Product Reviews Rated 2.76 out of 5 stars
83 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Take the cap off! This is a Great product for the price! I received this product as a free tester and I've loved it!
It stays put and while I'm usually a black liner girl, I love the brown I was sent!
My only complaint which is mainly a complaint against my own stupidity is that I spent way tooo long trying to use the smudger side as the pencil...take the cap off...lol.
#revlon #influenster
Most Helpful Critical Review Black Colorstay MICRO Hyper Precise Gel Eyeliner I purchased this last month and loved it, but after a couple of weeks use, the gel became brittle and began to break off out of the pencil leaving clumps of gel on my eyelids and face. I have lost much of the gel due to this breakage. It is a shame that the gel does not last in the pencil like it should. The eyeliner tip is very thin -1.5mm - and once it becomes brittle, the gel is not able to be saved as it can't be put back in the pencil. I have attached a picture of what broke off when lining my right eye that fell on my lashes and face as I tried to use it this morning.
Reviewed by 83 customers Need more 3
Karen from Indiana
I really like how thin this is but you really need to put more makeup gel in the tube, not really a lot bang for your buck....
Black Colorstay MICRO Hyper Precise Gel Eyeliner 1
Scribe from Charleston SC
I purchased this last month and loved it, but after a couple of weeks use, the gel became brittle and began to break off out of the pencil leaving clumps of gel on my eyelids and face. I have lost much of the gel due to this breakage. It is a shame that the gel does not last in the pencil like it should. The eyeliner tip is very thin -1.5mm - and once it becomes brittle, the gel is not able to be saved as it can't be put back in the pencil. I have attached a picture of what broke off when lining my right eye that fell on my lashes and face as I tried to use it this morning.
It was dried up! 1
Monica from Houston
Dried up !
not enough uses 2
Roxie from Ripon,CA
I did like the fine tip of this pencil for lining my eyes. Not happy that it ran out so quick. Wont buy it again for that reason.
Poor value 1
Paulafrn from undisclosed
The thin liner breaks off with just normal pressure of application
Great for tightlining 5
Middle Sister from Lehigh Valley, P/
Works better and is far less expensive than hourglass liner. The perfect dupe.
My new go-to liner 5
LE from Cary, NC
This is my new favorite eyeliner! I find it goes on very easily for a perfect delicate line which is all I want for everyday. It stays on well and I have had no problems with it breaking.
I got this in 4
londonwhite097 from undisclosed
I got this in the colour fig, a dark greyish purple colour. I was expecting it to turn out slightly more purple than it does, it appears almost black, but as it turns out I'm quite a fan of the more subtle colour anyway. I've been able to achieve a nice smokey eyeliner effect with this product; the crayon end goes onto the skin very smoothly with great colour intensity, though it isn't a sharp tip so you have to use fairly thick lines. I've found the brush end to work very well at creating a smokey wing to my eyeliner, however it doesn't always smudge the colour evenly, particularly when softening the main part of the eyeliner. It also reduces the nice colour intensity, so I tend to use a dark eye shadow over the line to give it a bold look. Overall I think this product can give a great smokey look that lasts all day, if you're willing to give it a bit of practice and some extra effort.
Perfect brown 5
Phh710 from Houston, Texas
I don't understand why this eyeliner has so many bad reviews. It's an amazing eyeliner for tightlining and lining the inner rim of your eyes. It's creamy and highly pigmented. I had no problem with it breaking. I love that it is so small and precise and stays only in my lash line.
Minus one star 1
Bo from undisclosed
Been wearing revlon colorstay eyeliner for many years. Thought this was the pencil I always used. Infuriated that I purchased this thinking it was the same quality. I couldn't even get it to go across half an eyelid before breaking off. Way too thin. I wasted the entire pencil trying to do both eyes. Retire this product to protect revlon colorstay reputation and consumers.
Tip breaks easily , disappointed of the product 1
Alexis from Florida
Worst eyeliner I have even had. Tips breaks easily. My micro eyeliner last me a week, because the crayon kept breaking. You have to be super super gentle not to break. It was a disappointment and waste of money!
Not what it seems 1
Not happy from Melbourne Australia
Not really a gel eyeliner. Just a very thin pencil. Breaks easily doesn't glide on as it says. But rather drags the skin on the eyelid. Extremely disappointed. Must be better products on the market. I cannot use this. So total waste of money.
Almost great 4
14Angie from Michigan
I have been using this for a while now. I love that I can get brown, it is great for a small line, but it breaks way too easily. I am wasting money having to replace it so often due to the breaking. I would love to continue use, hopefully there is some 'fix' in the works.
Poor quality 1
Ruby from undisclosed
The crayon fell from the pen as soon as I opened the package. And it couldn't stay put after I inserted it back to the pen. I need a refund .
Very Frustrating!!!!! 1
ldrm from Utah
This eyeliner is awful! Every time I use it it breaks! It breaks off so easily that I have a very hard time even putting it on. I only twist it so it is barely long enough to apply to my eyes, and it still breaks! I am very disappointed.
It breaks off !! 1
Nilu from Ireland
I was excited to try out the hyper precision gel and was trying to use it exactly as per instructions. Let me tell you, you roll out a small bit, and it skips since it's too hard. Roll out more and it breaks. There's no winning with this one. Totally disappointed !
Horrible! 1
Brandie from Eastover, SC
Bought this to survive southern heat whilst looking beautiful. Sadly the tip kept breaking so I was not able to use it at any length. I made several attempts to adjust the height for use. This is a dud 👎.
Don't buy this 1
Drea from CO - Colorado
I could not get this to work, I am not sure if it is an old product. It was a big waste of money.
Not the best 3
Sierra from Buffalo, NY
I usually apply eyeliner to my upper and lower lashlines. This breaks too easily when I am applying it because the tip is too thin. But the color looks decent, and it does stay well.
Truly micro 2
Sharlamay from Oklahoma City
The eyeliner is micro and does stay well. This is my second purchase and I'm unhappy. I bought on April 12 and it's already done. Pieces kept breaking off or falling out. There is no retractable to it. If you do it falls out. I love the product but not the applicator.
No matter how gentle I am it breaks!! 1
TO23 from Southeast Michigan
Horrible product! Don't waste your money, every time I used it, the tip would break off.
The Eyeliner Fell Out After 2nd Use 1
TheMrsKidd from OKC, OK
Would have loved it had it not fallen apart!
It is dry....it must be old stock. 1
not much make up from Florida
I tried to apply it and it just broke off dry
I would buy this product again. 4
Steph from kansas City, MO
It flows easily.
Eyeliner crumbled and fell out. 1
7 turtles from Santa Fe, NM
I barely touched the eyeliner to my eye and it broke off repeatedly. Waste of money.
