Rated 4.27 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Awesome!!
I honestly was hesitant about trying out this product because I've had such a bad problem with smudging in the past. I have facial tics which make it more difficult to wear darker mascara because it smudges. This product goes on so smoothly and easily and does not clump at all if you put on multiple layers. I would definitely recommend this product if you're looking for a natural lash look. It's survived a four hour plane ride home for me and still looked fabulous. You need this! I got this product complementary to test out.
Most Helpful Critical Review Clumps up easily
I like it, I have had better. It just clumps up a lot after a few strokes. I've had a better drug store mascara than this one. Probably not something I would buy. But it is decent!
Reviewed by 763 customers Probably good, but not for me
Isabella from Birmingham, AL
This mascara is probably fantastic for someone with naturally thicker lashes, but the formula just weighed my fine lashes down. The formula dried quickly, but left my lashes feeling dried out and brittle, however, I didn't lose any eyelashes when I took the mascara off later. I wanted to like it because the Ulta associate said she recommends it to everyone and she was super jazzed about this mascara, but it just wasn't a match for me.
The Perfect Mascara
Lady T from Florida
I absolutely love this mascara. It gives me the natural and full lashes look. Best of all, it last all day!! Can't do without it
Dana from New Jersey
I really wasn't expecting much from this mascara. Honestly I only purchased it because it was on sale. However, I'm obsessed! This mascara is great. It really lengthens and separates my lashes! Since using I've gotten so many compliments on my lashes. Definitely recommend trying this.
LisaMarie from Tuscaloosa, AL
I love this mascara and the applicator. I already have super long and full lashes. This mascara makes my lashes pop so much!
This is by far my favorite mascara!!!
Kim from TX
Makes my lashes look amazing!!
Decent, But Not Special
MyKaelah from Ohio
I tried this mascara hoping it would be as awesome as the reviews, but the formula was really off putting. It has a significant smell and it was hard to get past for me. Wouldn't purchase again.
Love this mascara!
Linkelly from Long Island, NY
I love this mascara, it stays on ! Usually any product I've tried always flakes on my lower lashes. This one has not ! It goes on smoothly and looks great on upper and lower lashes.
I love this mascara!!
Hannah from Nebraska
This is seriously one of my tried and true, holy grail mascara! I've tried a tone of other mascaras, but I always gravitate back to this one!! It's amazing.
LOVE LOVE LOVE
Hannah from Omaha
One of my all time favorite mascaras!! I love this formula, and the wand. The wand is a silicone wand and it picks up the perfect amount of product without being messy. I love how the wand separates my lashes and gives me tons of volume! The formula also never flakes, which is amazing!
Brush is loaded with tons of mascara
Redjetster from Massachusetts
I really like Smashbox cosmetics and was looking for a new mascara for lengthening. This one seemed to have great reviews. But, I don't know if the brush is defective or what. There is so much clumped mascara on the brush before trying to apply-it just goes on in clumps since the brush isn't cleared of excess mascara when removing it from the tube. I have played around and tried over and over to fix this problem, but it is just a waste of money at this point. I wish I could add a picture to the review to show what a mess the brush is when pulling it out of the tube. Would not recommend at all.
Say goodbye to falsies
Simplybecky81 from Charlotte
When I wear this mascara I've asked what falsies I'm using or did I curl my Lashes. This mascara gives my natural lashes life.
Overall good but not for me
Ana from Austin, TX
I love trying out different mascaras and I love the way it makes my eye lashes look- volume and length are on point without clumps and long lasting. Only complaint is it's super hard to remove (almost feels stubborn to remove like its waterproof, which isn't for me) and irritates my sensitive dry eyes when removing.
best mascara out there!
cindyg183 from Grand Prairie TX
best mascar product I've tried, truly love this product. I have had it for months now and is still in fresh conditions, the product hasn't dried up or clumped on my lashes, it does makes them look long and adds volume. Much better than Too Faced Better than Sex if I need to compare it with another high end brand product
Diaz from Queens
I really love smash box and I wanted to like this product. I'm very particular about my eyelash, and I noticed this mascara weighs down my eyelashes (after having curled them) and it just makes me eyelashes look messy
My favorite mascara
T from Manchester NH
I have used about 25 different mascaras in my life and this one is by far my favorite. The applicator is small enough to get into tough areas yet big enough to hive everything a good coat. The formula is a little bit watery at first but applying a thin layer and then another layer is the best way I have found to use it then! After that it is a perfect consistency and makes everything look long and beautiful!! Im currently on my 5th tube and nothing seems to beat this!!
J from USA
I used this mascara one time and was very disappointed. It did not help my lashes at all. The brush is also very basic.
Ladina from MO
This was recommended by a lady in the cosmetic section. Wow! This is the 3rd Smashbox product I've tried & am now hooked on.
Love the way it goes on.
Aaslaug from NJ
Stays on all day and makes my lashes look great.
rkultti from moore, ok
I found this mascara to ve very messy. It's almost too wet if that makes sense. I've been trying to pull the wand against the tube opening to help get some off the wand so its so messy but even that doesn't help. It is also very painful, like morr than other brands, when it gets in your eyes. I applied it around 6:30 in the morning and then had a waterballoon fight with my daughter around 3 pm, so more than enough to dry well and some got wet and leaked in my eye. It was very painful. I don't think it holds the curl well by mid afternoon my lashes are flat again.
Love it makes my lashes super long and full!
Cheyenne from Eau claire, wi
Love it will never use a different mascara.
I keep reaching for it
Emily from San Luis Obispo, CA
It's not perfect - definitely has a bit of clumping and flaking issues - but I find I reach for this more than many of my other mascaras. I feel like it really does volumize and fan out my lashes - and isn't that what we all want and deserve?
Great brush, but flakes immediately
Em mo from Portland
If I use this mascara I HAVE to top it with a different waterproof mascara
It flakes SO MUCH
And that's coming from someone who primarily uses drugstore mascara
It makes large black creases under my eye
But the brush and application itself is great
Great mascara. Had a couple flaking issues
Shmeahdaleah from Tacoma, WA
Great mascara. I liked how it applied - the applicator worked to separate and coat each lash. A couple times the mascara flaked on me but funny thing, that was consistent. Bought a second tube when it went on sale. In the picture: left eye is Pur brand mascara I opened the dah of the pic, right eye is Super Fan after a couple months of use.
New fave mascara
Adri from Texas
I am big on mascara! My lashes are thin, long and curved. This mascara is amazing for lengthening and thickening my lashes. This does not compare to Tarte and Milk mascara, in which I no longer use due to this doing exactly what I want.
tonyarita from Virginia Beach, VA
For some reason, way too much mascara comes out on the wand. I think it's some defect. It doesn't seem to be working correctly, maybe the ring that scrapes off the excess mascara is not working right. It does elongate my lashes and gives more volume, and it creates a bold look. You just really have to work with it because of the issue with the product coming out in clumps.