Rated 4.45 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Very good brow pencil! Will definitely order more.
I really like these brow pencils. Honestly, I didn't have high hopes because at the time I ordered, there was only one review and it wasn't a very positive one. But! In my opinion, these are very good if you can find your shade. I'll say right away that if you are light blonde, you are much better off with the "Studio" brow kit in "Ash" because even the "Taupe" pencil will be too dark for you.
These are suitable for medium blonde to dark.
So I got "Taupe" and "Neutral Brown" because I'm medium blonde at the moment ;). Can't be happier that I decided to give these a try!
The texture of these is very similar to other brands' brow pencils; they aren't too waxy, but not too soft either. They are soft enough to allow the pencil to glide when you apply it, but not too soft, so they don't feel like a sticky gel or anything like that. The pigmentation is very good; you definitely don't need to go over the same spot over and over again, which sometimes happens when the pencil is too waxy or just has poor pigmentation. I included the pictures, so that you can see the difference between the two colors and the amount of product you are getting. Speaking of the amount of products, you don't get much, as you can see, but you can't beat the price. If I had known I was going to like them this much I would have ordered more. Now I have an excuse to place another order soon. ;) Anyways, if you really need something like that, order more than one.
I had worn it all day yesterday and found that the staying power is good as well. Mine stayed on for about 12 hours. I'm pretty sure it could last much longer than that, but I usually wash my makeup off at this point.
Oh! And I didn't find the spoolie too rough, as one of the reviewers mentioned. I have the spoolie from the "Essentials" line and I never find myself reaching for it because that one really IS rough and kind of "sparse" . I found this spoolie much softer and I started using it right away; didn't get the urge to grab my regular spoolie.
So yes, I would most definitely recommend this product if the shade matches you. It would be good if they would came out with more shades though. ;)
Most Helpful Critical Review Alright...I'd give it 3.5 stars if I could
I bought this brow pencil in the neutral brown shade and I'm not unhappy or too happy with it.
Color is nice
not too waxy
convenient size (fits well in hand)
fast and easy to use
does the job well enough
brush bristles are really rough and rigid
the pencil "lead" constantly falls out
there is only about 2 inches of the pencil so it will not last you too long
It does the job but it's not that amazing (at all). I'd recommend it to someone who might be new to makeup but I probably will not purchase again
Reviewed by 1760 customers Fantastic product for the price!!!
Fredbaby from Stevenson Ranch, Ca.
I've tried many throughout the years, high end and low end. This has great pigment and is between a cream and a pencil. I will say for those of us with oily skin, it does fade. I would advise you to set it with a powder or eyeshadow. I've been using it for a month and it still has a lot of pencil left. The ABH ran out after a month of use.
Jessie from TX
Once you figure out your color, this product works SO well!
Lex from United States
I didn't expect this to be soo good !!!
Sara from Austin, TX
Great product for the price! Would buy this again.
LOVE IT SM
Ana from NY
u don't even need that much product!! it's cheap and works i love it!! definitely would recommend and buy again 😫☝️
Surprisingly good for the price!
Brow Skeptic from Chicago
I was SHOCKED that I actually liked this brow product - I've used Anastasia Brow Wiz for probably 6 years now, and decided to give this a try because of the price (what do I have to lose?)
I don't know if it's because this pencil is slightly thicker then the Anastasia, but I do my brows in half the time. It might be more pigmented? When I use this, my brows just go on SO quickly, I cannot figure it out. And they still look like natural brow hair strokes. I was a skeptic, but I LOVE this product! Anything to save me time in my routine.
Jay from FL
This is the most dependable eyebrow pencil I have found and surprisingly, also one of the cheapest. I purchase extra's sometimes in advance (in the shade Taupe) just to have on hand for when I run out.
I mean, at that price point - sure!
I have other brow products that come in and out but this has been my constant for years now. I always have one.
My Favorite Eyebrow Pencil
Soph from Fort Collins, Colorado
I love this product so much! The color matches my brows perfectly, and they have a wide variety of colors. It is easy to use and stays on the whole day. It's cheap but the quality is great!
Only eyebrown pencil I'll ever buy
Katie from Missouri
It's so easy to use and to fill my eyebrows in as much or little as I want to for the day. The brush is great to help tame the hairs and the color of the pencil is perfect for what I need. It's the only eyebrow pencil I will use given that it is only 2 bucks too!
Gold from Chicago, IL
I love this brow pencil. It's super cheap and it gets the job done. I only say 4 stars because the pencil disappears quick on my face. I love that because I hate too much makeup on my face and I already have thin eyebrows so by the time the pencil disappears a bit my brows look perfect for me, but if you're someone who likes things a little heavier maybe don't get this pencil OR just lay this pencil on thicker haha.
Samantha from Huntsville, AL
Perfect dupe for ABH skinny brow. All of ELF brow products are dupe for ABH. Save your money and buy ELF. The blonde shade was great, not too warm or red which you find typically in drugstore brow pencils.
I love this product.
Sev from usa
I always have used this product and it never fails to amaze me. It lasts a long time and blends very well.
Good product for price
Sr from Suffolk, Va
I have natural long eyebrow, however I do need to fill in one spot. It does the job. I can't say for drawing in full eyebrows.
My new affordable eyebrow product.
Yanilin. from Mansfield,TX.
I've tried so many eyebrow products even expensive ones and nothing works for me like this affordable option,it applies smoothly,no harsh lines,it doesn't crumple and it is the right shade.
erin from Maryland
It's a pretty good brow pencil, but the tip fell out I just put it in and still used it. Kinda sad it was broken but I still like it.
Kimmie MUA from Delco
I've been using this a couple years off and on. I switch up my brow routine sometimes. for the price this is amazing. it's creamy and it works well.
Kisses from Nv
I love it !
Susanna from PA
The pencil part of this broke off really fast and it fell into the tube and it's not possible to get it out. This probably doesn't happen to all but it happened to mine and it's not possible to fix. I still use the brush part, it's very nice.
Riley from MN
Best eyebrow product you could possibly get for the price! I've been using for years.
Wish there was more product
haeshadae from Greenville, SC
Luckily I don't use this every day, but I wish this came as a pencil that could be sharpened
anc from Station park
I have red hair but my eyebrows are almost transparent. I use this product all the time, it doesn't transfer and it doesn't take much product to yield good results. The auburn color works amazingly for my hair color and I am grateful that they have a redhead option because many brands don't
Ayebee from Ohio
Very waxy and color smudges very bad. Not precise at all of you're looking to defined hairs. Would not recommend. Spoolie at the end is alright.
AngelLove from Florida
I've been using this brow pencil for a year and absolutely love it. The deep brown is beyond perfectly matched for my color and I highly recommend. It goes on blending smoothly and stays in place. I also really love that the Elf brand is not tested on animals and is cruelty free. Thank you!!
Great for the price
C baker from St. Louis
I've turned so many friend on this eyebrow pencil. It's so easy to use especially on quick makeup days. The shade range is great. It's the perfect consistency of waxy and creamy and glides on easily without tugging.
Really liked this brow tool!
Mandy from New York
I fill in front of brow, then use Vaseline to comb it out. Really like that it is very casual.