Product Reviews Rated 4.09 out of 5 stars
302 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review I got the wrong color but I love this I heard it was very similar to the tarte shape-tape concealer but I like it better! I never set my eyes and I don't get that much creasing only the minimal because I live in a very hot city therefore creasing is inevitable. When I do set it it does not crease at all and it lasts throughout the day. I used to use the L'Oréal one with the sponge at the top (I don't recall the name) but after a few hours it would look like I didn't have makeup on. I would also use the Morphe concealer and it would last a little longer than the L'Oréal but the E.l.f one lasts waaay more! The formula is high coverage but it's very lightweight. I have really dry skin so concealer always hurts my eyes but this one doesn't because it doesn't dry my eyes out. My only complaint would be that at first when the product is brand new it can get a lot on the brush and sometimes this makes a very messy container but it's manageable, I'm a little bit of a clean freak and I could work with it so if you're not you're good.
Also, I didn't pick the right color and I got a very dark color so I had to change it. I do think the descriptions are very accurate online but I got a "light beige" when my foundation is a light beige so I chose the wrong color. I chose a lighter shade and this one worked really well.
Most Helpful Critical Review Cakey and drying on skin I ordered directly from elf's website so the complaints about customer service have nothing to do with ulta itself. I received a much lighter color than what I ordered, and although I was disappointed, I thought that maybe I could mix it with something more my color to get the best fit. The concealer ended up looking dry and splotchy, and I had to redo my entire face so I wouldn't look as if my under eyes were cracking. The next time I used it, I applied a small amount as I usually would do concealer (without mixing), and I had the same result. Drying, cakey, cracked, splotchy, and all around just not a product I'd reach for again. Every once in a while I try again in hopes that I had done something wrong, but I get the same result every time and either have to re-do my entire base or cover it up with my foundation. I've wondered if it was maybe because the color is too light and just looks bad on my skin, but I'm not willing to buy another concealer from elf to find out. I'm considering using it as a base for eyeshadow, but I dont want to risk having the same cracking/drying effect on my eyes. I really wanted to love this product since I didn't have a concealer and don't want to be harsh, but bottom line is that you get what you pay for, and I won't be using this concealer ever again.
Reviewed by 302 customers Cakey and drying on skin 1
alex from azusa CA
I ordered directly from elf's website so the complaints about customer service have nothing to do with ulta itself. I received a much lighter color than what I ordered, and although I was disappointed, I thought that maybe I could mix it with something more my color to get the best fit. The concealer ended up looking dry and splotchy, and I had to redo my entire face so I wouldn't look as if my under eyes were cracking. The next time I used it, I applied a small amount as I usually would do concealer (without mixing), and I had the same result. Drying, cakey, cracked, splotchy, and all around just not a product I'd reach for again. Every once in a while I try again in hopes that I had done something wrong, but I get the same result every time and either have to re-do my entire base or cover it up with my foundation. I've wondered if it was maybe because the color is too light and just looks bad on my skin, but I'm not willing to buy another concealer from elf to find out. I'm considering using it as a base for eyeshadow, but I dont want to risk having the same cracking/drying effect on my eyes. I really wanted to love this product since I didn't have a concealer and don't want to be harsh, but bottom line is that you get what you pay for, and I won't be using this concealer ever again.
I would buy again 4
Leslie from Texarkana to
I use it on my everyday
Good price, for a good product. 4
James the Sister from Los Angeles, California
Make sure to apply thin layers or else it will layer on pasty.
Not good 1
Just another makeup lover from Missouri
I bought this concealer because it was hyped up to be a dupe for shape tape, a concealer I love. I have oily skin and some wrinkles in the under eye area. This product was a horrible mess when I used it. Everyone's skin is different, so keep that in mind. This concealer creased so bad under the eye, it oxidized about 2 (yes, 2 shades!!!!), and it looked like I had used drywall spackle from the cakey look. Forget about trying to set this concealer, it will suck the life out of your skin. It just did not work for me.
Patchy 2
H from Michigan
I so wanted to like because everyone hyped it and it's so cheap! But it completely departed my foundation leaving me super patchy :(
Love It! 5
Sandoon from Buffalo, NY
It covers up so nicely
Great 4
Brianna from CA
It has great coverage and blends nice. I just wish there were more options for tan and deep complexions with more olive undertones as well
LOVE 5
Steph from Chicago
I have dry skin and don't usually like to wear concealers due to having to use setting powder to set it. I wear this without setting powder under my eyes and lasts all day.
a m a z i n g 5
morgan from Masontown Pa
this concealer is everything. i used to use the matte camo concealer, it was sooo dry but i loved the coverage. this concealer is AMAZING. the finish and the coverage are to die for and its not even heavy.
HUGE but decent concealer. 3
Rose from New England
Nice concealer to add to my collection, but maybe not my top choice. Creases pretty easily. A TON of product! Huge gluestick-sized concealer.
Yes Coverage! 4
Lee from New York
I needed a new concealer and saw this one on social media. Specifically the hydrating one. And let me tell you it is full coverage. I'm not too much of the big applicator because the product seems to glob onto one side of it. Other than that it's a great concealer and the color is accurate for me
Better than shape Tape! 5
Bpalms from Oregon
This concealer is the first and only that I have found to provide awesome coverage and keep my under eye looking flawless all day long. I love it so much!
new favorite concealer 5
Jasmine from San Antonio, TX
So I am on the quest to save money, I switched from my Loreal Pro Glo Concealer to this one and I LOVE IT! I will never go back. I love the packaging, coverage, and I found my perfect shade match. A little goes a long way with beautiful results but it is also buildable. This concealer is wonderful and at a great price!
Perfect for dry skin! 5
Cassidy from 5
I use this product without any foundation just to cover up small blemishes or lighten my under-eye circles. I LOVE IT! I have extremely dry skin and have had a hard time finding concealers that don't flake up or completely remove any little moisture I have from my skin. I am definitely going to keep coming back to this product for my everyday concealer!
great concealer, terrible color selection 4
chaqattack from miami,fl
this concealer is awesome !! great coverage and makes your skin look healthy and glowy. the only con is that color selection is awful. i bought the shade "light sand" because the website said it was a neutral beige but when i swatched it at home it was a dark peach color. So just look out for that
This is my jam 4
Elainna from Virginia
I truly love this product like this is now my holy grail. I will say I hate that it starts to dry quickly but tbh you just have to blend it out. If you allow it to "dry" it will be tough to work with. I love that it's full coverage and a little goes a long way! The applicator is great! ELF did their thing
A little goes a longgg way! 5
gmel from Chicago
Love this! But a little def goes a long way.
I primarily use this for my under eye circles.
Best concealer 5
Ness from Cincinnati ohio
Wonderful shade and coverage for a great price
Not enough shade options 3
Ellie from Wisconsin
I love the formula and the feeling of this concealer. It is a huge bummer that it wont be available to a lot of women and men since the shades are all lighter colors. How are you supposed to find your shade when there are only four even close to your skin tone?
AMAZING CONCEALER! 5
MonG from Lafayette, IN
I use this production to help even out my skin tone. I spot conceal, carve out my eyebrows, and put under my eyes. The shade I use is very similar to my foundation, but a bit lighter.
my ride or die 5
kait from omaha
this is the best concealer i've ever used, and i've tried A LOT of concealers. it has the full coverage of shape tape but it's so hydrating and doesn't get cakey. so beautiful! i'll never use another concealer brand..
Amazing for the price 5
Anuja from Allen, Texas
It's so full coverage and is AMAZING for my dry skin. You only need a little bit to cover up your entire under eye. It's not cakey at all and just sweeps into your skin.
I finally found "my" concealer! 5
Victoria from OH
I'm a medium-toned person, with a HIGHLY oily T-zone, who works 8 hour shifts. I've tried all the popular concealers, and some drugstore, and none of them had the right color and texture. I tried this in shade "light ivory" because my skin tends to melt off or absorb skin products and I've had to use much brighter concealers to compensate. For one fourth of the price of the "standard" concealers, this one works so well.
I always moisturize, occasionally prime, use foundation, and then blend this in while my foundation is still settling. Three solid dots (not per face area, but TOTAL) does the highlighting that I need it to. I don't use powder over it because I found that powder tends to make it super cakey, but setting spray helps it stick. It's also a great base for my eyeshadows. After a full day, my highlight is still there, no matter how much I sweat, and it doesn't crease up if I only use a small amount. And at this price? Amazing.
it's a no from me 2
leslie from Tennessee
I love elf, but this product missed the mark for me. I love hydrating products because I have super dry skin, but this concealer is so thick, cakey, and drying. It's hard to work with in my opinion and it does not sit well on my skin, with or without primer. I am very experienced in applying make up and I just couldnt make it work for me.
Love this product 5
Jamie from Loma Linda
This give me great coverage for easy days!
