Rated 4.0 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Best eyeliner
I received one of these beauties as a trial in one of my orders a while back; I've purchased two since. I previously wore an eyeliner with tattoo in the name. This wears just as well and pen has a longer life. I have not noticed any smuding or running but then again I don't wear eyeliner swimming and usually have a umberlla when it rains. So as far as eye watering, sweat, and crying this eyeliner stays put and requires a bit of scrubbing to take off at night.
Most Helpful Critical Review Nice eyeliner, definitely not water/smudge proof!
I bought this product in hopes of finding a great waterproof eyeliner that was easy to apply and that stayed on for the plans I had today. I applied 20 minutes before going swimming and out on my jet ski and unfortunately this product only halfway held up. It definitely smudged and definitely was not fully waterproof as I have fragments of this product all over my eyes. Kinda disappointing. I used a different product for tightlining under my eyes which lasted but I'll have to return this one for something that actually is fully waterproof.
Reviewed by 219 customers Why The Good Reviews?
Ali from Salt Lake City, UT
At first I thought this was it. That I'd found a budget eyeliner that surpassed Stila or KVD. The application and pigment were amazing.
Fast forward and hour. It's flaking and all over the place. It's awful.
My search continues.
Easy to apply!
HSLIFER08 from MT JULIET, TN
This eyeliner glides on effortlessly. And lasts all day! Great value as well!
Best. Eyeliner. On. The. Market.
Tomigirl1313 from South Dakota
Easy to use! Stays on the WHOLE DAY! I'm not joking. I have fallen asleep in my makeup (oops) and woke up and still had a perfect wing! *insert cry face*
Very good eyeliner!
paiged7 from undisclosed
In my opinion, this eyeliner is a very nice, affordable, waterproof liner. My eyes water a lot due to seasonal allergies -- or when I'm laughing -- and this eyeliner stays put! It does come off ***sometimes*** in one spot when I'm laughing, but other than that, it's very good!
Ritaamarieee from Texas
I love it. Doesn't bleed, stays put all day long! Definitely buying again
MsThang from New Mexico
I love the eyeliner! But i dont know why they always start leaking and actually start dripping! I end up throwing them out once that happens! But i like how they apply! So i always buy more ugh!
Trish S. from Riverside, Ca.
I love this liquid eyeliner. It's an affordable great price, works good & the color is good also. I 've tried the KVD or NYX which work good too, but the price was too much compared to this cheaper brand & works just as good. I just started using this & I like it. I'd take using this liquid liner & their retractable gel liner over any other expensive brand anytime!
Best pen eyeliner I have used after trying many
Sifrina from NE
I buy eyeliner when stressed at work, so I have tried several dozens - all price ranges. This is my favorite by far and the price can't be beat. I tested first - this stayed on the back of my hand through dishwashing but came off well with Ponds. I am 50+, not a makeup expert, and it applied a nice clean pigmented black line across my lids. I am not a big wing person but I like a small 'flick' and this was great, easy even for me. I did not shut the top well (my fault) and it shot off like a projectile so be careful. Shipping was quick!
Best eyeliner ever!
JJNN from England
I've been using this eyeliner for about 8 months now and it's THE best. Doesn't smudge and doesn't fade. I've got dry eyes so have to use eye drops which make them very watery but the eyeliner stays put. Super easy to use too, doesn't blob like the ones you have to dip back into the pot to put more on. Highly recommend!
best formula, worst bottle
monolidgirly from california
i have oily monolids and this is the ONLY affordable eyeliner ive found that doesnt smear after a long day. but the bottle/pen is totally defective. ive gone through maybe 10 of these and the reason is always bc the cap is really hard to put on and take off, and sometimes it just like bursts off and the eyeliner dries out
Its a good eyeliner but not waterproof
Larry_scary from Ottawa Ontario
(I bought this in store) it is a great formula, gives me a nice sharp wing, and is very easy to apply BUT i was advertised a waterproof liner and when i tried it out it was not waterproof
Babygirl16 from New York
I really love this eyeliner!
Definitely waterproof , it's a must have!
MissMaraJo from Chicago
I bought this last month and curently using it on my vacation. It is essy to apply and it is not dry.
I BROKE MY TOOTH AND THE EYELINER STAYED ON
trin from biloxi, MS
THIS ITEM IS SO AMAZING. I BROKE MU TOOTH AND WAS CRYING SO MUCH AND MY EYELINER WAS STILL IM TACT 10/10
Ride or Die Eyeliner
rachelt1234 from London
I've worn wings on my eyes daily for about the past 10 years so have been through MANY eyeliners. This hands down the longest lasting eyeliner I've ever had. It's always the blackest black and seems like it's going to stay like that forever. I've been using the same one for months and it's as black as it was from day 1.
I have oily lids and wear contacts so can definitely get that build up in the corner of my eye that I get from contacts, but there's zero transfer or build up with this pen. I love it dearly.
Pro tip: make sure you definitely close the lid. The first pen I used I didn't shut the lid properly and it dried out super quick. I got a second one and now that I always shut the lid properly I've never had any dried out issues.
Great waterproof eye liner
Pandasnow from Brooklyn ny
I have tried them all stila, von, Chanel and I have to say this is pretty good for the price definitely a contender. I always test my eyeliner by crying and taking a nap. It passed the test lol Will purchase again.
Emfrasr from Canada
Best h2o eyeliner ever used! Easy to use and wash off at end of the night. Stock up!!!
I've bought this 2...
Chelsea 20 from Vegas
I've bought this 2 times now. The first time I was in such awe; however, I lost it. The second time I remembered how much I loved it. My eyes are always watery and other eyeliners run down my face but with this one it stays super crisp throughout the day. Not only does it not run but it also is super easy to apply. cheap and effective.
Great eyeliner bad packaging
jings1luv from Jacksonville, FL
When I found this eyeliner I was so excited. It is very pigmented, applies excellently, and stays on all day with no smudging! But after a few weeks the casing started to break down and the liquid leaks. I purchased a second one thinking it might just have been one faulty one. But the second did the same thing as well. I use the product but it doesn't last very long before it breaks. Glad it's not very expensive.
really good eyeliner. sleep-proof, water-proof
Hailey from U.S
i loved this eyeliner. one day i put it on (was easy to apply) it survived through that whole day then i fell asleep in it, woke up to the apartment room i was staying in engulfed in flames, got out, and my eyeliner was still in perfect condition. honestly if it survived that in can survive everything. 10/10 reccomend
Abb from Mississippi
Make sure you shake it before you put it on I love it
High hopes, Big let down
WyldMoonChyld from Harrisburg, Pa
I bought this hoping that it was in fact totally smudge/waterproof....only to find out ...
Its neither. It doesn't matter how long I allow it to dry...a hour later, I'm looking like a raccoon. It also has a tendency to flack at spots. Just makes me look horrible. Definitely won't be recommending. Still on the hunt for a totally waterproof/smudge proof eyeliner
Bitchpuddin from Sunnyvale, ca
I was excited to try this, then I did...went on like latex, uneven color, peels and flakes off, definitely NOT waterproof when I can wipe it off with my fingers/ peel off. I usually love elf products. I am sadly disappointed
Best eyeliner but has a problem
Fool4gguk from California
This is the best eyeliner I've found. Tried most of the other highly rated eyeliners and most smudge off really quickly because of my slightly oily eyelids. This one is the only one that's stayed on the longest and it's super easy to use. But after ~a month of everyday use I'm also having issues with the lid. There's a spring on the lid which I think is common in other eyeliner pens but suddenly the eyeliner would just come apart when I open the lid. The inner compartment containing the ink stays on the lid while the outer compartment comes off. I'd have to hold the inner compartment and get ink on my hands and pull the lid off. Since other reviews have mentioned packaging issues I hope elf fixes it since the product is great otherwise
Love this liquid liner!
aaliyahhhh from Michigan, USA
I purchased this eyeliner a few weeks ago and I love it. The felt tip isn't too stiff, all the while providing the right amount of sturdiness to create a defined line. Very pigmented. Doesn't irritate the eyes either.