Product Reviews Rated 3.6 out of 5 stars
25 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review best brown mascara ever! I'm always looking for a good brown mascara for "no makeup" days. And by "no makeup" I mean ONLY three concealers, two bronzers, two blushes, two brow products, tightliner, two highlighters, contour... I have decent lashes but they are literally invisible without mascara. Black seems harsh with a lot of no makeup looks but brown mascara just doesn't get a lot of quality love. I saw the Pixi mascara getting good reviews on social media and gave it a shot. I'm very impressed! It doesn't clump even after 3-4 coats and it still looks like actual eyelashes. If you do need to use a lash separator, it doesn't flake at all. It adds good volume and also some length and actually holds a curl, which most mascaras don't for me. The result is an intense but natural, fluttery look that works great with no makeup looks. I'm not sure I'd reach for it with neon eyeshadow and glitter but it's exactly what I wanted for my purpose. And of course, Pixi is cruelty free!
Most Helpful Critical Review Its ight i bought this hoping it would be a diorshow dupe and have been using it for about a month now. its not bad but its not a holy grail. ill finish using it up but i dont think i will repurchase. i just didnt get the wow factor while using it. the black pigment is there for sure, one of the blackest mascaras ive ever used but the formula is more watery-gel like and it took me longer than anticipated to apply and had to do 2 layers, 3 layers gets too clumpy. it also took awhile to dry down and the wand isnt really like the diorshow. another pro is that when it did dry it didnt flake on me.
Reviewed by 25 customers Love 5
Debbie M from Brentwood, California
I love the brown color. I feel that black mascaras look harsh on me so I always look for brown. This is my second time buying Pixi brown mascara and I love how rich it looks. I don't think I'll ever buy another brand of mascara now that I've discovered this one.
Beautiful Lashes 5
Noel from Los Angeles
Great Mascara! It doesn't clump at all and gives my lashes a lot of length. Also love that it comes in brown as well as black. Brown mascaras are so hard to come by nowadays.
the brown is bassically a black 3
A from grassvalley
the brown is so deep it literally looks like black and the mascara doesnt do anything special for the lashes
Flakes really bad. 1
Svggie from Rockport TX
Goes on really well but flakes very badly.
Love best brown 5
Leslie03 from Missouri
I bought best brown. I prefer brown mascaras because black is sometimes too intense for my eyes. This one is great for minimal looks and is very natural. It darkens my lashes without making it look like I'm wearing makeup. It's so hard to find a brown mascara that isn't black-brown. This one is perfect!
Wouldn't buy again... 3
SamanthaErin from IL
Doesn't give much length or definition. Found it to run very easily with just a little bit of sweat from a hot day or workout. Definitely don't get caught in the rain and you will have a horrible mess. I wanted to like this, but there are for sure better mascaras out there.
I would definitely buy this product again! 4
Bell from Virginia
I absolutely love this mascara! It is better than most I have I used, seeing that it doesn't flake. I have tired so many different brands, and at the end of the day I have racoon eyes but not with this mascara. And then the fact that I can wear it all day, and it stays in place wonderful!
worst ever 3
ali from chico
Doesn't do much at all. Wouldn't waste my money again.
Great product 5
Lexi from Milwaukee, wI
This is ax great product. Adds lot of volume. Direct clump or crumble.
Less than full 1
Penelope from New Mexico
Mascara does not live up to any hype. There is no lift and definitely not more voluminous with this brand. I will stick to the telescopic by L'Oréal, cheaper and love the lift.
Large Lash? Where? 1
Xander from Wisconsin
The brush is aggressively large, for starters. I have blonde eyelashes and it barely colored them with two passes. If you can't coat blonde lashes, you don't get to be called Bold Black. It also stuck my lashes together, so I looked like I had 5 lashes total. Total waste, and that's with getting it on sale for around $11.
not happy 3
Ali from Ca
Dries super fast after a few used and barely works even when newly opened. Not impressed at all and wouldn't recommend. Probably the worst mascara I have tried.
Disappointing 1
Carol from Midwest
I knew not to expect a thick mascara. But, this was barely visible on my lashes after two coats. I didn't have time to see how many coats it would take to actually see my lashes.
BAD 1
md from stl
THE WORST MASCARA EVER IT DOESNT EVEN WORK
Love this 5
Teapoo from Turlock, CA
I don't know why this has so many negative reviews. I got this hoping it would be a natural mascara as I'm blonde and have light eyelashes so I got the brown and it's perfect. I work 12 hour shifts and it stays put and it looks very natural. Well as natural as it can look. I guess some ppl like big super huge lashes but I just want mine to have some color so I don't look dead lol it does the job.
My Favorite Mascara 5
Anya from United States
Not clumpy, nice natural brown color, and it stays on the lashes very well.
best brown mascara ever! 5
Stargaze from Colorado
I'm always looking for a good brown mascara for "no makeup" days. And by "no makeup" I mean ONLY three concealers, two bronzers, two blushes, two brow products, tightliner, two highlighters, contour... I have decent lashes but they are literally invisible without mascara. Black seems harsh with a lot of no makeup looks but brown mascara just doesn't get a lot of quality love. I saw the Pixi mascara getting good reviews on social media and gave it a shot. I'm very impressed! It doesn't clump even after 3-4 coats and it still looks like actual eyelashes. If you do need to use a lash separator, it doesn't flake at all. It adds good volume and also some length and actually holds a curl, which most mascaras don't for me. The result is an intense but natural, fluttery look that works great with no makeup looks. I'm not sure I'd reach for it with neon eyeshadow and glitter but it's exactly what I wanted for my purpose. And of course, Pixi is cruelty free!
Perfect natural looking mascara! 5
Mascara lover from Town
This mascara has no harmful ingredients. It provides super natural lashes. The brown is amazing. It's so hard to find a nice brown that isn't too black and this one is exactly what I was looking for! Goes on very smooth, no clumps, very clean application. The brush is so soft and fluffy. I love this mascara and will definitely purchase again!
Best mascara ever!!! 5
Leah7545 from Ohio
Thank you Ulta, so happy they finally have pixi! No flaking, no irritation, affordable. Very black and goes on smoothly. I was on a long expensive journey with finding the perfect mascara until I tried this.
Its ight 3
jboogs from pgh
i bought this hoping it would be a diorshow dupe and have been using it for about a month now. its not bad but its not a holy grail. ill finish using it up but i dont think i will repurchase. i just didnt get the wow factor while using it. the black pigment is there for sure, one of the blackest mascaras ive ever used but the formula is more watery-gel like and it took me longer than anticipated to apply and had to do 2 layers, 3 layers gets too clumpy. it also took awhile to dry down and the wand isnt really like the diorshow. another pro is that when it did dry it didnt flake on me.
My favorite 5
Lkay from Ohio
So happy Ulta now carries pixi! This mascara is amazing! Looks great and feels even better. No flaking, doesn't irritate and makes me feel beautiful. Once I tried this mascara I've never used anything else!
eh 3
emeraldeyes from NYC
it's not terrible but i won't buy it again
Probably wont buy again but not the worst product 3
Tammy from Cleveland Ohio
I will stick to Lancome mascara
Great mascara 5
Abkima from Chicago, Illinois
Looks very nice on and doesn't irritate eyes or skin. Will continue to purchase this one!
Better than others 5
Sassysyl from California
I love this mascara, I have tried many others but this one is my favorite. Ever since I started using pixi mascara this is all I use. So happy Ulta is now carrying this product, definitely will buy from Ulta.