time trying NYX lip liner. The formula is extremely creamy and stays on well. I mixed this with the nude lip liner as well and it looked great!
I like the color 5
Poe from Indiana
I like a chocolate or cocoa shade for my lip liner and this is good
Just buy it! 5
Nicole from Wisconsin
Just a perfect, affordable lip liner.
I would buy this product again. 5
CB from Florence, Alabama
Applies smoothly and stays on great.
Great product 5
Vanessa from McAllen Texas
This lip liner stayed in place the whole night for a wedding I attended. It is a beautiful color with a great finish. Needed it red to match my dress, thinking I'll go back to buy it in different shades.
Gorgeous Color and Long Lasting 5
Kat from MN
Ordered the color "Jewel" and love it. Very pretty and SO SO easy to apply. You do have to be gentle to avoid it breaking. Looks great under the NYX butter gloss. Can't wait to try other colors.
My favorite lip liner 5
Rayne from Ohio
I'm obsessed with this liner! The shade is beautiful and it stays on for hours. The best part is the price.
I'm buying again 4
Jackie from CA
It glides on the lip so smoothly, it's almost like butter. I love it.
Too Smudgy 3
VJG from Palmyra, PA
Great color, but smudges too easily where I want a Cupid's now to be defined.
Natural 5
Mandy from Green Bay, Wi
I use the color Natural everyday with any nude/neutral lipstick. so good.
Great product! 4
Cassidy from Panama City, Fl
Love, but the tip breaks off easy so you can't slide too hard.
Great product 5
💄Lover from Pittsburgh
I love this lip liner!
Stays on for quite a while!
Shimmer 1
Kat from Peoria, Az
So disappointed. Got nectar color. Looks like a shiny shimmery lip color my 13 year old granddaughter would like. I will have to look elsewhere for a matte waterproof retractable liner.
Absolute Favorite 5
Staritto from RI
I have fair skin and this color is the perfect shade for a nude lip. It glides on smooth and is not drying or sticky.
Beautiful color. 4
Nora from Thousand Oaks
Love this classic color natural and match with any color lipstick.
sad 3
ultalina from new york
why it doesn't state anywhere that it has shimmer? this looks like a lipstick I would wear 30 years ago... disappointed.
ONE OF THE BEST LIP LINERS EVER 5
Jenn from Los Angeles
This NYX liner is so underrated! It's so creamy and it last soooooo long. I find myself reaching for this liner over all my high end liners. Definitely recommend.
Color is off 1
Cyn from Indianola,IA.
The color is very different than the picture. It is much brighter. It is more of a cherry bright red then dark red. It is also soft. Rather soft then hard to put on however it smears easy it is so soft.
Sad not so good 2
Chanel from HAWAII
Sad not-so-good wrong color breaks easily
Great product for the money! 5
Desireered from Naples, FL
I used to use Smashbox's retractable lip liner. Once I tried this one I was hooked. At 3/4 of the price of the other, NYX retractable lipliner is the best. It is long lasting even when eating & drinking. I have bought this liner several times & will keep buying.
Very creamy 5
Diane from Denver
Great product and goes on very smooth definitely would buy again!
Amazing 10/10 would reccomend 5
Aisha from Stl
I live for lip liners that I don't have to sharpen and the colors I got are super creamy and soft and pigmented and everything you would look for in a lip liner and I love these overall. I have a massive collection of makeup and I am sooo exited to buy practically all the rest of this collection because it's truly top tier and not expensive at all
Love 5
Cristie from Alabama
Smooth lipliner, doesn't clump up when applying
Didn't realize it was a shimmer liner 3
Angel from South Carolina
I didn't realize the lip liner I bought wasn't matte. Its pretty but not what I'm looking for.
