Rated 4.41 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Adore!
This is my favorite brow pencil. It is very easy to apply and blend and if you have your techniques down can make for a very natural looking brow. The colors are great and true. The only down side is that they smudge like almost any brow pencil, if you set it correctly it will last for you all day just dont rub at all or scratch your brow too much.
Most Helpful Critical Review Love/hate relationship
I love this pencil for when I'm on a budget. But it isn't as thin as I would like it to be, is a bit too creamy and waxy, and looks a little oily by the end of the day if you don't set it. I do need to set it with a brow powder in order to feel confident it won't move throughout the day. I have other products I enjoy more. But I always keep this one on hand because when I work with it I do love how my brows look as my end result. Definitely a good option if you're on a budget.
Reviewed by 728 customers my faaaaaveeeee
eri-cuhh from Arizona
I keep so many extra on deck, its crazy. I love this! Goes on smooth, the color selection is nice, great price. Only slight downside is towards the end of my day or when I've had this on a little toooo long, the product easily smudges off my brows (but I guess this isn't meant to act like permanent brows so its not too bad, just something to consider). I can make my brows bold or natural with this, just depends on how much pressure I apply. Would definitely recommend this to anyone who goes through eyebrow products like crazy.
RainyDayGirl from Pacific Northwest
I had been using another popular expensive brown pencil for years (silver tube). The last few I purchased were dry and I had to drag it to get any color and it would pull out brow hairs, and the tube only lasted may be 3 weeks. A friend turned me on to Elf and it is simply amazing!!! Honestly beats that other high end product hands down and I will never go back, I will keep using this. It glides across my brows with no tugging whatsoever. I recently went to the store and stocked up so I don't run out.
Too thick for my liking
Zaynab from Pleasant Prairie
I like to do thinner strokes so my eyebrows can look natural and this doesn't work for that. Pencil is quite thick and works better for filling in thick eyebrows. Great staying power and decent pigment though, lasts all day and doesn't smudge. Spoolie is quite harsh but you get what you pay for
vivs from Houston
I've never really liked the eyebrow trend, plus I already have pretty full eyebrows but I still like to add a little bit of eyeshadow when I do my makeup. I wanted to try something new and decided on this because elf has amazing products for a great price. I've been practicing little by little and loving the results! you can definitely fill in by your preference
eh, it's just okay..
panda from new mexico
it's a bit too thick for me..i prefer a thin point on my pencil..however, the pigment is good. so it'll do for now.
Super affordable and such a quality product!!
Nadine from Fair Lawn, NJ
I got the color deep brown and it's a little too dark so I exchanged it for neutral brown and it matches my brows perfectly!! I love this brow pencil it's so affordable and so easy to use!! The only con is that it runs out fast with everyday use because it doesn't come with a lot of product, but for $2 it's easily replicable every couple of weeks.
ariana asf from CA
i love thissss! its so affordable and easy to use! i usually would use glossier boy brow, but i honestly love this more it makes my eyebrows look amazing
It immediately broke
EricaT123 from OH
I actually really like elf and think they have some great dupes and some great bang for your buck products. However, this little guy was very cheap. It broke before one use. Their eyebrow promade is nice though!
Michelle from Washington
If I ran out of my normal eyebrow product I would turn to this. It's just not my favorite because it's kind of waxy feeling. When I filled in my eyebrows with this I could feel it on my face and I don't really like the feeling. It might be because I like more of a on fleek eyebrow so it's probably because i used to much of it.
Super great value
Liz from Iowa
I have never used an eyebrow pencil before. I loved the price to try it out. The color was a great match!
Natural Gal from Texas
It fills in the spaces of my brow nicely. It doesn't make them look over done and I like to use it by shading in lightly, if go a little over I comb them with the brush. It goes best with some brow gel on top. I just touch it up a bit. So this pencil covers the small bald spots and the gel defines it.
It gives it a more complete, natural, and full look.
The Auburn color is nice
R. Jones from IN
The Auburn color is perfect for me. This product is surprisingly good. The spoolie is great, the tip is retractable, and the whole thing works well.
Great product and affordable
Valerie from Frisco, TX
Works great, no complaints
This product is perfect for someone with white brows
Joe mama from Chula Vista
I'm a redhead and my brows are like white. I kinda just draw a line where my brow is and I use the spoolie and blend it and it blends very well. I love every thing about this product and they better never get rid of it!
Great for the price!
Shopper AA from Harker Heights, TX
I usually use the colourpop pencil but after going into ultra and seeing that someone opened ALL of the colourpop pencils, I decided to look for something else. I purchased this pencil and it delivered! I love the color match and it glides on smooth. It doesn't shine so you get a nice natural brow. It stayed for most of the day and didn't sweat off. Now to the con- initial precision is good but the tip starts to bend and you have to constantly turn/rotate when filling in to keep a pointed tip. So if you like to fill in your brows with allot of short strokes to simulate the appearance of individual hairs, this will be tough. But for the price, you can't beat it!! I'll repurchase but also have a more precise pencil for the days that I want full glam.
In love with this pencil
Vanessa from USA
This is an amazing pencil for the price! Definitely universal when it comes to the type of brow you are aiming for!
Rylee from Florida
I was looking for a simple eyebrow pencil and stumbled upon this one and it works amazingly. I never expected it to work like this but it makes your brows so defined, even and nice that you can barely tell that you did anything to them. It just looks so natural. And that is a really good price.
I love this product! It is great for the price!
Crystal the Pistol from UT
I love the ease to use this product! It is so simple and I love the color options.
Pair with wax pen and you have a match made in heaven!
Oneplustwins from New Jersey
Glides on effortlessly.
My favorite brow pencil on a budget
Kiki from Sioux Falls, SD
I like a thicker brow pencil for shaping my brows and so far this is my favorite!
Niya from My house
This is such a soft and pigmented pencil. It just glides and fills in my brow so easily. It's also very durable, but can be cleaned off easily. I love and highly recommended it!
Fav inexpensive brand
Sarah from Western NY
With the pandemic going on and still working two jobs, funds seem to still be tight. This is my favorite inexpensive brow pencil and gets the job done right!
Taylor from Sunny Isles Beach
I like it because it is soft and does not mistreat the skin
Wrong color again
Tone Tone from CHICAGO, iL
I love Elf product. The product went on smoove but the color I choose was to light.
Maddi S. from Southern Indiana
The overall quality for the price is GREAT, but generally it's a bit thin, as it almost wipes off when you try to brush it out. Again, it is great for the price, and the brush is worth the $2 alone