Product Reviews Rated 3.85 out of 5 stars
639 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review BEST EYELINER FOR COLLEGE GIRLS This is my absolute favorite eyeliner!! It's very easy to control and it gives such a clean and sharp wing. It's a perfectly intense black and it just draws so smoothly. I use it almost every day and it hasn't dried up at all after months! I'm so impressed- my skin is pretty oily and this is the only eyeliner I've found that is immune to that. It's survived rain, sweat, three intense cry seshes in one day (crying about stress, homework, and boys) (multiple times), I've literally SLEPT with it on and it was fine in the morning. The 24 hour (and better than sex) is no lie!! I've tried a few different eyeliners in the past but nothing beats this one. I've gotten so many compliments on how good my eyeliner is and honestly I have to give credit to this eyeliner because of how quickly and cleanly it draws! I usually don't like to spend too much on makeup but this product is life-changing and SO worth it!!! If you read this whole thing and are convinced I also recommend the waterproof mascara, once you have the combination of these two products your eye makeup will be flawless and smudge proof even after crying. I don't know how I'd survive college without this.
Most Helpful Critical Review False Claims I was so excited to use this eyeliner. The Ulta worker that helped me told me how this is the most amazing eyeliner because it lasts 24 hours, it's smudge-proof, and water-proof. I asked if he's ever tried it (he didn't). If he did, he would know these claims are absolutely false.
I shook the eyeliner a lot before I opened it (the box said to shake and I read many reviews that said shaking is the key to getting good pigmentation). I started applying it by using the tip to make the tail/flick of my cat eye. The color was sheer, it looked almost grey. I shook it some more and applied the same way again. The color coming off the top was still very sheer. I used the body of the brisk to go over my lash line. The color didn't improve much. I went to do my other eye and I noticed the color was a bit darker, but not as dark as I wanted.
When I inspected both eyes, I noticed a ton of color transferred from my lash line to my lid (I hate this). Since I had a mess on my lid, I decided to test out the "smudge-proof" claim. It smudged on both eyes easily and spread the color all over my eyes. I was able to use just water to remove all the color.
I was so disappointed in this product. It didn't deliver on any of it's claims. I couldn't imagine this eyeliner lasting more than a few hours. Stick with Stila. I'm returning this next time in near an Ulta.
Reviewed by 639 customers Not proof anything 1
Mar from LA
If you need an eyeliner that fades quickly and is easy to rub off this is the eyeliner
My Go To 5
STEPH98 from WI
I have used and tried countless liquid eyeliners and this one is MILES above the others. I prefer thin and precise eyeliner looks and this is the only one that works for me in no time at all. There's no need for an extra layer to get the coverage I want like some other liners out there and stays ALL DAY without smudging. 10/10
NOT WATERPROOF 1
Steph from Texas
Buy this eyeliner if you love smudging and cheap looks. I don't know why it says waterproof, maybe as a joke? Lol But seriously, if you respect yourself buy any other eyeliner before wasting your money on this one.
I would not buy this 1
Velia from Hacienda
I used it once and it was dry!
I would buy again 5
VBlack from tx
everyday wear
Nope. 1
Amber from Olympia, Wa
Frayed tip after a weeks use. Bought again, frayed again…..NEVER AGAIN!
Dries out quick 1
Bb from UT
Worked well for a day or two and then dried out. Not worth what you pay, for sure.
Not much product inside. 2
Vicki A from Spfld, IL
I don't know what the problem has been? I have had some of these eyeliners that work great and plenty of product. However, recently it's like I'm getting eyeliners that don't last a week! It's like it's almost dried up or gone when I first open it! I can't afford to buy a new eyeliner every week. Not sure what to try next. Maybe it's been on the shelf too long or just bad batches? hmmm, second time in a row recently though! Definitely too expensive for a week or two's use! :-(
Perfect product 5
Shemica from Sumner wa
The most perfect waterproof eyeliner ever absolutely adore it
Messy 1
Sheena from Merritt island fl
It sounds odd to call a liquid eyeliner too wet, but that's the best way i can find to describe this one. The tip is so soft that it is not easy to control. The liquid bleeds into any crease or line you might have from squinting or normal eye movement. It doesn't stay put.
Love it! 5
Oli from Kansas
This eye liner is AMAZING! The tip is very small so it's GREAT fro doing precise thin lines, especially my daily wings. It glides on beautifully, is very pigmented (I've never had one *this* black) and I haven't had any smudging whatsoever within about 8hrs of wear! Most eyeliners leave the smudgy stuff under my eyes after a while, and this has stayed put! 20/10 recommend!
Wouldn't buy again 2
Ray from Fayetteville AR
I actually bought this product in-store because it was recommended to me. As someone who is pretty new to eyeliner, I loved how easy it was to apply. However, about a week into using the product, it began to smudge really bad. Throughout the day I would have to re-apply over and over because there would be random blotches of the eyeliner that smudged off. It's definitely not water-proof, and although the brush works very well, it becomes frayed very quickly. I had high-hopes for this eyeliner but I really can't say I would buy it ever again.
Love this eyeliner 5
Pam from Oak creek, wi
This is the best eyeliner I have ever used
Great 5
Biz from My couch
Best eye liner I've ever used
Try this product! 5
Teri from East Troy, Wi
This product is simply amazing and I recommend it. Very soft bristles and applies perfectly!
Love this 5
wlw56 from Virginia
This is my favorite liquid liner. I love the brush and the formula is great for my sensitive eyes.
I keep coming back! 5
Bellalynne from Cincinnati, OH
I love this eyeliner. I have been using it for years. I tried it the first time because I like the mascara and figured they eyeliner might be decent. I don't have issues with fading or smudging. The application is super smooth and I don't have issues with bleeding or anything like that. I will say after awhile the bristles of the tip get a little unruly, but it's not to the point that is unusable or anything. (Plus, usually if it's just one or two I trim them and it's over with.) Definitely recommend!
Wouldn't Purchase Again 3
agreener from Nevada
this eyeliner goes on easily however it does not last at all. it smudges more than any other liner ive ever tried. even with eyeshadow primer it stood no chance. its also more gray than black.
I love this 5
awells31 from California
I have tried a ridiculous amounts of liquid eyeliners. It's almost disturbing. This one is definitely in my top 3. Here's why: 1. when applying...application is smooth, no tugging, 2. no drying out. As many times as I've repurchased this liner...I've never had mine dry out. 3. It's staying power is amazing...in the winter! Summer could be better. 4. The perfect amount of ink comes out of the tip. My only issue is, is the bristles easily can poke out and it gets worse over time. Granted that was 2 out of 7 times I've bought it. So im ok with that. lol. I recommend.
MUST BUY!!! 5
urmom from ohio
i received this eyeliner as a christmas gift and i swear it is the best i have ever used!! it is very precise and stays on the whole time i have my makeup on. i used to use gel or liquid liners but i will NEVER buy another eyeliner from another brand. you have to try it at least ONCE I PROMISE YOUUU
I usually don't spend this much on eyeliner 5
Jon Dor from FL
This didn't come with a protective seal. Not sure if all of them where like that, or if mine was tampered. I purchased this in store. And ideally I pick ones that have plastic seals. But since this one was in a paper box so, it was difficult for myself to see the product without opening the box. I will ask the an employee next time for help.
YES YES AND YES 5
kass from Jacksonville, FL
Hear me out. You might think "eyeliner is just eyeliner I can buy one at the drugstore and it'll do the same thing." NO. This eyeliner is so perfect. I've tried several drug store eyeliners and somehow this eyeliner tops them all. They made it very pigmented so it's super bold and black. It's very precise so it's easy to create a winged look. It's my fav and I'm honestly not surprised because their better than sex mascara is equally amazing!
Doesn't stay on 2
Di from Lisbon,Ct
Put this on and about 30 minutes later it was faded and worn off. Had to reapply multiple times just to keep effect of a winged liner
Sometimes maybe good sometime maybe ssh 2
Em from Bronx
Not the best Liquid eyeliner it does smudge easy and I did notice it fades. It's easy to use and feels good in hand but the actual product not 100% more of a 60%
Not smudge proof 2
Moon from California
Smudges very easily…
