Product Reviews Rated 4.53 out of 5 stars
22899 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review My Perversion always gets the best of me! I have been a long time user of UD's 24/7 liners. In fact, Zero was always my go-to liner, I never went a day without it! However, times have changed and UD has stepped up their game in a way I didn't even know was possible! Hello Perversion!!! Not only is this the blackest eyeliner I have EVER used, it glided on smoother and lasted longer on my waterline than Zero twice over. I work 12 hour shifts at a hospital and I have noticed that my liner looks just as good when I leave work than it did when I got there! I may switch up my routine from day to day when it comes to makeup, but one thing will ALWAYS stay the same, and that's my Perversion!
Most Helpful Critical Review Terrible liner After reading so many positive reviews about this Urban Decay liner I really wanted to love it. But I hate it! The first thing I noticed is that the tip of the pencil is really, really thick. So I tried to sharpen it but the gel like consistency makes it impossible to sharpen. After breaking the tip three times (what a waste of product) I gave up and decided to use as is. The line was so thick I looked ridiculous. I had to clean all the mess from my face and apply my cheap Maybelline liner which at five bucks works ten times better. I am posting pictures because I can't believe that the eyeliner so many girls love was such a letdown. DO not recommend at all.
Reviewed by 22899 customers Best eye liner ever 5
Na from Arizona
Best eyeliner just wish it wouldn't smear sometimes
Doesn't stay on all day 3
JAM from Iowa
I really like the eyeliner but it doesn't stay in all day for me. Application is great but a want s product that lasts.
great pencils 5
angie 48066 from roseville michigan
i love urban decay pencils they go on smooth and last all day...they come off good...
Love this product!! I would recommend this to anyone!! 5
Dana H from Warren, Arkansas
I love that this product goes on smoothly and doesn't smudge, even after a hectic day!
Sadly, it doesn't make it through the day 3
TLM from Dallas, TX
I really like a simple eyeliner pencil. I love the rich whiskey brown but even with eyelid primer and setting spray by the time I get home - 5 to 6 hours later - it is completely gone.
I really like this item 5
Lucy from Joplin, MO
I really like this. Please add this to my previous text. It is the green that I like. And have been unable to find.
I really like this product. 5
Lucy from Joplin, MO
I really like this product. I like the liquid better but I can not find it now. This is the only product I have found so far. I used to use the Ulta brand, the liquid kind, but it was discontinued I don't know why. I would recommend purchasing the sharper brand Urban Decay to use with this product.
I would probably buy this again 5
Happy from NJ
Just what I wanted
Did not like it 1
Sabrina from Lawton, OK
Did not like the eyeliner and cost way to much for one time use.
Just ok 3
Shellnm from NM
Applies very well and is easy to use, but after a few hours I find a streak below my eye on the outside corner that I have to wipe away. Could be my own fault as I do use heavy moisturizer and occlusives in the winter, but this won't work for me. I also use the perversion and demolition liners from Urban Decay and they don't do that so there's something different with the formula in the blue color that I purchased.
Best pencil eyeliners out there!! 5
Gemjamgirl from Sharon, PA
Urban Decay eyeliners are the only ones I use now. I don't care for liquid eyeliners and so many eyeliners pull at your skin and you have to go over and over to get coverage. These are fabulous!! Plus, the range of colors is over the top!!
I don't get the hype 1
CatO from WA
Honestly, I don't get the diehard holy grail vibes. I don't feel like it glides on easily at all, and the color payoff just isn't there. I've used drugstore liners that are so much better.
Fabulous 5
Chigirl from Chicago
I have tried many eyeliners and love how you can sharpen this to a point but is still gently sift on lids. Great tight line on upper lids but you do have to sharpen every other time you use to get the point. Whiskey is a beautiful brown that is dark but still brown.
I love this lip liner, it goes on so easily, and stays put. 5
Sarah from Panhandle, Florida
I use it whenever I can, goes on so easy, and stays where I put it
Yes 5
Jb from Myrtle beach
Love the color. It stays on and goes on smoothly
Even with UD primer, transfers to upper lid 2
Clare644 from San Francisco, CA
I don't consider myself someone with oily lids. I use urban decays eyeshadow primer to help avoid color from fading or from getting into my crease (I have hooded eyes). The eyeliner was in my crease a few hours later. UD has a lot of great eye makeup products, but this liner just ain't one. And I've tried the glittery shimmery purple, the brown, and now this one — all the same
Finally found the PERFECT eyeliner 5
Silver Firl from Greensboro, NC
I have been searching for the perfect eyeliner for so long. This one is the best. Stays on, no melt downs or fading. I love it❤️
It's fine. 3
B Hay from Missouri
It's fine. Not worth the money though. I do feel it's better than drugstore, but I also have to use a primer to keep it in place. It is not waterproof.
Love the formula! 5
Cinda from Colorado
Love the pigment pay off and the creamy smooth formula.
I would not buy this product again. It is being returned. 1
Ellie from South Carolina
I purchased it to use as a lower lid liner to brighten my eyes, It just doesn't stay very long and that was what I thought it would do. This item is being returned. We can't try anything on anymore (whick is fine) however it makes it difficult to know what you have until you get home and try it.
Disappointed in color 3
Laurely from KC, MO
Typical Urban Decay pencil - which I like, but I am really disappointed in the color. It is called "Loaded" and is supposedly a "dark green shimmer." The picture looks like it is a vibrant color with a blue undertone. It is a really really ugly - olive/khaki flat green. There is a shimmer to it. But the color has no life to it.
I would buy again 5
Neet from Greensboro, NC
I've used this eyeliner for years! It is totally waterproof and lasts all day and night! I have several colors!! I love them!
Absolutely gorgeous. 5
Savanna from Bronx
So beautiful for brown eyes!! Smooth application great lasting power.
Not waterproof 3
Patty from Plainfield, IN
It was gone from my top lid within a couple of hours. Way to expensive for that! Although it felt great applying! Color is great. Just doesn't stay. The bottom lid smudged after 4-5 hours then was gone.
i had high hopes :( 1
hater from ohio
this is probably the worst eyeliner i've ever tried. not pigmented at all, and it disappears in 20 minutes. had better performance from the $3 essence eyeliner tbh
