Rated 4.13 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Amazing I love this Product
I am not a big fan of Mascara but this one I fell in love with it doesn't take a lot but it has big pay off. I got this in a gift set that I got for my birthday. It makes me look like I have on fake lashes when I don't so that's a plus! What's not to love it's Too Faced! I am doing this review as part of and Influenster contest.
Most Helpful Critical Review I used to love it
I used to love this mascara, it was lengthening and waterproof but the last one I bought smudged all over and it was super clumply, I do t know if they changed the formula but is totally messy now, will be looking for another one
Reviewed by 24809 customers I buy this item every time I run out!!!
Wendy from Houston TX
This is a amazing mascara.
Bb from Louisville, ky
This stuff is really over hyped. It goes on tacky, clumpy, doesn't lengthen, and just looks bad. I'm disappointed!
Def Not Waterproof
Remy from Scottsdale, AZ
Oof, where do I begin? Its not remotely waterproof, they definitely missed the mark here. It looks nice, but nothing special. I'm still on my search on a good waterproof mascara in this AZ heat.
All-time Favorite Mascara
V from Jacksonville, FL
I have used who knows how many different kinds of mascaras in my life, but after discovering this mascara about 5 years back, I haven't really used anything else. I have shorter eyelashes, but this mascara makes my eyelashes so long I've been asked if I'm wearing falsies. Even if I'm buying all drug store makeup, I'll still splurge on this mascara. 10/10
Maddy from CA
I ditched my go-to mascara for this product after getting a free travel size with a too face purchase. Its not very cumpy and does a good job of balancing length and fullness. The only downside is it begins to flake and run after an hour or two.
I would buy this product again and again
LA from Plain Township, Ohio
Looks just like fake lashes so full and long
T from Pocatello, ID
Love love this mascara however I wish it didn't dry out so dang quickly. It's so expensive to dry up in a month.
It's not even remotely waterproof...
Storm from Sacramento
This product remains tacky for hourssss and rubs off on my lids like no other. It's super clumpy. I feel like I could have gotten better results with a $5 drug store waterproof formula.
My tried and true.
MakeupFinatik from The woodlands
I've been using this mascara for the last 5 years, and when I tell you it's my go to I mean it! Of coarse I've tried tons of others, but I always end up going back to BTS. Volumized and lengthened my lashes every use.
First & Last BTS Waterproof Purchase
AngHeb985 from Houma, LA
I usually love Too Faced products; however, the waterproof mascara is the worst. It's incredibly heavy and sticky (and we're talking one coat). Because it doesn't ever really dry, it smudges. And when it smudges, it's hard to remove. It's like tar - that's the best word I can use to describe this goo. Extremely disappointed.
It was unfortunately underwhelming...
Kayla from New Jersey
I was just very sadly not impressed. I've wanted to try it for a very long time and it just didn't work out for me. Definitely doesn't mean it couldn't work for someone else. I felt I spent a lot of money to be unimpressed.
Not worth the hype
Isabellam from United States
This mascara with great for the first week and I loved it, but after about a week it got extremely dry and flaky. This product doesn't last long and starts to apply dry.
Not purchasing again
Brenda from Long Beach ca
Too expensive you don't get your money's worth
Had to say bye to too many lashes
Amy from Los Angeles
This mascara was a total let down. It never seemed to dry, and would get everywhere. The want is too big/bulky for a clean application. Even when I did manage to get it on without getting it all over the place, it would transfer to anything it touched (and being that I have deep set/hooded eyes it was a major problem). The amount of product that came out on the wand was insane and I was constantly trying to get to excess off but I would still get globs of it. The worst though is that it never dried properly. It was always tacky and even after I used makeup remover and face wash it would still just be black under my eyes and my eyelashes were still stuck together and gunky. And every time I removed the mascara there were sooooo many eyelash hairs on the cotton pad I'm surprised I still have some on my eyes
LOVE LOVE LOOOOVE IT!
Ashley from Sevierville, Tennessee
This is the BEST & most AMAZING mascara in the market, I've tried almost everything out here from the cheap drugstore brands all the way to the mist expensive, but this brand is my most #1 top rated, its the only kind ill EVER use.
Worst mascara ever
Rae from US
I had super high hopes for this mascara but it does absolutely nothing but become a clumpy disaster and is way over priced save your money and get the l'oréal lash paradise
Went on very clumpy
Lori from Illinois
Might be a great product, but definitely not made for small eyes
The product its self is good but the packaging is so cheap.
Liz from Texas
I purchased this product because the reviews were so highly recommended. I used the mascara about 2 weeks and the inside of the mascara broke off and was a waste of money. For this product being a high end product i don't understand why they wouldn't concentrate more on their products.
Holy grail mascara
Kalyn R. from Michigan
Slap a layer of Lancôme mascara primer before, then this is all you'll need. Been using BTS for years!
I would buy this product again
JPreston from Stroudsburg PA
Used it the same day of purchased, my friend asked if I had falsies
Want to love it, but don't
Case317 from CT
I love the way my lashes look after using this mascara, but the issue I have is that it always rubs off under my eyes. After about an hour, I have black rings under my eyes even if I haven't touched them at all. Not worth the price unfortunately.
Looks so natural
Maddy from Austin, TX
I used this mascara a couple years ago and thought it was over hyped. I recently tried it and fell in love! This makes my lashes look so natural and full. No clumping at all!
Dfav from CT
Travel mascara. Easy to carry but product was very dry... almost returned it but needed it for a next day trip!
em n em from Los anglese
Loved at one time. recently bought 2 during the 21 days sale and found both were dried out. not sure if ulta sells the older ones or the formula is changing.
Not worth the hype
Tee from LC TX
I got this as a free gift and I'm not impressed. The wand is very nice but the actual product comes of very goopy and thick which results in clumping. Throughout the day, the mascara would ball up and flake