Product Reviews Rated 3.96 out of 5 stars
141 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Highly recommend Very easy to work with, perfect for beginners! As a makeup artist I use this eyeliner every day , and it is such a great product it's does not run, stays in pace all day!
Most Helpful Critical Review Not worth the price While this product does stay on for the day, the actual look it gives is not great. I've had some dollar store eye liner that looked better on me. When applying the eye liner, the pen is super thin so it takes a little longer to get the desired look. Also, the product dries up quickly when applying so the color of the eye liner is not bold. In fact, immediately after completely putting on my make up, it has a faded color look. Personally, I love the cat eye look, so this product was not for me to begin with; but even if you're looking for a more minimalist look, it certainly is not worth the price you pay for it. Save yourself the trouble and get a cheap drugstore eye liner before even considering this product.
Reviewed by 141 customers Dried out Product 2
Mae from Florida
I picked this up today and was so excited to work with it when I got home. No matter how much I shook the pen, no product would come out just dirty colored water. Very disappointed, will be returned.
Works wonders!! 5
Sinner from Green Bay WI
I bought the micro tip only because the original one was out, but I love it! It's so defined I can do anything with it. Now I buy both!
Perfect precision eyeliner 5
Everyday Ulta Fan from Minneapolis, MN
I've struggled to find an idiot-proof liquid liner since Benefit discontinued my favorite a couple years back, and this product — the microfine tip specifically — has finally emerged as the clear winner! It applies smoothly and naturally, and you can add to it to go bolder without it starting to erase itself like some other brands do. It also doesn't peel off like some brands do. It's easy to remove with makeup wipes.
Disappointed 2
Rylee from Michigan
I have been on the hunt for a go-to liquid eyeliner, and I have heard good things about this one. The application is very nice. Not too much comes out, and the tip is tiny for a good wing. However, after a couple of hours wearing it, it became shiny and bled into the creases of my eyelids, and my eyelids are not overly greasy because I have never had that happen before.
Stays all day, fr! 5
Valerie A from Chicago, IL
I was looking for a good eyeliner that wouldnt smudge off because i have very oily eyelids. This eyeliner is perfect. It stays even when my face is super oily. The tip is very fine so its best for small details or thin liner. Definitely will be getting the version with the bigger tip too.
All Time Favorite 5
Madison from St. Louis, MO
I absolutely love this eyeliner. Over the past year, this has become my go-to eyeliner with any type of makeup look. It's extremely versatile and can be used for any makeup look from natural all the way to full glam. The micro tip liner gives you control of line thickness. You can make it thin and precise or bold and defined. I love this liner and would definitely recommend it to anyone that's searching for a precise liquid liner.
Love the ultra thin line 5
Chariotwatcher from Arizona
I love the thin line I get and the control I have with this liner.
Many things but NOT waterproof 3
Evan from St. Louis
I've used this eyeliner and the original version multiple times. Neither version is anything even close to waterproof. My eyes water quite a bit and simply tapping the watering away wiped my whole wing off. Other than that it's great. Sharp lines, no bleeding, or smudging and the felt tip is good.
VERY DISAPPOINTED 1
Tammy from Hanover, PA
Highly disappointed in this brand or possibly could have been Ulta's fault. Purchased one went to use and was completely dried up. Return product to have it happen a second time. Now mind you I also had this happen from a purchase of the Kat Von D brand before these Stila two. Ugh!! So annoying!! Have used Stila before and never had an issue. Bad luck?? Factory defect or negligence of not rotating stock???
hands down my favorite product ever 5
Sam Jam from Maryland
The micro tip makes getting those precise lines a breeze. I now get perfect wings almost every day because I use this tip (I don't hold human error against it lol). The staying power of Stila liquid eyeliner is unmatched. No matter what you and your face go through, this eyeliner will be there for you. Rubbing your eyes from lack of sleep? It will still be there. Face in a pillow? It will still be there. Crying from the chaos that is life? It will still be there. And don't we all want something reliable in this crazy world?
It was dry and empty 1
Dodi from oldsmar, fl
empty and dry . I will return it
Best Eyeliner Ever 5
Charlene from West Columbia SC
I have tried many eyeliners but this is my first time trying Stila. It is the best eyeliner ever. Am so happy to have finally found it.
Very sticky and flakey. 3
CiCi from Greenville, S
I love stila. And I was excited to find a fine eyeliner pen. It takes many coats for the color to seem black. It's very opaque. Because of the layers it gets flakey very quickly. Not my favorite product.
Not worth the price 2
Belle from Owasso, OK
While this product does stay on for the day, the actual look it gives is not great. I've had some dollar store eye liner that looked better on me. When applying the eye liner, the pen is super thin so it takes a little longer to get the desired look. Also, the product dries up quickly when applying so the color of the eye liner is not bold. In fact, immediately after completely putting on my make up, it has a faded color look. Personally, I love the cat eye look, so this product was not for me to begin with; but even if you're looking for a more minimalist look, it certainly is not worth the price you pay for it. Save yourself the trouble and get a cheap drugstore eye liner before even considering this product.
Long time favorite 5
Lindsey from Atlanta
Literally does not budge
I would definitely buy this product again! 5
HHILOVER from Twinsburg, OH
This is my go to eyeliner.
Loved It 5
Cristal from Madera, CA
I had never used an eyeliner like this before so I was a bit scared. However I used it and I was amazed of how it actually was quite easy! The color is well pigmented and it lasted all day, which usually never happens because I have really oily eyelids. Overall I found it to be a great product and would definitely recommend it!
Pretty good eyeliner 4
Zacharie from Florida
The eyeliner is well pigmented and lasts all day! The tiny tip also makes applying it super easy, especially for anyone else who has smaller eyes. The only critique I have is that if you have to touch up an area that has old product already on it, the old product can sometimes lift off the eye and stick to the applicator, leaving holes in the wing.
Easy to apply!!! 5
Kathy from TX
Very easy to apply and stays on all day!
I love it.Dark,stays all day,no flaking. 5
KKofA from Ca
I've been using this product a long time.
LOVE LOVE LOVE 5
Mars from Walnut
Definitely defines your eyes and dries quick after application. No irritation, goes on smooth! LOVE IT!
My new favorite eyeliner.. 5
Keisha from Tyler, Texaa
The liner is super pointy which makes it extremely easy to use
I would buy again and did 5
Gia Marie from Pearland Tx
I love it lasts all day and such a thin line. Works perfect. exactly what I was looking for
I would buy this product again.. 4
Carmen A from Fort Lauderdale, FL
Ok
LOVE for hooded eyes! 5
mummasaurus from Maine, US
I am absolutely in love with this liner! It is long lasting and the micro tip is perfect for my hooded lids. If you have smaller or hooded eye lids this product is amazing and very precise. Will be recommending to everyone I know.
