Rated 3.96 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Highly recommend
Very easy to work with, perfect for beginners! As a makeup artist I use this eyeliner every day , and it is such a great product it's does not run, stays in pace all day!
Most Helpful Critical Review Great applicator, disappointing formula
The original Stila Stay All Day liner is the only one I've worn for years because it is so incredibly long wearing and won't budge or smudge no matter what. My only issue has been I wish it had a finer tip. I was so excited when I saw this launch, but am so disappointed the formula is different. I just assumed, which is my mistake, that it would be the same. The first time I wore it I had liner smudged under my eyes within an hour. After a few hours it was an absolute mess. I tried it a few more times with the same result, then finally checked the ingredients and realized it was different. It is lovely to apply, but not worth the the maintenance and mess.
Reviewed by 119 customers I would buy again and did
Gia Marie from Pearland Tx
I love it lasts all day and such a thin line. Works perfect. exactly what I was looking for
I would buy this product again..
Carmen A from Fort Lauderdale, FL
LOVE for hooded eyes!
mummasaurus from Maine, US
I am absolutely in love with this liner! It is long lasting and the micro tip is perfect for my hooded lids. If you have smaller or hooded eye lids this product is amazing and very precise. Will be recommending to everyone I know.
I wanted to like this so badly
MorriganP from Olympia, WA
I wanted to see how it did on top of just some standard concealer. Big mistake the felt tip dried out before I could even finish one eye... I wanted to love this so badly because I love stila's other liners. Maybe it was a fluke maybe it wasn't I'll try again with a bare face and see how it goes...
Andi from Louisiana
Amazing easy to use
Love the thin application!
Summer from Arizona
Felt tip is so smooth and application is easy!
Love how sharp the liner is
Jade from Orlando, FL
I really only use this for a wing on the end of my eye. Not over my whole lash line. I guess I should've looked into budge proof. I just barely tapped the end of my eye and it all started wiping away. It's a really good liner if you don't touch it.
Cheyayn from Colorado
I love the micro tip! I find it easier to control my lines.
Not worth the price
Sburk from Massachusetts
Very disappointed by this product. It dried out after the 3rd use and the tip looses fineness and begins to fray. Its not very black and it looks patchy on the eye. It also, does not layer well, when you try to go over a line again to make it darker, it picks up the color from your eye.
I will buy this every time
Norma Jari from Florida
This eyeliner has been my favorite because it's flawless to go on also to control it's very easy the fibers on the end of the brush are very smooth on the eye which helps the application go on eyes perfectly.
My favorite eyeliner without a doubt!
Angie from Tulsa, Oklahoma
Stays on all day...super smooth!
I will probably buy again
Happy from Reno
The sharpness of the tip makes it easy to apply - after a little practice.
Second purchase and would buy again
BertaD from Golden, CO
I use this product everyday. Easy to apply. I have sensitive eyes and this product does not make my eyes burn or water.
Tracy from So Cal
Love this eyeliner! My eyelids tend to get greasy throughout the day and this eyeliner doe not come off in the eye crease. So glad I found it and worth every dime.
My go-to eyeliner
Emmy from Arkansas
It lasts so long and it's a wonderful product. I do winged eyeliner everyday and this gets the job done perfectly!
Easy to use
Nic from Lyndhurst NJ
I'm terrible at using liquid eyeliner but this product makes it foolproof even for me.
Go to liner!
Mina from Saratoga
This liner stays all day! I dance all day which means non-stop sweat. By the end of the day, it's still perfect! The microtip really helps for a defined shape. I absolutely love this liner!
Yes I will buy it again.
Olga from El Paso Tx
I like how it dries as soon as you apply it. It also stays on all day.
I would but this again
Kim from Westminster, MD
i use this everyday. I love how it makes my eyes look
Chelle from Nashville, TN
Easy to use and is awesome to provide definition to your eyes and lash line.
Betsey from Denver
If you cry and it isn't there afterwards, it's not waterproof. Skinny skinny line. Not worth the money at all. I wish loreal Precision was still around.
Smooth thin line!
Vicki from Sahuarita, AZ
Love this eyeliner! Nice and smooth application.
Most amazing eyeliner ever!!
Quinn from Wichita, Kansas
I have hooded eyelids, and anyone who has this issue also (it's common) knows that when you apply eyeliner...it will transfer to you top eyelid- leaving a black mark on your beautifully perfected eyeshadowed lid. Well this stuff I live by, people!! I literally could be the spokesperson for this brand. I rant and rave about this eyeliner. I tell all my friends and even strangers about this eyeliner. I won't ever change from this eyeliner. It works soooo well. It stays on from the minute I put it on until I wash it off. It glides on like a dream, so you don't get bumps or smudges. It dries quick and never leaves a mark on my upper lid. One stick of these will last me about 2 months. When I say I won't ever switch from this eyeliner, I absolutely mean it. Best eyeliner ever!!!
Autumstone from Beaumont
Perfect for minimal eyeliner. I use everyday. Also you can do a full on cat eye but it works best for a simple easy line. Love this eyeliner and DOES NOT SMUGE. good for about 10 hours.
Eddie from NV
Love the new micro tip