Product Reviews Rated 3.83 out of 5 stars
887 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Can't get enough of this ! This eyeliner is the best you can have for a low cost. The tip is so fine it's easy to get the wing done & out of all eyeliners that I have used, this one is so easy it cut the time I take to do my makeup by almost half. love love love. since the tip is felt tip, it's so soft you can barely feel a thing so your eye won't get irritated when applying.
Most Helpful Critical Review Was GREAT and then AWFUL I received this as a gift less than a month ago and at first I LOVED the product. It goes on very quickly and smooth and cut down my time for getting ready extremely in comparison to using my gel pot and brush. Although, I would not recommend it for doing wings because the tip is not fine enough to get a good wing in my opinion. After about three weeks the tip of the brush has dried out and very quickly the rest did as well and now it is basically unusable. The color comes in VERY faded or not at all and that's if i'm making an effort to apply from the back end of the brush and not the tip which is annoying. I've heard other complaints of this so i'm not sure if it's a common fault or if it's because every time I used it it was over top of eye shadow and the eye shadow clearly stuck to the brush which may have made it dry out faster or not work as well. Either way I would not recommend this unless you are someone who barely ever uses eyeliner or rarely wears eyeshadow so maybe it will last you longer.
Reviewed by 887 customers Dry and dry 3
Tiff from Alameda
It was good for 1 wear, no smudges and came off easily when needed. But it only lasted for 1 wear. I thought I might have forgot to close the cap so I bought another and same exact situation. I loved the formula but the way they designed the pen/cap is terrible.
Great, but not waterproof 4
hm1124 from Tempe, AZ
This is a great felt tip liner for creating a wing, the pigment is nice and dark and even. it's easy to use, it would especially be great for a beginner looking to practice winged liner. However if you really need a waterproof eyeliner this isn't it. I don't know why they keep saying it is cause it isn't at all. Maybelline does make great waterproof eye products but this isn't waterproof at all. Now if you don't like waterproof eyeliner this is a great option. However if you need a great waterproof eyeliner I'd recommend the lasting drama gel eyeliner instead. But overall, it is a good liner.
One of my favs! 5
Jess from Wisconsin
I love this product. I buy it over and over again. It's one of my favorites. It's a smooth eyeliner, goes on smooth, stays on and is long lasting. Highly recommended and makes for a great winged eyeliner! Truly one of the best on the market! Great price point!
Favorite for years 5
Nina from Ohio
I've been using this eyeliner for years. Every time I switch, I regret it. So easy to use and get a nice sharp point too.
Dispenses too much liquid 2
Dispenses too much liquid from Downey
I had been using this eyeliner for a while now but recently I noticed that it's dispensing too much liquid. Even if I hardly even press down on it. This has resulted in me just blinking, and it drips down to my lashes and onto my undereye. Which then makes me wash it all off, take off my contact lens because it goes inside my eye, and then redo it. This is horrible when getting ready before work EVERY DAY. Won't buy again.
Terrible 1
Violet from Tempe, AZ
This eyeliner was absolutely terrible. I bought it as a gift for someone, and we both ended up trying it and thinking it was bad quality. The pen would be completely dry, then when I'd apply slightly more pressure, it'd suddenly make a big blob of eyeliner. Once the eyeliner dried, it was flaky. I definitely wouldn't recommend this product.
Stay away 1
Joc from California
This liner is very bad. It's only pigmented for the first use, but after that it is not. It also smudges pretty bad and it just kinda melts off after 30 minutes. The tip of the liner also gets dry after the first use. 10/10 DONT recommend.
Great packaging, mid product 3
Gia from Columbus
Received this as a gift. It applies great, I really like the tip, especially because felt tip liners often clump at the end and dispense too much product after a while. This one has held up great! A huge downside though is the liner itself. It is dark after initial application, but smudges really badly after just an hour. I have never dealt with smudging this bad before. Granted its not waterproof I can understand slight transferring after a couple hours, but this one breaks down immediately and leaves your under eye and surrounding skin looking very messy. I think it would be great for dry skin types that do subtle liner, as someone with combo skin who likes doing really thick liner it just did not work for me.
Dang girl 5
Kelsi from Cincinnati
For the price point? YAS. If it was priced in midrange like too faced, tarte, etc…? YAS. I absolutely love this stuff. It's so easy to work with. I'm a bartender and I wore it on New Years Eve to work. I was sweating like a dead beat dad at a child support court hearing and it stayed for a full 14 hours!
For the price, this is the good stuff 5
Alice from USA
Lasts so long and dries on the skin so quickly. I'm dumb and fall asleep with it on sometimes and half the time I wake up and it still looks good. God bless this eyeliner. Super nice deep black too.
Allergic reaction 2
Doe eyes from Boston
I'm so bummed I had such a bad reaction to this eyeliner because it works great and is very easy to apply. But as soon as I try to remove it or it gets in my eye and, or waterline, it's starts itching like absolute mad and my eyes get incredibly red and irritated. I've never had a reaction to eye makeup before, especially like this ): please note I do have a latex allergy so that may be responsible. I've tried using it a few times hoping other variables were causing the reaction but nope it's the eyeliner.
Dry, smudges, & NOT pigmented 1
Kat from Maryland
Love the size and shape of the applicator but it was extremely dry and not at all pigmented from the first use. It also smudges very easily.
New Favorite Eyeliner 4
Linzy from Tucson, AZ
I like that I can get a thin line with the tip and then thicker where I want. If you make a mistake you'll have to use a wet cotton swab to erase. It stays put very well. Doesn't work on the water line if you like to put eyeliner there. The cap is loose on this one I received, so I'll try another and hope it's not loose.
Okay 3
Jocelyn from North Carolina
The formula is pretty good but it dried out after a couple uses , I wish there was more product
It's ok 4
Christina from Texas
It doesn't run or transfer into fine lines or if you have a hooded eye it dries down fast but for the precision part it just doesn't give me a clean line. The tip of the brush is dry (at least on mine) so I will use this liner for like an outline but have to do the wing with something else that has a better applicator if that makes sense
Tip dries out 3
Marin from 34953
The tip is completely dry and now I can't get a precise line. Wonderful color pay-off, last a long time, but the tip is dry.
Not the greatest formula 2
Raquel from Oregon
When I first applied this, I was so excited since it was very black and easy to use. However, it smudged throughout the day! Not the best eyeliner I have used.
Nice eyeliner pen. 3
Sobreen from Memphis Tennessee
I struggle with eyeliner so I need a really good eyeliner pen. This one is nice and slick but the pen does let out a lot at the sliest touch.
Used to love before they changed it 1
Bella from Texas
Used to absolutely love this product until they changed it! Now I can't stand this, I just recently went to get a new one and it's not even been 2 weeks and the tip is already dried out and hard to apply! I keep it covered all the time so it's nothing I've done. Really disappointed.
Love the concept, formula not great 3
Tinkerbelle from Ohio
Love the brush tip and the fact that I don't need to shake it like my nyx. My only gripe is that it seems to transfer to my lower lash area in the outer corner. Also I cannot seem to get it to flick to get a decent point on a wing. I can make it work but it's not the best.
Simply I love it! 5
Ilia from florida
This is one of my favorites eye liner. Lasts all day without making a disaster and do not smudge..
I wouldn't buy again 1
Panda from Lakewood, CO
It was dried up when I got home. I tried getting it to go again but it smudged on my eyes. I had big raccoon eyes after I got off work. I wouldn't say its waterproof.
Love this eyeliner! 5
Mary from maryland
This is one of the best eyeliners I have tried.
Best and Favorite 5
carashorts from Salt Lake City, UT
I've been using liquid liner for about 8 years and this Master Precise by Maybelline is my all time FAVORITE. The line it creates is perfection and you can go small or big with the wing. Love!
Great for precision 5
kp164 from SoCal
This is very pigmented, lasts all day and is easy to apply. The brush is firm enough that you can get into the inner corner easily to make precise lines. This is my second time purchasing. I use it maybe once every other week, and it lasted me about 10 months before it started to dry out. I'll continue to buy it because of the great price and lasting power.
