Rated 3.5 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Bold blue
This eye color pencil is very high pigmented giving you a very bold look. It's very noticeable, especially when you already have blue eyes, just pops even more. I received so many compliments I fell in love it. It has a soft tip that helps blend in right into your eye. Very long lasting and doesn't need to be sharpened.
Most Helpful Critical Review Fix it now!
I don't know what you have done, but you need to fix it now. You obviously are aware that this product no longer works like it did. It is almost unusable with it breaking off in chunks as you try to use it. I'm also quite sick of cleaning up the marks on my floor where it lands. I've used this product for decades and have never had this problem. This product no longer works and I will no longer use it, nor would anyone else. Stop messing around and fix it before you lose all of your customers. And fire whoever thought changing it was a good idea to save money.
Reviewed by 2046 customers Horrible
Doughboy from Kansas City
Got new out of packaging, tried to use the bottom and click to get product out the top and it didn't work. Kept twisting, it kept clicking with nothing coming out. Finally took it apart and now have to manually use the spring to push product up. It's worthless, falls apart and crumbles if you even try to apply to your eye. I think more of the product ends up in the sink bec I can't get the tip of the liner to stay on when using. Worse eyeliner I've used
Vy from Atanta, GA
It keeps breaking off in little pieces when I try to use it, so I can't even apply it before the whole tip breaks off.
The tip consistently breaks off now.
Blondie0236 from AR
I have used this product for years and have loved it but now the tip is always breaking off. Not sure if I will keep purchasing it or not. Very disappointed because this as been the best eyeliner but not so much anymore!
Cheap and crumbly
cgarcia1002 from Chattanooga, TN
Never in my life have I used such a poorly designed product. The primary issues are that the tip not only breaks off/crumbles with every use, it is encapsulated in a hard plastic that rubs against the eye and irritates. I'm not sure what the cheap sponge on the other end is supposed to be used for since it does not spread the cheap crumbly product smoothly. Finally, the eyeliner lasts only a couple of hours before it has to be reapplied and it streaks horribly. If I could give it zero stars, I would.
waste of money
sunflower from van nuys california
Awful. I've used it twice and the tip of the pencil has broken off every time. I don't even apply that much pressure when I do my eyeliner! Smudged like crazy too within a few min underneath my eyes. will never buy again.
I like this product
Sonja from Tallahassee florida
Great to use on eyes
MkupNerd from NJ
Black onyx eyeliner is highly pigmented jet black in one swipe. I used it to tightline and on the lids. It got on my eyelashes. Consistency feels like a creamy-putty. Not as precise as indicated, but close. I can get a precise look when clean ed up with a q-tip and makeup remover. Does not cause redness but slightly irritates my sensitive eyes. Product moves slightly around the lids and the under eyes. Overall, it is comparable to high end eyeliners- like UD, Tarte, MAC, etc. but at a reasonable price. Not sure if I will use it much or re-purchase.
for a soft natural look
ellie from california
tl;dr - natural looking, simple/basic eyeliner, doesn't last all day
it's very nice for basic everyday looks, where you want some kind of eyeliner but nothing over the top. it does not last all day, but it doesn't exactly smudge. it sort of fades after a couple of hours of wearing and it's not a bad thing tbh, kind of softly fades into nothing. easy to work with but the mechanism to get the product out is a little confusing.
Best eyeliner Covergirl makes
Heidi from Kent, OH
This eyeliner is the best Covergirl makes. It doesn't smudge and allows for you to do anything from a thin line to a thick cat eye. I've purchased this in multiple colors and have been very happy.
Also, Covergirl is 100% cruelty free and does not test on animals.
Good overall smooth liner
MD from KY
Doesn't last as long as some retractable
Love, Love this eye pencil!
Lily from Atlanta, Ga
Best eye liner ever! I have used this for years. Glides on easy. Stays put for many hours, The greatest colour & in a hue that takes the appearance of redness away in your eyes. Super price. I highly recommend.
Irritated my sensitive eyes
Dion from Christiana, DE
It was difficult to apply due to the plastic covering around the liner point. It took me a while to build up the color, only for my eyes to become irritated and teary. I wiped off the liner and dealt with sensitive eyes for two days. This was a no-go for me.
Too messy and clumpy!
Leslie no nickname from Charleston, WV
I wasted more eyeliner as it came out of tip! Little clumps. Wasn't impressed with the product. Will go back to the product I was using. This eyeliner was cheaper than what I used. I would rather pay more and get a better product. Fix it or lose customers.
My go to eyeliner
Cari from Alexandria, VA
This is a very good eyeliner. Goes on easily and definitely lasts!
Lily from Atlanta, GA
I have used this particular liner for years, hope it is never discontinued. Newer products from this line have not added up to this one. Glides on so easy, stays on all day. The colour, Charcoal I love - it brightens the eye. Great product!
Aly from Seattle
I only used this for my upper waterline but somehow it always ends up smudging underneath my eye after a couple of hours. I would not recommend.
I always buy this..
Morgan from Muncie Indiana
I've used this liner for 6 or 7yrs. It is my favorite always..super soft, easy going on & stays.
I've used this my whole life!
Gigi from Florida
I've used this since I was 13 years old (I'm 43 now). I've never found another eyeliner I like better!
I have bought this producct in the past and love the it.
None from Bear, Delaware 19701
I feel that this item gives me control when I apply it.
This is the only eyeliner I ever buy!!
SG from Alabama
Goes on smooth. No smearing or smudging.
Been using this for years
NonnaB from San Jose
This is so easy to use that it's hard to make a mistake.
I do not recommend
Minni from Naugatuck CT.
This product is not what it use to be. The eyeliner point breaks as soon as you start to use it . just horrible...
None from Pa
Like the way it goes on
Having Trouble With the Packaging
Brunosmom from Yorktown, VA
Bought this because of good reviews. Can't get to the eyeliner itself because there is a piece of plastic around the tip that I'm unable to remove. Pencil will not wind allowing the eyeliner tip to protrude. A total waste of money.
no, the liner flakes off as you apply it
lynn from 53188
when you applyt it the liner sometimes breaks off