Revlon

 ColorStay Micro Easy Precision Liquid Liner

My go to liquid eyeliner product! Have purchased in brown as well. Able to get a thin line and close to lash line. Only not giving it full stars because as the container dries out/ runs low and as wear from using it happens, the tip becomes a little worn out and the liquid because more dried out and kind of clumps where it seals. Also, no full stars because it is not transfer proof and can smudge away if not careful. Would may need to reapply

I appreciate the precision tip. Perfect for thin lines. What i don't like is the formula. It is like glue if it gets on your eyelashes during application. I would not buy again.

The ColorStay Micro Easy Precision Liquid Liner allows fine lines. I use the black with the brown, What The Fudge, color over it to soften the look. The Colorstay liner stays in place without smudging. Best eyeliner ever!

Good for someone who needs thin lines on top or lower eyelid, probably great for graphic liner looks/precise lines. Does not bleed or pool to the bottom/outer corners of your eye (winged eyeliner) but it also won't stay there throughout the day. It's just not a match for me and my needs for an eyeliner. For liquid liner, I prefer something a bit thicker that I can put on my waterline. The formula is thin but very opaque and will just slide off. I can't envision this being good for someone with oily or watery eyes. I envision this eyeliner being for someone that likes really thin and simple winged liner, or even drawing lash-like lines.

I have been looking for an eyeliner just to do a simple little baby wing. I'm pretty bad at it so a super thin brush like this is great. it's pretty good I think. I only deducted a star because I was hoping this would be a nice dark more chocolate-y brown and it's almost a reddish brown which I don't love.