Product Reviews Rated 3.94 out of 5 stars
127 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Best eyeliner I received one of these beauties as a trial in one of my orders a while back; I've purchased two since. I previously wore an eyeliner with tattoo in the name. This wears just as well and pen has a longer life. I have not noticed any smuding or running but then again I don't wear eyeliner swimming and usually have a umberlla when it rains. So as far as eye watering, sweat, and crying this eyeliner stays put and requires a bit of scrubbing to take off at night.
Most Helpful Critical Review Nice eyeliner, definitely not water/smudge proof! I bought this product in hopes of finding a great waterproof eyeliner that was easy to apply and that stayed on for the plans I had today. I applied 20 minutes before going swimming and out on my jet ski and unfortunately this product only halfway held up. It definitely smudged and definitely was not fully waterproof as I have fragments of this product all over my eyes. Kinda disappointing. I used a different product for tightlining under my eyes which lasted but I'll have to return this one for something that actually is fully waterproof.
Reviewed by 127 customers Amazing 4
n0101 from england
Absolutely love it, one of the best eyeliners I've ever bought
amazing 5
em from Maple Grove
seriously best eyeliner, although i do like to sharpen my wing with a liquid liner. great formula and doesn't budge all day!
really nice eyeliner 4
melissag4gucci from los angeles
i bought this and i love it the one thing i would love more is if it had a slightly sharper tip to get a sharp wing but overall it has good pigment and it looks nice and is easy to apply and for the price its really good
GIRL I- 5
cakefacemaria from Charlotte, North Carolina
i'm not lying when i say this is the best eyeliner i've ever tried. great pigmentation, easy to use and the PRICE!
Great eyeliner 5
Lolawazhere from Orlando, Florida
This eyeliner is better than most I have tried and I have tried a lot unfortunately lol Its in my go too makeup pile. Doesn't smudge and always goes on neatly. MUST HAVE LIST
Amazing eyeliner 5
Sev from usa
Absolutely love this eyeliner. It's very durable and lasts a very long time. The lines are very smooth and doesn't take much time to dry.
Love! 5
Karma from Washington state
I love this product!! Super easy to use and dries quickly and perfect for price!
Not that great 2
Liz from Napa
So I bought this because NYX eyeliner was out of stock ad decided to try this one. It said shake so I shook it thinking it would soak the tip and glide smoothly but it didn't and it came out in patches and no matter how much I shook it nothing more came out. It felt like it was barely wet.
perfection 5
cate from co
this has amazing pigment and easy application, great for beginners like me. price is golden and i love this!
GREAT PRODUCT 5
alex from ca
The pigment on these is amazing. 10/10
It's actually waterproof. 5
emi_ from Philadelphia, PA
I was cutting onions to make stir fry earlier while wearing this makeup and cried so much. The eyeliner stayed on without smudges!! Not only is it waterproof, but it's so easy to use.
Love it! 5
Kai from Beaverton
Fave eyeliner. Inexpensive, long lasting, smooth brush strokes
Better than brands twice the price 5
Jesse from Flat Rock, MI
More waterproof than my usual waterproof Stila at half the price. Goes on really nice. Very deep black and not watery like some budget brands. Found a new loyal customer. Switched to Elf shadows not looking ago and happy with those too.
Lovely eyeliner 4
AvaReal from LDN
It's not exactly waterproof especially if not using an eyeshadow primer underneath, other than that, good liner
Lovely eyeliner 4
Ava Real from London
It's not exactly waterproof especially if not using an eyeshadow primer underneath, other than that, good liner
Best Eyeliner to Exist! 5
lauchnor from undisclosed
I've been using this eyeliner for MONTHS and it is by far my favorite makeup product ever! Bold color, great flow, felt tip pen applicator is so gentle on the skin and the best part is this eyeliner will. not. move. EVER! Go to work, take a nap, workout; you name it and this eyeliner locks on until you want it off. No smudge, crease, the perfect amount of liquid. Perfect!
Amazing! 5
Andrealva99 from California
I love this eyeliner because it has a thin tip but it goes thick on the back, it is super easy to use, even for beginners! It is actually waterproof I already tested it haha it last really long even when you forget to wipe off your makeup in the next morning the eyeliner will still be there! One of my best eyeliner.
good for beginners 4
Kelsey A from los angeles, CA
this was one of the first eyeliners that I tried as a beginner to eyeliner and it did the job. I was able to get used to how to apply liquid liner. great for beginners.
VERY AFFORDABLE 5
ashley from New Jersey
I really like this eyeliner it's very black but it might of been just the one I bought but the eyeliner sometimes may crack. It waterproof all right. Applies very easy and it's easy to travel. Over all love it < 3
Great price great quality 5
Natalie72 from undisclosed
I recently bought this as a practice eyeliner (my wings aren't good) and the thin tip on this eyeliner makes it so much easier! It has great pigment and lasts a long time with no smudging.
Love this 5
Raquelle from undisclosed
Love this eyeliner!!!! It's super long lasting. I like how thin the tip is; makes it super easy to apply
bleeds, really sheer, watery 1
teresa from cali
nyx's is a buck or two more and it's so much more worth it than this. this is literal charcoal water with a felt tip.
easy to apply but not enough pigmentation 3
maza from toronto
My go-to eyeliner was a Korean one and it would last for a day and it was super pigmented, like it was similar to the kvd tattoo eyeliner, but it was way cheaper. The store chain i would buy it at closed and i heard that the elf one was also great. I decided to try since it was around the same price, but i was super decepointed when i tried it. It's not black enough and i can remove it by simply applying a bit of water, which is a bit of a bummer since it's marketed as being waterproof + i bought it for that specific reason. The applicator is great tho, since it's more on the finer side.
Wedding liner!! 5
BAldo from Florida
First time ever using liquid eyeliner at 38. Goes on super easy makes a nice bold line but not super thick going to be in my wedding eyeliner because it's definitely waterproof
YAS YAS YAS 5
Lauren from Illinois
Love the point on tip on pen! Lasts all day!