Rated 3.37 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Holy Grail!!!
Definitely love this product! This was the first liquid eye liner I ever tried, Its so easy to use! I'm just a bit disappointed to see that elf is beginning to raise up the prices on their essentials products.
Most Helpful Critical Review WHAT HAPPENED
I've been using this eyeliner in black for years, and have literally recommended it to all of my friends. Then, all of a sudden, it changed. I bought a new black one recently and it wouldn't go on in a solid line. Even if I tried to go over it to make it darker, it was too runny and wouldn't go on in a solid line. I thought it was a fluke, so I bought another, but I had the same problem. Bring back the old formula, whatever it was... :(
Reviewed by 686 customers Favorite eyeliner!
Antonia from USA
Super cheap and works amazing!
Nice, but sheer and hard to get fine lines
Shelli from Minneapolis, MN
I like the product okay. The tip of the brush is not really sharp enough to get thin lines and points, which is a little disappointing. And the liquid is a little thin which makes it a little hard to use because if you want a deep color you might have to reapply.
Lovely bird from Wichita ks
Very good liquid black works well everytime
beats kat von d !
. from .
it's amazing and one of the best eyeliners i've ever used !
Best liquid liner
Amanda from Olympia, WA
I have tried over and over to find a felt tip liquid liner and I just could not get the hang of it. I finally grabbed this to try and it's the best, most precise I've ever been able to do a winged liner.
Shoffy from Florida
I buy this eye liquid liner and work perfect ease to use long day
So sheer, not good for newbies
Zonara from Orange Counth, CA
This eyeliner is SO SHEER. I had to go over the same line multiple times to get it to be a solid color. I have one from LA colors that was one dollar and opaque in one coat!! If you are a beginner, going over the same line can be difficult without messing up. Not worth it.
Great eyeliner and color payoff- def needs a steady hand
Fi from New York
I absolutely love this eyeliner. but it def needs a steadier hand than pen-like eyeliners. It also needs a few minutes to dry. not waterproof!!! if u cry it'll run down ur face a little bit.
My go to!
Kat98 from Illinois
This is my go to eyeliner. I like the thin, soft brush. I can't find many liquid eyeliners with paintbrush like brushes. I love it!
Lourd from Michigan
Easy to control and apply.
Very good and affordable.
Go-to liner, practical applicator
KornFan2112 from undisclosed
The first time I used this eyeliner was on the day of my middle school graduation. Now I am in college and I'm still impressed by how well this product works. It is perfect for experimenting with cat-eye looks, and for the price it is a fantastic product. It also lasts a really long time. Before COVID, I would wear eyeliner every day to school and one bottle lasted me the whole school year. That's a lot of cat eyes! The applicator is great and the color of the liner is bold and vibrant.
tgffvt from England
Been using this for years. I've tried others but honestly, nothing compares to this one. PLEASE BUY IT'S AWESOME!!!!
AmandaM14 from Davenport, FL
I am so happy with this eyeliner, it's so pigmented and easy to use.
Shagun from undisclosed
I bought this and it was completely dried up and I couldn't use it. I would never buy it again
Only liner I'll ever need
Lexie from Tennessee
I can't get enough of this eyeliner! I switched from high end to this, and I am never going back. It's so easy to use, creates a precise wing, dries MATTE and lasts all day! This beats out any other liner I've tried.
A little disappointing...
samanthag from Herndon, Virginia
I bought this a few years ago and fell in love. I actually like the dipping pot eyeliners way better than the pen. I usually use a mix of Mary Kay and e.l.f. products and I needed to use up an MK eyeliner that I had bought, so I hadn't purchased this e.l.f. liner in a while. It's disappointing now! The application is streaky and takes three to four coats to really get that solid black line. I have to use it over top of the MK eyeliner to really get that black look. I bought it because my MK eyeliner is a little gray, but upsetting I have to use them together. I don't know what happened to the formula!
Period luv from undisclosed
The liner really can get so precise it is also one of the very few liners that don't make my eyes water y'all need to try this it is awesome
Sjsharks408 from San Jose, CA
My friend brought me this liner and its the best liner I've used that doesn't bother my eyes
Madiiadm from Ny
Works better then my expensive eyeliner! Lasts long and a lot of product in the container.
great for beginners
Gal1 from London
I bought this when I first started wearing eyeliner and I learned how to do eyeliner with it.
My favorite makeup product ever
Olivia from Los Angeles
If I could only use one makeup product for the rest of my life, it would be this. It may be a little hard for beginners since it's a brush instead of a felt tip, but if you're confident in applying eyeliner with a brush I'd HIGHLY recommend it.
Ashton from North Port, FL
i'm a beginner, & this stuff is awesome! especially for the price, way better than my more expensive other brand. the photo is literally my first use & my first time using this type of liner. i got the sharpie kind as recommended for beginners, total waste.
Holy Grail Eyeliner
angiepangie79 from Washington
This is my all time favorite eyeliner. Its the only one I repurchase over and over, and always have on hand. I love the thin, flexible brush, and that the consistency is on the thinner side. It applies so easily whether I want to so a super thin, minimal liner look or a full on wing. Its also long lasting and very pigmented. The price is also unbeatable.
I buy this product and this one only for my liquid eyeliner
Bex from Aspen, co
This is my favorite because it does not bug my eyes like other eyeliners
this eyeliner is awesome!
chauder8 from tampa, fl
i ran out of my usual eyeliner about a month ago so i decided to try this one out. it was cheap, so i wasn't expecting much out of it. when i tried it on it worked beautifully! the brush is precise and if you wipe off a bit of the eyeliner off of the brush you can get a really thin line. what amazed me most is that the eyeliner lasted on my eyes for so long. i put it on at 6:30am, went to school for 7 hours, went home and chilled for a bit, and went on a run until 10:00pm. the eyeliner lasted the entire time!