Cetaphil Gentle Makeup Removing Wipes, Fragrance and Alcohol Free

Most Helpful Critical Review

Very Avarege

I've been using the Cetaphil Gentle Makeup Removing Wipes for a few weeks now, and I have very mixed feelings about them. They're definitely not bad, but I can't say they're great either—just somewhere in the middle. That's why I'm giving them three stars. First off, I will say they are truly gentl...e, which I appreciate. I have sensitive skin, and these wipes didn't irritate my face at all. They don't sting, burn, or cause any redness, even around the eyes, which is a big plus. The wipes also have a very soft texture, and they feel nice against the skin—nothing scratchy or too rough like some other brands I've tried. I also like that they're fragrance-free, because I can't stand strong smells in skincare products, and this one didn't have any weird scent lingering on my face. That being said, the makeup removal part isn't as impressive as I hoped. These wipes are fine for light makeup—like tinted moisturizer, a little blush, or some mascara—but if you're wearing a full face or waterproof products, they just don't cut it. I often had to use two wipes to feel like I got everything off, and even then, I still noticed some makeup left behind when I followed up with my regular cleanser. They're not the worst I've tried, but they're definitely not the most effective either. It's kind of frustrating when a product is marketed as "makeup removing" but can't handle the basics without help. Another thing I noticed is that they leave behind a slight residue. It's not super greasy or sticky, but I could feel something on my skin after using them—like a film that didn't fully absorb. It didn't cause breakouts or anything, but it made me want to wash my face immediately after, which kind of defeats the purpose if I was hoping for a quick, on-the-go cleanse. I wouldn't recommend using these as your only method of cleansing. The packaging is convenient, with a snap lid that keeps the wipes from drying out, but I did find that the top wipe sometimes felt less moist than the others. I also feel like I go through these wipes quickly since one isn't always enough, which makes them a little expensive for what they are. If I'm spending money on wipes, I want them to be efficient—and I just don't feel like these are. In the end, I think these wipes are okay if you have sensitive skin and only wear light makeup, or if you need something travel-friendly and gentle. But for deep or heavy makeup removal, you'll probably need something stronger or follow up with a cleanser anyway. They're not bad, but they're not great either. Just average—and that's why I'm sticking with 3 stars.