Rated 4.37 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review could be slightly perfected but i will still buy
I received both pioneer and lover for free to review from influenster and this is what I have to say about them..
Packaging: sleek and simple , love the wand you can be precise and also the hole in the center packs extra for main filling. The wand gives you good control.
The color of PIONEER is like that of a red rose to me and i love that i can see the violet undertones.. i will definitely be purchasing patriot again and some of the more deeper shades.
LOVER is subtle and pretty , it has a nice color and isn't too bright or too dark for my skin type, good pink.
Both LOVER AND PIONEER have a matte finish as advertised.
Advise: You only need to apply once, i don't recommend applying twice
the texture is a little sticky but not so much that i can't handle it.
I have ate burgers with these lipsticks and they hold up great.
only time i noticed a good difference is when i ate an overly greasy pizza
The lippies are removed with oil, i personally choose coconut oil and it does it's job, i would say don't skimp out on your oil, use a good amount and removing it shouldn't be a problem.
Cons/ It could be a tiny bit less tacky and i'm sure if they had more of a selection of shades they would be even more popular.
I am excited to try more of the deeper shades soon :)
Most Helpful Critical Review Thanks for the unwanted tattoo Matte ink
I brought 2 of these today and the colors are amazing, but this product is a nightmare. It stain my lip. It took was to much make up remove to get off. If it's gonna take more than 10minutes to take off I rather buy a lipstick I have to reapply every hour. Don't wanna worry about the product being stuck on my lips.
Reviewed by 18616 customers Voyager for the win
Teacheroflearning from New Philadelphia, OH
Favorite long wear matte lip stain. Color is nice for day and night. Bold. Red but not too dark or light.
Yes It's Worth It
Alys from Minnesota
LOVE it. It not only smells great but is so soft and stays on so well. I do need some touch up towards the end of the night but not much. The color is bomb and it does not dry out your lips like other matte lipsticks
Best lip for face mask!
Molly from Michigan
I have a lippie obsession so I wear something everyday even under a face mask where most lip products smear all over my face. Not this one! Best lip product I've tried under a face mask! And I've tried many lip stains! Lasts through coffee, water, lunch and 8 plus hours of face masks! It wore off around the very center of my lips after lunch but I didn't reapply, just left as is and it was still presentable. No smearing under face mask either! After dinner it wore off and got splotchy but that's understandable. Totally awesome. Buying more shades now!
Oh Lawd, She Sticky
Zoe from Boulder, CO
I'm a very sensitive individual, so this may not be a make or break for most, but HOO BOY, this lipstick sure is sticky. I thought it was just an issue while drying, but nope. I kept it on for about an hour and the stickiness did not go away.
It's also VERY difficult to remove, which is to be expected, since it's supposed to be long lasting. I'd suggest those who purchase this product also invest in a Makeup Eraser, since the removal process will exfoliate your lips regardless of what product you use, so you might as well use a soft product with no chemicals that could get in your mouth.
RillLil from Colton, Ca
It does last but gets a dry cracking look and feels dry on my lips. It did transfer a couple of times to my cups and mask.
Mask proof, drink proof, life proof
Appy from The void
This stuff is actually difficult to remove. Stays put underneath a mask all day except in my experience the corners of my mouth. I apply at least two coats though, letting each coat dry completely in between. With three coats of all nighter setting spray, I couldn't remove it without a sugar scrub. Amazing. Wish all lipstick wore like this, because I'm not crazy about a matte lip all the time.
Evi from Los Angeles, CA
I picked this up on a whim because one of my fave influencers raves about it. I tried it later that night with a Morphe "sweet tea" lip liner and it's the perfect gorgeous nude lip. Also it barely transfers, I ate oily food after applying and it only removed a bit but not enough to be noticeable.
Long lasting but not the most comfortable to wear
Ash from Kansas City
Make sure to moisturize your lips before using and/or use a gloss on top but you may have to reapply the gloss if you do wear one. There's a little bit of stickiness but I didn't notice it too much unless I really put my lips together. Other than those two things it really is a great product and will really stay through eating, drinking and talking. It's overall a pretty good product.
I like these more than I thought I would and I have multiple
Diamond_rose from Chicago
The colors are amazing, paired with a lip liner they are amazing! So many compliments!
Strong smell, okay staying power
Chipmunk from Ohio
When I first opened it the scent was super strong and has a very fake vanilla scent. Personally, I find it off putting. Second, I've never had any of the SuperStay lippies before but it did transfer and it stained longer than I liked.
Amazing! MASK PROOF!
Babydoll from East La
I got this just because I've always heard good things and figured why not try the make it black edition....so glad i did. Wore it a full shift under a mask, ate & drank and it did NOT move! NO feathering, NO bleeding absolutely love it. I think some people might have not had the same results if they used a lip balm or something right before applying this because this is so amazing I can't imagine it not working well but I just left vaseline on while i did my face then wiped it off to apply the lipstick and had no problems.
Ayesha from New York
Great lipstick with affordable price.. it's not makes lips dry..
Perfect, long lasting lipstick!
Johnelle from Texas
These matte lipsticks last all day and night even while wearing a mask! They are also very pigmented!
I would not buy this again
Sea Girl from Hiram, Ga.
This product is very drying. Cannot use it because it feathers.
Alex from Pennsylvania
Wanted to love it so bad. It seems like everyone loves Maybelline super stay matte ink, but I don't get the hype, because it wasn't matte, and it made my lips feel gross. The only reason it's not one star is because I do enjoy the fact that it's not patchy.
This lipstick never comes off and does not dry out your lips
Jacqueline from Peoria. Il
I put it on early and it stays on despite drinking hot drinks or eating. The lipstick you have been looking for
Stays on forever and is transfer proof
Becca W. from MD
I love matte liquid lipsticks and these are the best for the price. They last forever, even through eating and wearing a mask. The color range is phenomenal. I have high end and low end options, but these are the best. I can't believe I slept on these for so long. By the end of the night they are a little drying, but not the worst I've experienced. If you like a matte liquid lipstick, look no further, buy this one!
Stays on but drying to lips
Jules from Chicago
It's one of the few products that stays on all day but the choice of colors is too intense for regular wear. I only wear it under a mask so it doesn't come off onto the mask but otherwise would not wear it for every day
Top Drugstore Lipstick
Haf from NJ
This is one of the best drugstore lipstick. It really does stay on a long time without a smudge of smearing. My husband always checks to make sure that I don't stain his lips with my lipsticks...this one he approves!
A HUGE Mess
Mary from North Carolina
I've been using high-end lipsticks for awhile, but I've been tempted to go back to Maybelline after I tried their ink crayon and thought they were making good moves. Someone suggested this product to me and I bought the shade "Pioneer." I wore it for the first time on my birthday, and although the pigment and color was nice (not a true red, though), it was incredibly sticky and goopy all day. It gets on EVERYTHING, and the only reason it "lasts" is because it stains really bad - so you have to commit to wearing a stain for at least 24 hours if you put it on. With it retailing for $10, just spend a little extra for a decent brand lipstick that won't leave you a sticky, stained mess.
Love this lip's
Carmen from Haines city
Why is it sticky?
Dee from Somewhere Around Here
When I think of long wearing matte lipstick it evokes a finish like Anastasia's liquid lipsticks. It dries down quickly, very opaque, and lasts a long time. I have bought three different shades and all of them stay sticky and don't dry down. I learned the hard way and kissed my husband and it turned into a mess for both of us! Ugh..... no.
Goes on too thick and wet, such a mess
Jen from Minneapolis
I tried this and the liquid got everywhere and then was a pain to get off. It looked awful, could not make a line, and got on my teeth. I'm not sure how you would apply this to make it work out.
JLP123 from New York
This product LASTS. I mean like, drinking, eating, dabbing with a napkin, probably other kinds of activities and it stays on and keeps its color! I've tried so many types of liquid lipsticks including Nars Powermatte Pigment which I love too, but this one is my number one. It stays on your lips and doesn't fade away on the inner portion of your lips like some do (making you look like youve just lined your lips circa 2000). Great variety of colors, affordable and very easy to apply.
brandi from Corona ca
love the color and it stays on