Rated 4.19 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review great waterproof eyeliner for the price
I have oily skin and monolids so it is VERY difficult for me to find eyeliner that won't smudge by the end of the day. I heard good things about Milani eyeliners so I decided to give it a try. This is the best drugstore eyeliner that works best for me. Usually eyeliners will "crack" by the end of the day but this one didn't move at all. Comes off pretty easily with water even though it says its waterproof though. but just don't cry during the day and this will be perfect for you.
Most Helpful Critical Review Decent
The formula itself is awesome, it dries matte and doesn't crack or flake and is extremely pigmented, it's the applicator itself I dislike. It's super thick and long (the sponge tip) and there's so sharp Tip on it, it's like someone cut it off and it's a blunt end on it so you can't even do a winged liner with it
Reviewed by 145 customers AMAZING
Jessie from New York
This is my holy grail eyeliner. It is matte and stays put - through workout, shower, beach day ANYTHING!
17 hours does work
Z from Las Vegas, NV
I use this everyday & it works unless you cry.
Barbara from Sebastian Florida
I have tried sooooo many eye liners from expensive to the cheap I just wanted an eye liner that would stay on and not smudge! Well this one is the best ! I can wear it all day and it lasts ! Worth a try and so affordable
Kai from NV
This liner looked promising but was a big let down. The felt tip is too big for starters. Dried very black but after a while looks faded and flaky. Rubs right off and came off so fast with just a bit of water. So yeah hard pass on this liner.
I would not use again
DownhomeLadyDi from TN
This is the worst liquid eyeliner applicator I have ever attempted to use. It is long, skinny, and spindly with a little knob on the end. It is almost impossible to use. It has increased my makeup application time by five minutes, trying to get a 'wing' on the end. It doesn't even apply a smooth line. It's supposed to be .09 hundredths of an ounce, but it hasn't lasted as long as any other liquid eyeliner I've used. It's already drying up. It's been a nightmare to use.. I've used liquid eyeliner my whole adult life....like about 35 years. I used another brand for years until they changed the formula and it stung my eyes to use it. I had high hopes for this one and it was a big disappointment.
Fabbi from San Francisco
Long lasting, super matte, very black, loved it!
Eliza from Miami. Florida
The fine tip applicator allows for precise and easy application. I like the matte finish. I would definitely purchase it again.
Repurchased many times
V account from Washington DC
This is the best liquid eyeliner I have every used (compared to Seph, MAC, etc.). It is long-lasting (despite not being waterproof), does not smudge on oily eyelids, and is very black. I think it is easy to apply, but I've worn eyeliner for many years. I have worn it for 10+ hours at parties/work and it stays looking good (I have been asked several times what I was using). It is matte, like the name says. The eyeliner comes off easily with makeup wipes/micellar water.
Stays put but not precise
alise from VA
This liner worked really well. It went on smooth and it was very matte and had great staying power. The color was very deep. My big issue is the brush is too wide. You cannot get a precise line at all. It is also more of a "knob" then a brush. I could not really use this to get a wing or cat-eye look.
BeautifulPeople from Florida
For some reason it wasn't visible on my skin. They only way I was able to see it was close in a mirror. The plus is that it dry fast. I didn't to have worry about blinking and it appearing on my upper eyelid.
Anon from US
I loved the tip and how easy it was to apply the product. Also supper easy to wipe away a mistake.
Easy to use
Bmend from Texas
I love the Milani stay put matte eyeliner. It does not smudge, is easy to put on, and can last almost all day!
Mia from Californiana
Really like the color pigmentation
Tiff from Laredo,Tx
I love this eyeliner it is very pigmented and stays a long time.
Bri from Gastonia, North Carolina
This eyeliner is one of the smoothest applications I have used. I normally do not wear eyeliner because he can get messy; however, this was simply and crisp.
The Bold and the Beautiful
Ace from Atlanta
The first thing I'd like to say is WOW. this eyeliner is BLACKKKK. The first stroke had me hooked and it left my eyeliner looked perfectly matte the rest of the day and didn't smudge! My only con is the super fine tip. You have to be super in control to hold the eyeliner naturally without shaking in order to keep the wings looking sharp and straight.
Super good matter eyeliner
Glittery999 from Texas
I've always had trouble using eyeliners because I am still a beginner. This product made it easy to do a winged eyeliner. It goes on very dark the consistency of it glides on very well to your skin. It was very easy to use.
Lupe from Miami
Love this product. It is very dark and has smooth application. Easy to apply onto the skin. Just great overall.
Love and pigmented
Foggymist from Mission, Tx
I got the color espresso, and let me tell you girl it's so pretty. The application tip to apply the liner is thin so you can make a precise cat eye and I love it. Super pigmented and it does last. It doesn't droop with the heat and trust me I live in Texas so I have to wear makeup that last the heat. It's super affordable and I would definitely get it again. I did receive this product for free but all opinions are my own.
Vani from Nashville
This eyeliner is wonderful! It's long lasting, I love the matte look to it and it's very easy to use and take off when you're ready. Overall, I would definitely recommend it!
Not for me!!
Sol05 from Texas
I definitely cannot recommend this product, I think it is great that it is a completely matte brown color and that the applicator is very easy to use. But when it comes to drying it breaks horrible and that ruins my makeup.
Paige from Oswego, NY
I picked this eyeliner after reading many different reviews on all different eyeliners and I'm so glad i did! The tip is perfect for winged liner and it's easy to work with.. i love it!
Fantastic for Beginners
NanaB from Atlanta
I'm new to makeup and have always loved the look of eyeliner. Being that I am a newbie, many of the other brands brush tip did not work well with my unsteady hand. This Milani eyeliner made it so easy to apply and even clean up the look. I was able to achieve a simple eyeliner look and even a cat eye look. The eyeliner grips really nice in your hand so it makes it really easy to stay steady.
Milani Stay Put Review
Crystal from Pharr, Tx
This matte eyeliner is easy to apply & it actually stays on all day! Also, it's easy to remove with a makeup wipe at the end of the day which is perfect! My only problem with it is that it's kind of hard to do a wing with the applicator but other than that, I love it!
My New Favorite Eyeliner
Sharon from Miami
I have been using the Stila eyeliner for ages but wanted to opt for a more affordable one with the same features and honestly this one does it for me. It is longwear, very rich in color, doesn't crease AND it is easy to apply with the brush it comes with. I love it!!!! I actually will be doing some shoots soon so expect to see me wearing this eyeliner soon! I will tag Milani for sure :)