Product Reviews Rated 4.51 out of 5 stars
192 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Love this eyeliner I received a sample of this Milani stay put eyeliner in 06 silver foxy through the viewpoints sampling program! I have never tried a Milani product in my life but I have tried other eyeliner products and this one performed just as well!
I really loved the color of this eyeliner! It made me super excited because I normally stick to more plain colors but this one allowed me to experiment and I loved the results!
Huge plus was that this eyeliner was easy to use. I'm fairly new to using liquid eyeliners and this one glided on easily without making a huge mess.
Another pro is that it really did last all day long, hence the name stay put eyeliner! It looked just as fabulous at the end of the day as it did in the morning upon initial application.
I have nothing negative to say about this eyeliner! I was super impressed with the quality and beautiful results I was able to achieve! I would highly recommend and purchase again!
Most Helpful Critical Review mixed feelings First things first, I am not an eyeliner expert. I'm still learning when it comes to these types of liners. I try to tightline with this and for some odd reason it always smudges and it is like it works its way into the outer corner of my eyes and smudges downward and transfers beneath my eyes. I have to kind of wipe it off of underneath my eyes and the outer corner. However, given all of this, I can BARELY get it off with microfiber cloth, double cleansing, micellar water...GT I don't know if I am doing something wrong or if this doesn't mix well with my eye area. Little to say, when I wear this, after a 12 hour shift I look like I've had a VERY rough night.
Reviewed by 192 customers Color was Off-Putting 3
RileyH from OKC, OK
Based on the picture of this product, I thought it was more of a burgundy color and not too red. When I applied it to my lower lash line, it was just too red. It made my eyes look raw and that I had been crying or was sick. I took it off immediately. Maybe it would look okay on the upper lash line.
Great 5
Sabah from Toronto Ontario Canada
This is a really good liner, especially for the waterline. It's jet black, which is what I want and doesn't bother my eyes
mixed feelings 3
Gloria from KY
First things first, I am not an eyeliner expert. I'm still learning when it comes to these types of liners. I try to tightline with this and for some odd reason it always smudges and it is like it works its way into the outer corner of my eyes and smudges downward and transfers beneath my eyes. I have to kind of wipe it off of underneath my eyes and the outer corner. However, given all of this, I can BARELY get it off with microfiber cloth, double cleansing, micellar water...GT I don't know if I am doing something wrong or if this doesn't mix well with my eye area. Little to say, when I wear this, after a 12 hour shift I look like I've had a VERY rough night.
Really Does Stay Put 5
Kiki from Ohio
This eyeliner really does what it says. I wear it in the waterline and work 10-hour days. While I can't attest to 16-hour wear, it stays put through the work day I gave without transfer under my eyes. I have tried everything and this is the best-even compared to eyeliner that costs twice the price.
I love this eyeliner!!! 5
Chrissy from Red Lion Pa
i just love this eyeliner! I am 56 and have problems with eyeliner skipping places on my lids. Milani Stay Put Eyeliner glides right over my lid without skipping places! Plus it stays put just like it claims to do!
Favorite liner ever! 5
Holly from PA
This eyeliner is amazing for my sensitive, contact lens wearing eyes. It lasts so well on the lower waterline, doesn't smear on my contacts or cause a burning sensation. I love the deep brown Semi Sweet shade and plan to try the black. The smudger on the bottom is so handy to smooth out the line along my top lashes while retaining deep pigment. Highly recommend!
Definitely a keeper! 5
Paige from TN
This is a really great eyeliner. Especially for the price.
Nice color but doesn't last 3
Momack1964 from Wi
This is a great color, however it does not last more than 2-3 hours
yes yes yes 5
Michelle from Pittsburgh
I use this on my waterline. I have the most watery eyes and this has stayed put!
Works well in waterline. 4
MelissaP from OK
This eyeliner is creamy, easy to apply and stays in the waterline. I only wish the color were a little more vivid.
Excellent Eyeliner 5
Laurie from Michigan
Good color, coverage, stays on well, and the smudging tool works perfectly. All of this and a great price!
Yes I will purchase again! 5
Rita from Undisclosed
I like the way this pencil glides on as an under eye liner. It blends well.
The best eyeliner I've found so far! 4
Sunflower girl from Entriken PA
I like this eyeliner because it stays on forever and smears very little. The only thing I don't like is it gets clumpy if you put too much on
New Holy Grail 5
erica from Pennsylvania
this eyeliner is incredible. it does exactly what it says- stays put. it doesn't smear or fade out throughout the day even if you are sweating.
Waterline 4
Catie T from Boston, MA
I used this on my water line and it was great for that, I wasn't a huge fan of it on my eyelids but I ordered it for my waterline. I went with a different eyeliner on my lids and the look was perfect
Stays put 5
Bumblebee22 from Raleigh North Carolina
Lasts all day and does not smear! It does not hurt my sensitive eyes either.
Love it 5
Day from Poulsbo, WA
After using other eyeliners that are hard on my eyes when blending, this one is great!
Waterline dream 5
Emily from Chicago
Navy color is the perfect deep navy for blue eyes. Stays put in my waterline. Love!
Stays on all day long love this product 5
Shorty from Texas
Use as eyeliner for under the eyes always stays on without smudging
Amazing! 5
CKK from FL
I have been looking for an eyeliner that will not transfer to my upper lid ever since I had surgery and need to put ointment in my eyes to sleep. That means that my eyes are always quite greasy/oily and all makeup melts within a few hours. This is the first eyeliner that has not transferred to my upper lid. It stays all day.
Great eyeliner! 5
Amy W from WI
Very impressed the the Stay Put Eyeliner. The Silver Foxy color is perfect! Not as harsh a color as black for older women.
First time trying Milani cosmetics, will definitely be trying other products..
best eyeliner ever 5
Jules from Oakhurst, NJ
It's very pigmented & stays exactly where you put it! Goes on pretty smoothly and stays all day! I have oily skin/eyelids so eyeliner and mascara tends to show up on my lids throughout the day but not this liner! Because it stays, I suggest smudging what you want to smudge immediately after application so you can get the look you want. Otherwise you might have a hard time smudging/blending because it sets quickly. Also, it has a built in sharpener on the opposite side of the smudge tip... I've never seen a mechanical pencil come with a sharpener but it's a genius idea since I find the mechanical ones usually get pretty dull after a few uses.
Sticks Where You Put It 4
ItsMissKae from NW CT
I'm loving this, for the most part. It sticks where you put it, literally. Slides on smooth. Highly pigmented. Stays put. The only thing I don't like is that it's sticky, REALLY sticky, on my waterline. Even hours after putting it on, my eyelids stick together when I close them for anymore than a second. My brother thought there was something wrong with my eyes as they stuck together mid-conversation and and opened one at a time.
Favorite. Eyeliner. EVER. 5
Bri0045 from GA
When they say stay put, they mean STAY PUT. I was wiping my eyes with makeup remover for 5 minutes before I got it off. Love it so much, even after a shift at work my makeup looks the same as when I first applied it. I will be buying this eyeliner exclusively from here on out! Would definitely recommend.
I buy this product often. It applies smoothly and lasts 5
ohio girl from Ohio
I love this product!!!!
