Product Reviews Rated 2.83 out of 5 stars
952 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review The BEST liquid eyeliner out there! I love using tons of different eyeshadow types and I usually apply this eyeliner pen OVER the shadow just to keep the color consistant and the liner glides on smooth, doesn't fade or crease. I love the pen tip because I'm a notorious "wing" girl and love that it's soo precise that I never NEVER have to use anything to correct it (unless It's my error. I bought soo many just in case they decide to discontinue it. LOL
Most Helpful Critical Review Poor longevity Well I've been giving this product (in the shade Coffee Brown) plenty of trial because I really like other elf liquid product. But this eyeliner just doesn't doing its job. Advertised as waterproof, the product glides as a dream for an easy application, beautifully first, but only after an hour wear, it smudged and got all over my eye makeup, became uneven and lost its sharpness.
It's absolutely not waterproof, I used it with another elf setting spray and the mist made my liner BLED out brown. Basically, I can use only my finger and rub this thing of even without presence of any moisture
Reviewed by 952 customers long lasting 5
rosanna248 from california
the color is very pigmented and lasts for a long time
this is great. I... 5
Mariama from undisclosed
this is great. I bought this for a friend and she loved it.
I wouldn't purchase again. 1
JJ from Georgia
I use eyeliner to line the lips of my eyes, for the cat look and I love elf, but they dropped the ball with this product. The liquid in this is more gray, it goes on with a very thin consistency. And even if you try to trace over it to build it up it just makes more gray lines through what you've already put on. I was not happy with this purchase at all, don't waste your money.
only liquid i use 5
gwen from NJ
I cannot do a wing and I am not good with liquid liners. I use this to do a natural look right along my lashes, and its perfect. not too much comes out, so its easy for shaky hands like mine. It also doesn't dry too fast so its forgiving. I've been through 3, but im sure there is better quality for people who have skills.
Nice, but the coffee is just like black 3
Jgonz from Florida
I used it for the first time today. Easy enough to use, but the coffee color is pretty much black. I am light skinned and tend to find that black liner makes my eyes look small so I always opt for a brown. This is really dark, and doesnt look brown at all on my lids.
LOVE THIS PEN 5
Dinah from Florida
Very easy to use and I love the brown! This is my go-to liner. Very long lasting yet easy to remove!
Okay for Beginners 3
Alexia Gonzalez from New York, NY
I am a beginner with eyeliner and this was very easy to use, definitely recommend for that. The only con is that the color isn't dark enough, I got black and it came up as kinda streaky. However, I would still recommend as this issue is probably just a defect in my individual product.
I definitely like it! 5
Jesica V. from round rock, TX
easy to use and It dry faster
Wasn't able to use this liner. 1
Rae from Tucson
Unfortunately this product went from store to trash. I tried using it but it was dry and wouldn't work unless I applied way to much pressure.
Love it! 5
Jlee824 from Fordsville, ky
I've bought a couple different brands of liquid eyeliner that left me disappointed before but when I tried this product I feel in love. It works great and very inexpensive.
I liked it 4
Jess from htown from Houston, tx
I liked the eyeliner for what it's worth. I wouldn't say it's completely waterproof. I have very watery eyes or I'm always crying so I need it not to smudge. It did last all day but when I touched my eye I did find residue on my fingers. I would buy it again- it's easy to use and I like the felt tip.
Great price 4
Itsgr8 from undisclosed
Good overall except it does smudge if you rub your eyes.
Works great! 5
Val in OC from Orange County
Works great, easy to apply and you can't beat the price! Its does occasionally transfer onto my eyelids, but I have very oily skin (could probably be avoided with a primer). Great for beginners who need to practice their technique and everyday wear.
Very good steal 5
Bo from New Jersey
This eyeliner is very underestimated. It serves very well compared to its price! The only inconvenience is the smudging effect when removing it. Totally recommend it!
Great eyeliner but sometimes hit or miss 4
Dbhenry26 from Michigan
I come back to this eyeliner again and again, so I definitely like it. I have it in coffee and black as I have dark features and like to choose the color depending on my look for the day. I do say it's hit or miss because sometimes it does dry out fast. I've also had times when the cap pops off if I didn't secure it all the way (and obviously it dries out super quick without a cap). It's so inexpensive though that I don't mind having to buy a new one every couple of months. Great for beginners as a basic eyeliner, nothing too fancy. Love that it's waterproof
great liner for beginners 4
Kelsey A from los angeles, CA
this was the first eyeliner I tried at it's great for beginners.
It does what you'd expect of its price 2
bluejay from undisclosed
I bought this as a newbie learning to apply eyeliner bec I wanted something cheap to practice with. Well, it's an eyeliner, it lines your eyes, I'd say it has an average drying time. It smudges with even a ***slight*** contact with water. It's not too long-lasting. I'd recommend this if you're trying to learn to apply eyeliner bec you can just wash it off with a slightly damp tissue if you're not too happy with how your eyeliner looks. But if you want a long-lasting eyeliner, best get some other product. This one's like a super washable marker. It does have a fairly nice point which makes it nice to cat-eyes, and the pigment is fairly pigmented, but it won't go to a jet black and you may have to go over the lines over and over to get a darker colour. It's not too pigmented on the first swipe. So I'd say it does what you'd expect of eyeliner of its price range. Also, there's like a tiny cap inside of the cap, mine came off after a few months. The eyeliner was super pigmented when it was new. But a few weeks in, it turns to not be so pigmented anymore.
Complicated product 1
nancy1 from California
This eyeliner applicator has a really sharp and firm nothing like a brush that should be anywhere near the eye. Liquid is really runny and bleeds.
Note: not for use for someone with unsteady hands or sensitive skin
Leaves Stain on Skin 2
DD from SF, CA, USA
I have used this for a while now, and every time I remove my makeup, I get an orange/yellow stain on my lid afterwards (using the brown shade.) I love the brush tip, but I will not be repurchasing again.
Good eyeliner - poor amount of usage 2
Caitlin from Merseyside
I really liked this eyeliner the first time I used it, applied really well and lasted incredibly. However, I only got one use out of it, when I came to use it the next day it was dried out (cap had been replaced properly and stored upside down as per recommendations!)
Not worth it 1
T Henson from Austin, TX
Horrible and dry. Do not waste your time.
Great Results 5
BarbieS1987 from Brenton, WV
This glides on effortlessly and I love my results. I have the brown and it wears well. I love the pen shape, I feel it's easier to apply than most eyeliners. The pen shape with cap lid is easy to carry with me in my purse.
Great Results 5
BarbieS1987 from Wyoming, WV
This glides on effortlessly and I love my results. I have the brown and it wears well. I love the pen shape, I feel it's easier to apply than most eyeliners. The pen shape with cap lid is easy to carry with me in my purse.
Would buy again 5
Hi from Sanford FL
Bought it in store, pen looks cute and eyeliner works great.
Would buy again 5
hi from Sanford FL
The pen looks so cute, and works really well. It is kind of hard to get it off, but it was fine. I just bought it yesterday in the store, and I love it.
