Product Reviews Rated 4.46 out of 5 stars
2167 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review A must have for me!!!! This eye makeup remover literally removes everything!!! I love it so much, have been using it
for years now. Couldn't find anything to replace it, and nothing beats the price.
Most Helpful Critical Review Can be an oily mess. It says on the label that it's "Oil-Free." I understand that you have to SHAKE the bottle vigorously to mix up the solution so that it's not oily, but you better use it QUICKLY before it becomes oily again. I use Q-tips to apply, but if I don't immediately remove my makeup at least 5 seconds after I shake it, it becomes oily again. And I natural have oily skin, so the product was a lie. Although, it does get the job done. Very well, too. But for oily skin, it's a no-no.
Reviewed by 2167 customers Great 5
Gi from MD
I didn't have to rub hard on my eyes. Easily takes off my eye makeup and mascara!
Best eye make up remover 5
KaylaTheShopaholic from Milwaukee
I love this, it's a constant repurchase for me. I only use it on my eyes. I also use it when I apply
Make up if I mess up an area I can use a pencil brush with a dip of this and all my mistakes go away!
works just as well as more expensive products 5
Emilie from Vermont
i usually buy a product that costs 2x as much but this works just as good!
Removes waterproof makeup 5
Kim from shoreline
I love taking off my mascara with this product.
This is a keeper! 5
JoJo from Seattle, WA
I wet a cotton pad with it and hold on eye for a few seconds and then wipe off eyeliner and mascara. Works great.
No 1
Peyton from Los angles
I used this a few times and when it got in my eyes it stung I would get the garnier makeup remover for cheaper and works a lot better.
favorite makeup remover 5
Maggie from Louisiana
I have tried several other makeup removers but I keep coming back to this one. I know it's designed to remove eye makeup but it works all over my face to remove my makeup.
Still leaves behind mascara 4
Dr Sugar from Tampa Fl
I have had a hard time finding an eye-makeup remover that will get off all my mascara and leaves me with racoon eyes. This one does not do great with the mascara, but everything else comes off easy. Very gentle with my skin and leaves my eye tissue moist.
I will buy this again. 5
Mary from Georgia
I love this product. I had a sample of take the day off by Clinique that another retailer gave me. I used it and it was good but the price for a full sized bottle was extremely high. An Ulta rep recommended this Neutrogena kind and it works just as well for a fraction of the price. Easier on my wallet!
Great eye makeup remover 5
cmurphy from Warminster, Pa
Out of all the products I've tried through the years, I've always thought that Neutrogena's eye makeup remover was the best one because it doesn't sting the eyes and removes EVERYTHING! It's also the best priced. I would highly recommend.
Love it 5
Gladys from Maple Grove, MN
It wipes makeup off easily, no hard rubbing needed
Gets the job done 5
Mimi from California
Takes off the most stubborn of waterproof mascaras. It does have an oily feel BUT that's what's needed to breakdown the mascara.
Ehhh.... 3
Beast from Houston, Texas
I normally use Loreal's eye makeup remover but decided to give this a try. OH OH OHHHHH how disappointing! This wouldn't remove my Nyx mascara and I soaked a cotton pad and held it on for a second to try and dissolve what I could without wiping/scrubbing my eye area. My eyes were red after trying to scrape the mascara off and I had to use 3 cotton rounds. I'll be returning this and sticking to my usual.
I would buy this product again 5
Boop from Troy ny
Used other make up remover before. Didn't work as well. Love neutrogena. Takes off eye makeup very well. Will bye it again
Best eye make remover ever 5
All smiles from Nacogdoches, Tx
Great at removing all eyeliner, mascara, she shadow and also eyebrow gel. I love this stuuf. I have used it to remover allover face makeup in a pinch. Wonderful product.
meh 2
s'ylloM from Oregon
it's VERY oily on the skin. left my skin feeling worse and doesn't work the best either
It makes my skin feel so soft 5
Amber C. from PA
This product works well and a little goes a long way. I love how soft it makes my skin feel after each use.
So much oil! 2
Kyla from Olympia
Not understanding how it says "oil free" on the label & also says it doesn't leave oily residue. You can literally see the oil separation in the bottle! It is SO oily when applied. Yes it removes make up well. Definitely wouldn't buy again though just because how much oil it leaves around my eyes
oil free eye remover 5
duch from Missouri
It serves it purpose
Will buy again 5
Michele R from Chesterton, IN
This works great for waterproof mascara. It is also very gentle on your eyes. It definitely removed all my eye makeup but it took a couple swipes.
Best eye makeup remover! 5
LettyV from Torrance, CA
I've tried so many eye makeup removers. By far this one has worked the best.
very oily on the skin 3
Kaylie from Oklahoma City
This product does take your makeup off but it is very oily. As someone who has dry skin I would not recommend this to someone with oily skin.
Perfect eye makeup remover 5
Krys from San Antonio texas
Only ever use this to remove my eyeliner and mascara
LOVE IT!! :) 5
C from :)
Love it!! :) works amazing!!
Best make up remover EVERRRRRRR 5
Mag the rag from Glendale az
LOVE..LOVE
.LOVE BETTER THEN ANY PRESTIGE BRAND OUT THERE.