Product Reviews Rated 4.36 out of 5 stars
907 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Wonderful Lengths, Thickness And it Lasts All Day I use it liberally in the morning with a few light touch ups during the day. As good or better than the more expensive brands and I've tried many but have settled on this one.
Most Helpful Critical Review Just OK After hearing and reading so many good things about this mascara, my curiosity was piqued, so I tried it. Let me preface my review by saying that mascara is very personal, based on the type of eyelashes that you have. In my opinion, this mascara would be great for someone with very thick lashes who simply wants to add a little length. I have average-ish lashes and for me, this was just OK. It does not flake and it stays on well. I did not really care for the look that I achieved after applying 2-3 coats. It really is not a volumizing mascara and my lashes were borderline "spider-like." So I will be returning it. It is not bad, but it is not for me. I am sticking with my NYX "Doll Eye" volumizing mascara.
Reviewed by 907 customers Good, solid mascara 4
The Nerd from Modesto, CA
I love how the wand separates my eyelashes but I do wish it added more volume. It's not waterproof but it does stay on all day without smudging.
Empty Tube 1
Miranda from Pennsylvania
When I got this I opened it and saw there was no mascara on the wand but I thought I just had to move it around in the tube a bit but there was no mascara in there the tube was completely empty
Best mascara ever 5
Kwags from Wisconsin
Make your eyelashes look long and tangle free. Best brush applicator I've ever used! I've been using this mascara for 10+ years and would never even consider another mascara.
Ingredient List is Wrong 1
Ria from San Jose, CA
The ingredient list online does not match the ingredients on the packaging. Product has parabens that I am allergic to but these were not listed on the ingredient list online. Would not have bought if the correct ingredient list was posted online due to my sensitivity to those ingredients...
LOOOVE 5
Laura from San Diego
Makes my lashes SO SO LONG AND BEAUTIFUL!! The wand is a little unsteady but you just have to be careful with it.
Wand broke off in the tube 1
Tyra from the Bronx from New York
After my second use I tried to put the wand back in the tube and snap! The bristle end broke right off in the tube. I thought I might try to retrieve it with a tweezer but to what end? I can't use the product with another brush because clearly the narrow tube opening won't allow it. Waste of money.
Disappointed. 1
mascara addict from Az
I bought this mascara with high hopes after using L'oreal's other mascaras which were amazing. It gave me length and was pretty black but the darkness didn't even matter because it made my eyelashes so thin! I had spider leg lashes after the first, second, and third coat.
One of my favorite mascara!! 5
Sue of the South from Chauvin, La.
I love that it makes my short lashes super long!! Love the wand the best I've ever tried!! Doesn't smudge and stays all day!!!
Hmm 3
Lulu from Seattle
I have a feeling they changed the formula. Doesn't work the same when applying. This used to be my holy grail mascara
Love this for lengthening 5
Lex from NJ
Love this mascara. I use it to lengthen my lashes after applying a volumizing mascara
BEST MASCARA EVER 5
Bree from Ca
You see all the good reviews, buy it!!! I have very straight lashes and they are not long at all but what I do is first put on a volumizing mascara and then this adds the LENGTH!!
Bad wand 2
Madeline from Oregon
The wand on this mascara is so flimsy it won't go back in the tube on its own and it's horribly frustrating. The product is ok. It used to be one of my favorite mascaras but they really messed up the wand and the product just isn't as impressive as it used to be... bummed
Love it 4
Evie from Brooklyn from Brooklyn NY
This product is amazing, I love the consistency, the thin brush that allows you to get fully close to the lid, great for bottom lashes, the only thing is when you pull out the wand it's great, no excess mascara comes out, but putting the wand back in it's a struggle, if you push really fast and hard you can break the wand. That is the only complaint.
Highly recommend 5
I from Al
It stayed on really well while I sobbed for 20 minutes and comes off easily when I remove my makeup. 10/10
You need to try it! It's the best 5
Sunflower from Long branch, NJ
I have been using this mascara for about 3 years and I love it. It doesn't flake up and it's basically water proof. Makes my eye lashes look longer.
best mascara ever 5
Kate from USA
Have tried what feels to be every mascara at the store. This mascara makes my lashes longer than any other. It's best to use another mascara with this to add volume.
My favorite mascara!! 5
Kam from Loudoun, Virginia
I have been using this mascara for over 4 years and I have tried many many others (low and high end) and I continuously buy this product again and again!! It doesn't transfer either. I have super dark lashes and hair and I've struggled to find a mascara that is black enough. Carbon Black is by far my favorite.
Will not purchase again 1
Brittany from Salisbury, MD
Product brush was DAMAGED.
Hard to put wand back into container 1
Gina from Tucson, AZ
I would not recommend this product
I've repurchased over and over 5
Isa from Pasco Washington
Love this product, I've purchased this 3 times since January... i naturally have thick eyelashes but this mascara really help make them look fuller and thicker, I don't even have to wear lashes anymore. But I think I use a lot or maybe there isn't a lot in the bottle.. not sure but will still continue to use it
Worst mascara I have ever tried. 1
Angry from Nebraska
Worst wand and product. I will be returning!
I always go back to this 4
Luhhndynn from Utah
Lengthens like crazy and you can do multiple applications without it clumping. Definitely recommend if you want length. If you want thickness like false lashes, don't buy it. If you want a natural look, this is perfect.
I've used this mascara for years 5
Kristi from Chattanooga
I've used this mascara for years. I will not use anything else!
I would not buy this again 1
Karmen from Eureka ca
Works well on extending and separating lashes but have to really battle with getting wand back into tube
overall great buy! 4
uhhhhazel from california
love this mascara. I recommend this mascara for those who have medium to long eyelashes as it separates your lashes for a longer effect. Super easy to apply, has never gotten clumpy on me and overall looks beautiful. This being said, the down side is that there is always crumbs on my under eye after a couple hours of wear which means you have to constantly check and clean your under eyes otherwise it makes your under eyes looks black and baggy. If it wasn't for this i would give it 5/5 stars. Hope this helped !
