Rated 4.13 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Amazing I love this Product
I am not a big fan of Mascara but this one I fell in love with it doesn't take a lot but it has big pay off. I got this in a gift set that I got for my birthday. It makes me look like I have on fake lashes when I don't so that's a plus! What's not to love it's Too Faced! I am doing this review as part of and Influenster contest.
Most Helpful Critical Review I used to love it
I used to love this mascara, it was lengthening and waterproof but the last one I bought smudged all over and it was super clumply, I do t know if they changed the formula but is totally messy now, will be looking for another one
Reviewed by 24989 customers Worst Mascara EVER!
Maggie from Corpus Christi, Texas
After all the hype, decided to purchase, and it has been the worst one, yet. It flaked on my face as I applied it and the waterproof just feels like clump on my lashes, cause yes I tried the waterproof one as well. It doesn't last long and dries up in tube pretty quick. And no, I don't pump the wand in there. I bought it a second time thinking maybe the first was a bad batch, but it got just as dry and ALWAYS flaked during application. I went back to Loreal!
Looking for mascara?
Nurse Ellen from Port St. Lucie Florida
Best mascara ever
Not A Good Buy
Pam from Portland, OR
When I initially opened the box and unscrewed the mascara wand from the container, I noticed there was no seal and the wand was DRY. I used the mascara one time and it was not as advertised. It doesn't give you the long, full, voluminous lashes like the box said. I will be returning for a refund.
My personal fave
bundysmom from Las Vegas
I rarely wear makeup; you wouldn't know I have some pretty amazing lashes hiding…but I do. After trial & error practically every brand out there this one ends up being my personal fave.
Lengthens, separates. Not clumpy or drying. No flakes. No irritation. Removes easily with my face cleanser or Neutrogena clothes. My lashes look amazing every time I coat them with this. I always come back to this one without fail.
If this isn't available I also use Diors Volumizing mascara for similar results I receive from Too Faced.
Morgen. from My house
I love this mascara, it makes my lashes so volume filled and feathery. Will be buying again.
My favorite mascara❤️
Dana from Ohio
Love this product, stays on all day!!!
Stephanie from McKinney, Texas
Bought this travel size for a anniversary trip. Never got a single smudge from being hit and sweaty in Vegas. Yet, came off very easily with eye makeup remover. I will buy regular size for day to day use!
Han from Chicago, IL
Mascara smudges everywhere and does not give my lashes a lasting curl
Middle of the road mascara
Lorry from Rochester, NY
Color is great, but did tend to clump and flake.
Not better than sex for me....
Nikki from Ohio
Clumpy, smudgy, not sexy. I won't buy again. I'd rather have my man.
Not worth the money
Yg from Phoenix
Worst mascara I've ever tried. I'm glad Ulta has a return policy.
Rose from USA
This mascara is not smudge-proof or curling for me. I do not use moisturizer on my eyelids and I apply after using Urban Decay eyeshadow primer and eyeshadow. That said, it leaves my whole under eye black within 1-2 hours just doing computer work. I tried using setting powder on concealer but made no difference. I also was hoping this would have a curl effect but it actually weighed them down and straightened within an hour.
SuzyQ from NY
I never write reviews but this is so bad I just had to.
With no water even involved this smudged ALL OVER top lids, bottom lidS, EVERYWHERE!! I feel pretty stupid returning a travel size but this is SO BAD and SO EXPENSIVE that I'm definitely gonna!!! Would give zero stars if it was an option!!
SO not smudge proof
soullesun from Reno NV
I got this, a waterproof mascara because I have been fighting smudging a lot and I wanted something I can wear all day at work. I am a CNA and I work 12 hour shifts, so I need something that lasts and can stand up to literal blood, sweat and tears! Back to the drawing board because this ain't it.
my lashes look great and I love the brush, but it isn't what it's advertised to be.
Starfishie from Melbourne, FL
I wouldn't recommend this mascara. It clumps, flakes, and smudges. Disappointing.
Used to Love This But Not Anymore
Starfishie from Melbourne, FL
Did Better Than Sex change the formula of this mascara? Because it used to be fabulous and it's not anymore. It clumps easily and flakes now. It never did that before. I wouldn't recommend it anymore.
Don't waste your money.
Sandra from TN
My honest opinion, t's not worth the money. Sure, I love it in the morning makes my lashes look great. But, by the afternoon my lashes have fallen and there's flakes everywhere. I found a $7 CoverGirl mascara is much better and lasts all day.
bharles from USA
Idk why this doesn't have 5 star ratings and people say it's not waterproof that's cuz there's a separate better than sex waterproof mascara which is blue. This is my favorite mascara ever just too broke to get it again :(
my new fav.
tiffany from grandview,tn
I love this mascara!! I have used bareminerals and other high end mascaras i Deff. have a new favorite
Not really waterproof
Abt from Indiana
Its exactly like the regular better then sex mascara, it smudges throughout the day & its not actually waterproof. Ive tried drug store mascaras that performs better.
Didn't really like it
Shawn from Niles Illinois
Still swears and you end up with raccoon eyes. It's supposed to be waterproof I don't like so. And to pay as much as you do for it you are expecting it to really work. Was very disappointed.
Baby from MI
Is it even possible for a mascara to make your lashes look smaller? well, this mascara does that for me. I will stick to my tried and true Thrive and Il Makiage mascaras.
Brandi from Yakima Wa
Best waterproof mascara
PeppermintPatty14 from Eastern North Carolina
I received a trial size of this mascara. I loooove it! I think it's the wand shape (hourglass) and the quality of the actual mascara. It really works well. I'm going to buy a regular size and ditch the rest of my mediocre mascara.
Never thought I'd spend this much on mascara but it's worth
Mal from New York
Got this on a whim while returning another mascara and it's pretty unbelievable how great it is. My eyelashes are short and thin so I always have an issue with maintaining the curl and so far all day my lashes look great.