Rated 4.41 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review So smooth and easy to use
I just got this eyeliner today. I couldn't help myself so I tried it. This is a nice felt tip liner. The application is so smooth, no skipping and it is ine of the easiest felt tip eyeliners I have ever used and the color is nice and black, I may need a backup!
Most Helpful Critical Review Unexpected
So it says waterproof, cry-proof, humidity proof, smudge proof, flake proof. So once dry it is definitely smudge, flake, and fade proof. Although if you cry or wet your eyes I suggest light pat drying not wiping your eyes because then it will definitely smudge. This product reminds of a slightly upgraded version of the Wet n Wild h2o liquid liner.
Reviewed by 78 customers Bad
Emiko from undisclosed
Bad quality. It was already not able to draw a line after four times of using.
good for beginnners,, but not exactly breakup proof
bad bleep from hype house
this would probably stay better if i used an eye primer or setting spray,,, but i dont soooo.... tehee hopefully this helped < 3
Kat from Oh
I love this liner. I'm a liquid liner addict and of all the brands I've tried stila is my go to. However, since I use it nearly everyday I go through them like crazy, the $22 dollar price tag had searching for a dupe for over a year. I have tried nearly every lower priced liner and sadly could not find anything near stila's quality. I resigned myself to the fact that I would just stock up when they are on sale, and sadly have to buy them at full price when I ran out. Then I tried the wet n wild. Now I will say that it is not a 100% exact dupe. I feel that the stila liners last longer on the eyes, and take longer for you to run out of product. However, at nearly 1/4 of the price these are a more than acceptable replacement. I know some people don't get the hype around the stila eyeliners and don't care much for them. If you don't, then you probably won't like these much either. However, I love them and I hope wet n wild continues to make these forever!
Precise, pigmented, long-lasting and great price!
angiepereztv from Miami, FL
The Breakup Proof Liquid Liner is AMAZING! It's precise, pigmented and lasts a long time on my oily complexion. I love using it for fantasy detail work.
Thank goodness I found this
Emma Xi from Texas
I have oily eyelids, and I have monolids to boot; eyeliner never ever ever stays on me for a whole day except one specific Korean one designed for eyelids. I thought the name of this was funny, so I bought one, and touched up my (disappearing) liner in the car before I went to work. It lasted through sweat, moving boxes, running around, and my eyelids. 11/10.
H from Daytona beach, Florida
I love wet n wild but this eyeliner always smudges and ends up all over the top of my eyelid because i have pretty hooded eyes. I wouldnt buy it again.
Wet&wild breakup proof waterproof liquid eyeliner
Eastcoast73 from Nc
Love this wet and wild eyeliner... Tried several and this one is the best! I love it... just wish I could find this eyeliner in brown too.
Nikki from McKinney, TX
I purchased this eyeliner going by all the amazing reviews and price. First time I used it, I loved it. It went on smooth, easy to use, very pigmented, dried fast and matte. I thought I had found my new favorite liquid liner but unfortunately this liner did not hold up to a sweaty shopping trip to Ikea in Texas. By the time I got back to my car, I had sweated off one of my wings and the other just wiped off like I was using make up remover. I really wanted to like this but the search continues!
Best drugstore pen liner
Spencer's mom from Orange, CA
Suuuper black and pigmented. Glides like a dream. It's very easy to apply because of that and lasts all day on my asian eyelids.
New favorite liner
MrsHendo from Van Nuys, CA
Really black liner, lasts all day, no smudge, dries fast, easy cat-eye. Of course my husband didn't even notice.
Eye liner critique from Billings
Almost 40 and finally attempting a wing
Reyna_78 from Houston, Texas
This stuff is amazing. I'm 39 and have mature skin and was amazed that this liner didn't bleed when I attempted a wing. The tip is so tiny and perfect for this too!!!
Good liner, doesn't set completely
elizabeth from California
Im on my second already. For the price, works really well. There's some loose fibers that curl up around the time when you're done with the ink, but doesn't affect performance. The only thing is that you have to set it with translucent powder esp if you have hooded eyes like me. I was able to build up my liner skills with this and not have to worry about going through an expense 22 dollar liner. Stays really well once its on, but you have to set it if its gonna touch other parts of your eye.
it was okay
Kate from California
I loved it for a few weeks but after about 3 uses some of the pieces started to fray away from the tip and it got a little drier every use but it was very pigmented for the first few uses
I'll give them an E for Effort
Lorilei from New York
The good thing is that it has my favorite kind of brush: firm at the base with give at the tip, very similar to NYX Epic but without the glorious formula. It doesn't stay flexible like Epic; has a plastic-like look and shine so it emphasizes every bump and bit. Plus it definitely does crack.
Best Affordable Liner!!
OnTheReal from Huntington Beach, CA
This is one of the most precise liner tip I've ever used! From what I've noticed only gel liners have your falsies stay on all day BUT so does this liner!
kate from nc
I cried for like 2 hours in this and it didn't smudge at all
Better than expensive brands!
Buttercup from San Jose
I like liquid eyeliner, but searched for one that was easy to apply, lasted all day and distributed the right amount. This is a winner, especially for the price! I previously bought an expensive brand and was disappointed because when I would apply it too much liquid would come out, seeping into my eye. I kept trying to use it , thinking it was my application style, but I ended up throwing it out. This one is so much better.
Doppelgänger to Stila Stay All Day 10/10
Nicolextayl0r from San Diego CA
This is the equivalent to the stila stay all day waterproof eyeliner it goes on the same it was the same packaging is similar it's perfect
I love this liner for the price!
Kenzie from Kentucky
Stays on, doesn't smudge, easy to apply!
Took me by surprise
Beck from NEVADA
It last my whole work shift. Dose not flake. The pen is easy to use. Will order more.
Lokisa from California
I am in love with this liner, it's pigmented and stays put well on my oily skin. It's easy to work with and I will keep buying this as long as it's made.
tattoo liner dupe!
Mil from Arizona
So I have the KVD tattoo liner. It's really well loved and everyone likes that liner, I like it as well but when I tried this liner it immediately remind of the KVD liner! It works the same. Very matte and black, has long wear and won't come off! One of the best drug store eyeliners I've tried!
Stays ALL day!
Jenna from Huntsville, AL
I use this every day I put on eyeliner, and it LEGIT stays all day long. I don't have to worry about my eyes watering or even when I rub my face! It's incredible how long it stays. I'm not even that great at doing wings, and this is easy to apply. I will buy this over and over again!
Cadence from Tu
Good if you think about buying it you should