Product Reviews Rated 4.23 out of 5 stars
1037 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Beware: When they say Huge, they mean HUGE I use this product everyday to make my lashes the first thing that people notice when they see me- whether its at the office or a night out. For someone who recently stopped doing the liquid eyeliner wing (for about 4 years I did this everyday), this really has made a difference in my look- brightening up my eyes, and making my lashes pop! I am not someone who typically spends a lot of money or splurges when it comes to make up products- I am a very reasonable shopper- but I would definitely keep purchasing this product. The price isn't very bad considering it has lasted me over 2 months- when I'm usually buying mascara every 2 weeks. I highly recommend this product to anyone! Depending on how many coats you do (I usually put on 5-10, spending about 5 minutes on my lashes), you can really make people think your lashes are fake because of the exceptional length and volume that comes with this mascara. I have had people ask me if I was wearing fake lashes because of this amazing product. And the brush helps in curling them the same time as application, so throw away your lash curler! I recommend this product to anyone who wants to make a statement with their eyes and lashes!
Most Helpful Critical Review AWFUL! This is the worst mascara I've ever used! I got it to try as a free sample and I was excited to use it. What a disappointment! There is way too much product on the wand/brush and it is really difficult to avoid clumps. i wore it for 8 hours and there was absolutely none left on my lashes. It had all flaked onto my under eye area and I looked like a flaky raccoon. I used it twice and it's going in the trash.
Reviewed by 1037 customers Game Changer! 5
JmeAddison from Lubbock
I am very picky and particular with my mascara!
This is a game changer!
My lashes look AMAZING!
I have NO fall out, NO issues with clumping!!!
I'm in Love!!! Customer for Life!!!!
This is my go to mascara! 5
Bogey from Hudson, FL
It's an all occasion type of mascara
I did not like too clumpy 1
lizzie from Albuquerque NM
Did not like too clumpy
Awful 1
Erica from NYC
I look like a raccoon, I'm actually mortified I walked around all night looking like this. Granted it was below zero today so my eyes were watery but it smudged EVERYWHERE and it's supposed to be waterproof??
So bomb! 5
Tee from Tx
I've tried many mascaras, drugstore and prestige, and this one is definitely in my top 3!! It gives me length & volume in 3-4 strokes. Naturally my lashes are very thin & sparse from wearing falsies all the time, but this mascara really brings my eyes back to life
I've tried many…but this is the best for me! 5
Happy Customer from Kaysville, UT
My favorite mascara! Never clumps, never flakes, never irritates. Just gives me natural looking, long, fanned out lashes!
really good 5
sandy from OR
doesn't clump or flake, looks better than any mascara I've tried.
best mascara ever 5
jenjen from San Jose
I don't know why this isn't more popular. It gives tons of length and volume. Makes me look like I'm wearing false lashes. I'm 56 and love it, and so do my picky makeup obsessed teenage daughters
Mascara 5
Smiley from IL
I buy 2 at a time. One for home and the other for my bag
Had me-lost me 2
EyeChiGrrl from Chicago
Thought this was pretty great at first and even bought a second time but never again. Way too clumpy. I have to take off so much from the brush at opening so doesn't clump my eyelashes together when I apply. And it still clumps. Lovely brush but won't thicken and elongate without too much work to separate you lashes with a different brush. And it flakes. A lot. Many other mascaras are better for less. Don't buy
Awful 1
Samra from Wisconsin
Literally the clumpiest thing I've tried in my life. Like where is the volume? Where is the length? There is none. You're better of buying 5 maybelline mascaras for this price. Or a Lancôme one. Nasty
Smudge smudge smudge 3
Kitty from Los Angeles
I love trying new mascaras and I did like how thick this one made my lashes but one mistake applying it and it smears. It's very clumpy. I use another mascara to even it out but I don't plan on repurchasing but of how much it smudges.
Itcs okay 3
MrsBeanz from New Jersey
I was looking for a mascara similar to BTS that wouldn't smudge, this was recommended. It doesn't smudge but it flakes. While my lashes were nicely separated I didn't feel that it gave me the volume that I was looking for.
Best mascara I've ever used. 5
NickiB from New York, NY
I have fair eyelashes so, when I don't wear mascara, I always look tired abs my eyes look smaller. I've worn mascara nearly daily for the past 20+ years and have tried them all - from drugstore brands to $100 brand names. This is, hands down, the best mascara I've ever used. It has not clumped for me (this is my second tube), has even coverage, and fully lengthens my lashes.
Gave as gift she loved it 5
Got lucky from Enid ok
Got this for my girl friend she said it was the best mascara ever
Love this! 4
abby from Washington PA
I really do love this as an everyday mascara! It can be a little clumpy at first but I find that it wears off a little bit as the day goes on.
Holy grail mascara 5
Blynn from Kansas City, mo
Best mascara i have ever used and i have used tons of brands. My holy grail
My new favorite! 5
Hannah from Toledo, OH
I love this mascara! It gives me great length and volume!
Good mascara! 4
N.E from Texas
Helps define thin short lashes. I buy lots of different mascara and this one has worked well for me.
My HG 5
Selena from Houston
I've been using this about a year now and absolutely love it. I have fairly short, thin lashes, and this mascara has people commenting on my beautiful lashes. WHAT? I have no lashes, but this magical wand makes people think I do. The wand is definitely big (not my favorite type) but I'll deal with it for the results. I had no flaking and very little clumping..I tried out Maybelline Sky High and literally laughed. It looked like child's makeup compared to the Stila!
Super Flakey 2
Shazz from League City, TX
This would maybe be the perfect mascara if it wasn't so dry and flakey! Getting the look I want doesn't matter if I have to deal with the flakes!
Best mascara 5
Paat18 from Dixon, Ca
I always will try other mascaras but come back to this one. Its clean not clumpy n my lashes look great!
Not a fan 2
Mart from NJ
Got this mascara as a bonus offer. Once my other mascara expired I opened this one up and was so disappointed. The wand doesn't do a nice job of curling lashes unless I basically close my eyes and for me the wand was an odd shape. It also kept clumping up and didn't seem to have a smooth application.
This is a Winner!! 5
AtlantaJJ from Atlanta, Ga
I love this mascara. I received this and others in my Boxy subscription. This is the only one I will actually purchase. It makes my lashes so thick looking and full. Lasts all day and doesn't flake into my eyes. I need to buy a couple of tubes during the next sale.
THE BEST foif the "fake lash" look on your own lashes! 5
LeeAnn from Dallas, TX
A friend recommended to me, and yes, I recommend to friends!