Rated 4.26 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review My go-to liner for perfect wings
Winged eyes are my every day look, and I've gone through so many different brands and types of eyeliners. I've purchased both cheap and expensive, as well as pencils, gels, and liquids. I've used different sized applicators ranging from tiny, wispy brushes to super thick felt tips, and dealt with terrible pigmentation and durability issues. I can honestly say that Revlon's Colorstay Liquid Liner is the best of all categories when trying to create the most perfect wing! I typically don't apply liquid liner on my water line so I would only recommend using on the lid. I can apply this early in the morning, spend an entire day at work, and my liner lasts until I take it off at night. It loses very slight pigmentation, but not enough to need complete reapplication before heading back out for the night! One of the few downsides to the durability is that, if you make any mistakes when applying, you'll need makeup remover to correct. My skin type is normal/dry, and I've had minor irritation on the outer corner of my eye while the product is drying (I typically have that problem with most makeup, though.) The formula is fairly wet to begin with, so I may not recommend to beginners, and a little goes a long way. I've consistently repurchased this product and will continue to do so!
Most Helpful Critical Review Not a huge fan
I wear a substantial amount of makeup everyday. The whole shebang. I tried the sister eyeliner with the SKINNY applicator which I was actually looking for in store but it was out of stock, so I decided to go with this. I don't know why but I feel like the formula is different. This one isn't as pigmented as I would like, putting it over my eyeshadow is a two layer job and even then it looks watered down. It also bleeds so I ended up with larger wings than anticipated, when I finally got a perfect line I looked like I was going for an Amy Winehouse impersonation. Luckily my style is crazy so it works, but for a simple line for daily wear, I would not recommend this product.
Reviewed by 2254 customers Disappointed
Mi from Northridge Mall
irritates my eyelids and doesn't stay
The applicator and packaging
jessicaharpclements from undisclosed
The applicator and packaging are nice, but the eyeliner itself does have a tendency to smear after a few hours of wear.
Doesn't day out fast
jennyb161 from undisclosed
Doesn't day out fast and it's easy to use. Longevity is never an issue. I always buy the brown color bc it compliments blue eyes.the only problem it has is when it starts to get 'old' it will yuck up on the applicator. I recommend it.
Applicator Awful for Hooded Eyes
LoLo from Missouri
Didn't realize winged eyeliner on hooded eyes could be more difficult until I tried using this eyeliner. I was looking for a cheaper replacement for my Stila stay all day because I use through is so quick and this ain't it.
Awful. Inconsistent application and awful applicator.
I love this eyeliner
carrief46 from undisclosed
I love this eyeliner so much and I love the brand as well! It is dark when applied, it's easy to apply, it's affordable, and it stays on for quite a while and that is so important when you are a mom of 2 boys because you do not have time to reapply eyeliner! Lol
Not a fan. It
mayrarosas_ from undisclosed
Not a fan. It can get the job done, but it takes much longer. The applicator is really stiff and thick and hard to work with. A sharp wing is definitely a task. I've gotten better eyeliners for cheaper.
I use this liquid
idks from undisclosed
I use this liquid eyeliner almost every night when I go out. It's very easy to apply. It dries very quickly. It has a fine tip for that perfect cat eye makeup. It doesn't smudge either which is amazing. Also if you really don't want it to come off, sometimes I add a little setting powder to it.
ALWAYS my go too
janetteh13 from undisclosed
ALWAYS my go too for liquid eye liner love how long it last and the easy to apply coverage last all day for sure makes nice wings on my eyes love love this one the price is great too
Love it. No need
bridgettelp from undisclosed
Love it. No need for expensive eyeliner. This does the trick and is easy to apply. I use a lot of eyeliners but I always come back to this one.
I love Revlon colorstay
katiesmith9d7bf1e9 from undisclosed
I love Revlon colorstay blackest black liquid eyeliner!! It has a fine tip making it super easy to draw a thin line and get the ultimate possible precision. Your eyes will POP with this super black liner. As a woman with hooded eyes, it makes my life a lot easier. If you haven't tried it already, what are you waiting for??
Have purchased this multiple
katieb488 from undisclosed
Have purchased this multiple times and always works and reliable. Not the biggest component so don't expect it to last for months of daily use or anything. Great product though!
The best liquid eyeliner
member71f31 from undisclosed
The best liquid eyeliner on the market. Still. I love my wings and I dislike when my eyeliner fades or bleeds by the end of the night. This stays put! Quick Pro tip, for even longer last, draw on wings or eyeliner with Revlon eyeliner pencil first, then redraw with this liquid eyeliner! Stays all night guaranteed.
This is a MUST
emilyd264 from undisclosed
This is a MUST HAVE. I used it and it was so strong and looked so good and never once when I was wearing it did it smear! This is a must have if you wear eyeliner! Only complaint would be to have more in a bottle
This is a great
nikia12 from undisclosed
This is a great liquid liner. When they say blackest black it's true. Goes on smooth. Love the applicator.
I am very impressed
annah477 from undisclosed
I am very impressed and pleased with the new Revlon ColourStay black eyeliner. I really love how smooth and soft the pencil eyeliner is, as it glides on very easily and last all day long.
I love liquid eyeliner
diamantev1 from undisclosed
I love liquid eyeliner way more than pencil or gel, it just looks more cleaner to me! And it's easier for me to apply even though I have shaky hands.
Love this line!
Lisa from Phoenix
This liner is my all time favorite . It doesn't smudge, it doesn't flake, it stays on all day long.
I love this liquid
blancao23 from undisclosed
I love this liquid eyeliner cause it's very black and very easy to make a wing . And always ask wich eyeliner I'm using all the time .
This is my favorite
vanillaidacream from undisclosed
This is my favorite liner. Of all of them, I've tried the high end ones and I always come back to this one. The brush makes it so easy to apply, I always can get my best wing out of this one specifically.
Revlon ColorStay™ Liquid Liner
This is my fav
bethanyg45 from undisclosed
This is my fav eyeliner! I've tried several but this is by far the best an it's affordable. Easy to apply! Stays well too!
Does the job. Long
shivanirunning from undisclosed
Does the job. Long lasting . The Colorstay Liquid Eyeliner is rich, intense color that creates a precise line from ultra fine to dramatically bold. It's also waterproof. It's good for everyday look .
This is my go-to.
msmexicanvanilla from undisclosed
This is my go-to. I actually feel as though I have more control with this tip than I do with an eyeliner pen. It's quality and affordable.
Thought it was great
nicolept16 from undisclosed
Thought it was great except that the liquid ran out quickly. The tip was precise which I really found helpful
I totally dig this
heatherw255 from undisclosed
I totally dig this liner. It's my go to stage makeup with false eyelashes liner. It's easy to apply and very dark and opaque. It's perfect for creating winged designs on my lids and has a precision felt tip for getting a thin line into the inner corners too.
My biggest complaint about
stylebystella from undisclosed
My biggest complaint about this eyeliner is that is peels off your eye. Like it doesn't come off normally and if you accidentally touch or rub your eye in any way, the entire line will peel off. It's so weird to describe.