Product Reviews Rated 3.19 out of 5 stars
295 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Bring it Back !!! :) I've been using this for years! I can't find a color that compares! It's gone everywhere ! I swear this color had a following !!! Please put it back on the shelves !
Most Helpful Critical Review Terrible Mascara This is one of the worst eyeliners I have ever used. The color of it is very rich and black, but that is the only good thing about it. I used it to tightline my upper lash line, and for the rest of the day it is literally smudging off onto my undereye area. I have rarely used any products in my life that give 'raccoon eyes.'I even tried putting UDPP (eye shadow primer) under my eyes and a lot of eyeshadow to try and keep it in place, but NOTHING helps. Really disappointing because I tend to like Maybelline products a lot. This eyeliner is terrible, terrible, terrible. I'm going to just end up throwing it out.
Reviewed by 295 customers There's better out there 1
Ashley from Nashville
Doesn't last long at all, especially if you're someone that has oily eyelids.
Very terrible product 1
BeckySue81 from Cleves, Ohio
Ok im used to buying L.A. colors because I don't have a lot of money. I decided to really splurge and get the Maybelline define a line which was pretty costly and what I got was worse than the L.A colors honestly. I put it on my lash line and within 20 min it was ran down my face. So I tried it again and the same thing. I trusted that Maybelline was a top of the line makeup and its not. I'm really let down, I cant afford expensive makeup and I'm sad that it was big let down
Please bring back chestnut brown! 4
Blueeyeschestnutlover from New York NY
The eyeliner was always great quality but the browns available are too dark! Chestnut brown was my go to for YEARS! Now I can't find it anywhere ... Please bring it back!
Runs and Smears EVERYWHERE 1
HaylC from Indiana
This is THE WORST eyeliner I have ever used. It goes on easily, but smears everywhere absolutely horribly. So embarrassing how badly it gets everywhere and makes you look like a raccoon. Waste of money, especially for being fairly expensive!
BRING BACK CHESTNUT BROWN EYELINER 5
User123 from Florida
Chestnut brown eyeliner was my daily go-to eyeliner for years. I have yet to find a better color.. Please bring it back
Please bring back Chestnut Brown 5
permis_97 from New York
I have spent way too much time and money looking for a replacement, all I want is the Define a Line eyeliner in Chestnut Brown . Are there any leftovers sitting around some warehouse somewhere ??
My favorite eyeliner 5
Lisafallgirl from Missouri
I have always loved Maybelline eyeliner period I've been searching to find a new one to replace the one I'm almost out of period it's so easy to apply don't and I love the way it brings my eyes out period the other end has a little remover in case you put just a little too much.
chestnut brown 1
kittykat2728 from PA
So disappointed you got rid of the chestnut brown color. Had been using it for over twenty years. These colors are too dark. I really like the light/shimmer color of the chestnut brown. Please bring back!!
Raccoon at work :( 1
Kc2020 from Los Angeles, CA
I wish I would have read reviews before purchasing. Purchased the other day for the first time and was excited to put it on for work... an hour or so later when I noticed my reflection and I looked like a melted raccoon!! I was so embarrassed and the more I tried to remove the worse it got. I had only applied a small line to my upper lid and somehow it got all over my under eye. Even after getting home and using makeup remover I'm having a hard time removing all the smudging. So disappointed and hoping to be refunded. Definitely not using it again.
Nice and Smooth 5
Feshejo from Michigan
This pencil is perfect! It glides. It leaves a nice dark line the first time, but you can double back if you like, for a darker line.
Best eyeliner color of all times 5
SPC_inc from Maryland
I love how this eyeliner contrast with brown eyes.
Pigmented but horrible. 1
JillianFaith from undisclosed
I bought this because my tarte maneater was running low....and it's bad. I love the pigment of it but it's so smudgy upon application I have to constantly look in the mirror just to be sure I'm raccoon free.
good color, smudges a lot :\ 2
Lone Wolfie from Minnesota
it goes on super smooth but you cant touch your eye or else you look like a raccoon
The only thing I use! 5
Janer from undisclosed
Like many others, I am older and have loved this eyeliner pencil for years. Now I can't find the product or a color that is similar. There isn't anything out there like it - PLEASE bring this line back to our stores!
Smears everywhere! 1
Megatron from undisclosed
Advertised as smudge proof, yet I've never had a product smudge so much!! It makes a mess and comes off of you barely tap it.
Smears too much 1
suheid15 from Long Beach, CA
I have tried everything, setting it with dark eye shadow, but it just smears too much! I put it on and I look like I slept or took a shower with it on.
Love this and use it everyday! 5
GMR from Dallas TX
Can use to line eye inside and out
PERFECT! 5
FarmMom from Midwest
I have used 2 or 3 colors for years! Easy to use, smudges easily with the soft tip to soften the look for adult women! Now I cant find 2 of the 3 shades I use! I have now bought several other Maybelline eye liners and none compare and I would return them if I could! Chestnut brown and Brownish Black are the best for women who are not trying to look like they are teens!
I would buy this product again. 5
Nurse purtie from Texas
Very nice and smooth.
Love it! 5
Thefox from New Zealand
I really WANT my eyeliner to smudge a bit. Others cake but this goes on smoothly. I can only use the slate gray, however, which is certainly black enough fo me. I wish Mabelline would make a navy blue! But the smudging softens the look.
smudged 3
AngelM from Bristol, CT
Goes on easy but be sure not to touch it or rub your eyes or it will smear.
The black is awful, the brown isn't bad. 3
Lyia V from Tatum, TX
The black color is AWFUL. Do not buy the black! The brownish-black, however, isn't so bad. It is easier to apply than the black and lasts all day. I like that I can use the sponge on the other end to smudge it into a more "smoky" look and then use the sponge on my bottom lash line to smudge a little bit of the color there too.
it's ok 3
. from .
It's ok, not the best
Worst Maybelline product there is 1
Katie_girl73 from Michigan
I bought this for the first time about a week ago and I'm trying to give it the benefit of the doubt, but no matter what I do or which eyelids this is on, it's smudges like nothing I've ever used before. I don't touch my eyes after I do my makeup, there's no reason for it to smudge.
Bring it Back !!! :) 5
Makeup lover 143 from Tampa Fl
I've been using this for years! I can't find a color that compares! It's gone everywhere ! I swear this color had a following !!! Please put it back on the shelves !
