Product Reviews Rated 3.73 out of 5 stars
33 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review New Holy Grail I've worn (most would say dramatic) winged eyeliner everyday for years now and this eyeliner is a miracle for the price!! I have oily hooded eyes so I'm used to my eyeliner smearing and transferring throughout the day, but I fell asleep in my makeup last night, woke up, cried and my eyeliner still looks perfect! I've used this eyeliner three days in a row now so I can't comment on how fast it may or may not dry out, but for now I love it! I've never left an online review for anything before, but felt compelled to write this because of how much I love it. Buy it lol
Most Helpful Critical Review meh not the best it is very sheer so it takes alot of layers to make it show up. even then it isn't matte. when you try to put it on top of eyeshadow, the eyeshadow gets on the eyeliner. it does have a good felt tip and last long when you set it with a black eyeshadow. probably wouldn't buy it again because of how sheer it is.
Reviewed by 33 customers I will buy this product again 4
Beth from Oxford, AL
This product is so easy to use. It's easy to hold and apply. The one con would be that I do have to put on multiple coats for it to be as dark as I want.
meh not the best 2
Leighann from Mississippi
it is very sheer so it takes alot of layers to make it show up. even then it isn't matte. when you try to put it on top of eyeshadow, the eyeshadow gets on the eyeliner. it does have a good felt tip and last long when you set it with a black eyeshadow. probably wouldn't buy it again because of how sheer it is.
Easy basic eyeliner 5
Tara from Washington
I love this eyeliner because it's exactly what you think of when you hear basic eyeliner. It sets quickly, is pigmented, and is easy to remove with a qtip (for cleaning up edges and such). I don't exactly agree with the name because I do think it's rather easy to remove with water, but I actually like that because I don't have to rub my eyes to remove it at the end of the day, however it doesn't budge throughout the day which is really nice. The price is just another reason to love it, and it feels very high quality to me. This eyeliner is my holy grail because of this.
Easy to apply, hard to take off 4
Would Buy Again from Los Angeles
I love this eyeliner! It's definitely the easiest to apply but beware when taking it off, because once it's dry it will take some strong makeup remover, and as someone with sensitive skin, sometimes taking it off would irritate my eyelid. But if you have invested in gentle but strong makeup remover, this is the best!
New Holy Grail 5
Cece from Seattle, WA
I've worn (most would say dramatic) winged eyeliner everyday for years now and this eyeliner is a miracle for the price!! I have oily hooded eyes so I'm used to my eyeliner smearing and transferring throughout the day, but I fell asleep in my makeup last night, woke up, cried and my eyeliner still looks perfect! I've used this eyeliner three days in a row now so I can't comment on how fast it may or may not dry out, but for now I love it! I've never left an online review for anything before, but felt compelled to write this because of how much I love it. Buy it lol
LOVE 5
grace from philadelphia
perfect for the smooth and easy when applying
I love this eyeliner! 5
LaurelOH from Lancaster OH
Lasts all day. Can make a thin or thick line. Smooth. Does smudge a little on my lower lid, but not as much as other pencils.
Just ok 3
Mo from Oregon
I tried to do my cat eye, but good lord, it looks like my cat eye walked away and left behind a shadow. :/ I wish it was more pigmented! Once it was 3 or 4 layers thick and actually black it did really well.
better then Pat McGrath?! 5
ashlyxoxo from Minnesota
I can not believe I love this liner. I had been using pat McGrath liner that's like $30 but dang that's alot and the tip was to floppy it was hard to get a even line at 5am lol but this tip is perfect and the formula lasts amazing on my super watery eyes. stila liner always melted on the corners. Pat McGrath has a slightly better formula but I'll skip the $30 price tag.
Awful 1
Beth from Pennsylvania
I'm not sure if I'm doing something wrong. But i was so excited to use it, i shook it and nothing was coming out. The tip was dry all the time. And yes, i keep the tip facing down. It's awful, the pigmentation it's so poor, i can't believe i bought this.
good, but not waterproof 3
lily from Cincinnati
its really good for quick wings but its not tearproof at all. its incredibly runny and smears a lot.
Only one i'll ever use 5
KAY-KAY from Plattsburgh Ny
this is the only eyeliner i use because it's so amazing. it is perfect for a liquid eyeliner and it's not dry. it never dries out or gets gross. it's very affordable and worked just as well as any other eyeliner!
This eyeliner survives my 12+ hr ER shifts ♥️ 5
Lindsey L. from Mesa, Az
I work as a nurse in a busy ER. I stopped using eyeliner for a while because by the end of my shift I would look like I had been punched, my black eyeliner would smudge so badly. This waterproof eyeliner is a life saver! It lasts longer than any other part of my make up and stays in place during my shift.
Very pigmented and seriously smudge free! 5
Misselove from Los Angeles, CA
I have tried several other liquid eyeliners in my quest to find the best one and though the tip is probably my 2nd or 3rd favorite, the formula and pigmentation is seriously the best. I tested this along some of my other eyeliners for a whole day and the elf one is the only one that was still there after hours. It lasted longer than my Kat Von D tattoo eyeliner and maybelline master precise all day liner. I swatched 3 lines and went about my day, even washing my hands and again the elf was a little faded but still very much there.
It's alright 3
Carly from Brookfield
It's an alright product.
Amazing eyeliner 5
Jenn from Palmdale CA
I wanted to get a back up eyeliner I use KatVonD ink liner and this is as close to that I can get for under 6 bucks great waterproof liner
Love it! 4
Mexican Dutechess from Las Vegas, NV
I'd first like to give advice to those who say that the eyeliner run's dry or run's out after 1-3 uses. It's been my experience with ANY felt tip eyeliner that if you DONT keep it upside down, tip facing down, the Ink will dry up, it has nothing to keep moist. I keep all my felt tip eyeliners facing down and never have a issue with it "running out or drying up"
The black it true to its color and easy to apply. No jerking or smudging, just a easy glide for a perfect winged tip. < 3
There is better 4
Bagel Eater from Baltimore md
I used it to make a winged liner for a simple look. It didn't perform as well as the other liners I have so it was a miss for me and I wouldn't buy again.
LOVE IT 5
Mikaela from St.Charles, MO
I use it for making a cat eye and it works great! Some eyeliners out there say they're waterproof but actually aren't but with this one it truly is waterproof.
Very disappointed 1
Connie c from USA
I'm a HUGE elf fan and I've tried their other fat eyeliner felt tip liner and I hated it. I heard someone say this was good and replaced their high end eyeliner, so I went for it, I brought it and I was so exited. I payed for it with my own money. I loved the packaging and the tip. When I applied it for the first time, it was beautiful. So black and sharp. The second time I used it... it didn't even show up. IT DRIED OUT! I didn't even use that much product the first time I used it. I did a basic SMALL Wing. I was very sad and I even tried shaking it but it was a goner 😭
Life Changing 5
Patience W from Carrollton, GA
Omg. Never buying soupy-liquidly eyeliner again. Not only is it cheap and cruelty free, this stuff stays PUT! 12/10 would recommend, literally buying 10 to stock up.
Flakey and dried out 2
Jess from Chandler, AZ
Like other reviewers mentioned, the formula does flake off after wearing it an hour or two- mine dried out after 2 uses. Would not recommend.
idk what happened 3
Carrie from Florida
I normally love all elf products, but this is no good. The tip of the applicator is sharp, I felt like I was applying my eyeliner with a toothpick. the color that went on was sheer so I had to keep going over and over it. I'm really disappointed.
wouldn't buy againg 1
ruthie from iowa
Like the color but it does flake it does feather when you use it and isn't waterproof. can take a wet qtip and wipe if off. definitely wouldn't buy it again.
Great product. Great price. Goes on smooth. 5
Quita from Tennessee
Love this product. Goes on with ease.
