Rated 4.61 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Best toner for combination skin
It's has a great formula for combination skin. I always had an oil problem at my T-zone and feel dry at my cheeks after washing my face. But Thayers toner makes my skin feel calm and soft. I feel like the moisturizer cream absorbs better and quickly after I used Thayers toner.
Most Helpful Critical Review Changed the formula when sold out to Loreal.
I've been using the rose petal toner for years and it was the absolute best. I read that they sold out to Loreal last year so I expected the product would be altered. The original product did not have added caprylyl glycol, ethylhexylglycerine, or potassium hydroxide. The water no longer says purified and the fragrance no longer says what it is, where it used to say natural rose. This may not matter to some people, but it certainly did to me. It's a shame that they changed the formula unnecessarily. So sad to have to find a new company to purchase this from. If it isn't broken, don't fix it.
Reviewed by 2665 customers They changed the formula and it's not that great
Lulu from US
I've been using the Thayers rose petal toner for about a decade, that's how much I loved this product. I recently repurchased via Ulta, and I noticed immediately the difference. First and foremost the scent is awful. It used to be a light rose water scent, but now it is a strong artificial powdery scent, irritates my skin and sinuses. yuck! It's also not as hydrating and refreshing as it used to be which sucks. I asked the company if they changed the formula and they gave me this long-winded advertisement reply which in the end they were saying yes they did change the formula. Ugh. I can't use this anymore which bums me out because the rose petal toner used to be so great for my skin, why I've used it for a decade! I'm going to give the unscented version a try, but I'm not holding my breath that it won't irritate my skin now too.
Have bought multiple times
Deanna from New York
Love this toner, refreshing!
Vanna from Boise
I've been using the same toner for years, I have very sensitive skin so I really change my skin routine. I only bought this because it was on sale and I wanted to try something new. It has changed my skin! I used to have those little white bumps especially on my forehead and my jaw and they are completely gone now! I got the unscented one just in case because my skin is very sensitive, but I love this and I don't think I'll go back to my old toner.
Jackie from Indiana
I have sensitive dry/normal skin. I've tried other toners, but the cucumber toner is the only one I've found that doesn't break my skin out. I also like the size for the price which is nice on the wallet.
LOVE I got Coconut Water
Linny from NY
I love what it does to my skin!! I feel it working wonders once I apply it, I think I'll try Rose Petal scent next cause I didn't like the coconut smell too much
Carolyn from NY
Feels light and fresh. Makes your skin feel soft. Doesn't sting.
makes my skin feel great
rachel from atlanta
i have very sensitive skin and i am very acne prone to the point that i have to use prescription acne medicine. i use this in the morning and at night before bed to clean off dirt/excess oil, and it works great without irritating my skin or causing breakouts. i use the rose petal one and it smells really good. highly recommend!
Would purchase again
Megan from Yulee, Fl
I like this toner better than others I have tried. I love the smell.
Yes, would buy again
Josie from Ar
Been using this product for a year or so. Love it!
Best impulse buy!
Sunnie from Davenport,IA
Forgot to pack my toner for weekend getaway so grabbed this 3 years ago and realized Thayers was so much better than what I was using. I have sensitive skin and have no problem with Thayers Witch Hazel Toner!
finished a bottle before this review
Yala from My house
I bought the rose toner and while I tried to like it, as it's a cheap alternative to my regular toner, I just couldn't. We weren't compatible. Maybe it's the witch hazel but it always irritated my skin. I'll have to look elsewhere.
Amazing scent and so refreshing to use
Ghostgirl1 from Virginia Beach, VA
This is a regular staple product for me. I use after cleansing my skin at night. Removes any makeup residue and tightens and shrinks my pores without drying out my skin. I use it in the morning again as a wake up freshener. The scent is perfect and starts you on a positive note for the day.
Added bonus: This product also stopped the itch when my husband got poison ivy and stopped the "cat scratch" itch when my daughter was scratched by our kitten. Since it is non-alcoholic it does not dry up the skin.
Definitely Will Buy This Product
Leesa from Little Rock, AR
I appreciate the makeup artist who assigned me and the toner is wonderful.
Pores look smaller and skin is well-balanced
Kate from Atlanta, GA
My esthetician told me to use this toner in the morning instead of cleanser. I wasn't thrilled about the idea but now I've been using it for two weeks and my pores are smaller and my face doesn't get as greasy during the day. Highly recommend if you have sensitive/combination skin
Rose Petal is the best one
Lulu from US
I've tried all versions of this toner except the unscented. I will mention my experience with the other versions because I've noticed when a product has multiple types/scents, the reviews on Ulta can be confusing because we can't tell which version the review is about.
I have combination sensitive skin, and I've found the rose petal version to be the best for my skin: it does the job of a toner without causing irritation. It feels fresh and leaves my skin soft. I've noticed a general tone and texture improvement from this too. Rose Petal is the only one I will continue to repurchase.
Cucumber smells good but it was very drying, which I didn't expect. If you have oily skin, you may like the cucumber one.
Lavender was good at first, but a few uses it caused too much irritation to my skin. Though I was disappointed, I was not really surprised. Lavender isn't always the best to use on skin, especially for sensitive skin types.
Coconut broke me out really bad! I should have known because coconut water and coconut oil can cause acne. Stay away unless you know coconut doesn't break you out.
Love but don't Overuse!
Essie from Maryland
I have sensitive normal/borderline-oily skin and bought the travel size cucumber version. I love this product for clearing skin when I have little breakouts or flare ups of acne which are rare for me. I only use this probably twice a week and at night hence the travel size. It does brighten my skin and even out texture. I gave it 4 stars because it would not use it how it's recommended. I would not use this every day for any skin type as it is very DRYING even for oily skin!
I would only buy this if your skin is not too dry.
JoJo from Seattle, WA
I have tried different toners in the past which I was not impressed with. I was hoping this one would be better after I saw it on the Today show. The person said this one would not dry your skin like previous ones. If I only use it at night it is OK. But when I have used it also in the morning my cheeks get pretty red during the day.
I definitely will buy again
Turbo from Michigan
Helps heal poison ivy and dries up excess oils without any burn. Leaves me feeling fresh and clean. I just apply it with a cotton ball or pad.
It's amazing at first then loses its touch
nana from Winchester
It was really good at first made myself skin even looking and no acne . After using it for awhile it just didn't help anymore . It was like if I wasn't even using any type of toner anymore . So if your looking for a toner that works for awhile this isn't ur go to
Katie from Utah
Love how this leaves my skin! I use treatment and moisturize afterward and my skin is so clear! Mild enough to use twice a day. Not drying as it doesn't have alcohol. My go to witch hazel toner!
Bad for my skin
VTE from Rochester
I bought this in the coconut version. I have combination skin so I though this would be fine. It made my skin oily but did hydrate it well. However for some reason it made my eyelids SOOO oily. I don't know how or why since I don't put it on them and I try not to use a lot. I thought at first it might have been something else since I had altered my skin care routine at the same time, but almost a year later and when I put this on at night I wake up with super oily eyelids. I don't know if this product overall is the issue or if it's just the coconut version but either way was not worth it.
A person from California
I've been using the lemon scented toner for about 4 months now and wow! I see a huge difference… I have oily and acne prone skin, but my oil and pimples really depends on what I ate the other day or the weather, and this product really deep cleans my skin and removes excess oil and helps to make my skin feel clean and dries pimples. One complaint I do have is that it burned the area around my nose and really hurts when you have cuts or busted pimples on your face. But other than that, love it!!
Zena from WA
It cleans very well and it helps with different skin type.
Very refreshing on my face, especially under my eyes
Ree' from Memphis
One of the best cleaning products I used today
do not use if you have dry or sensitive skin
elizabeth from united states
i wanted to try this out since everyone was talking about it, but it dried out my skin, stung like crazy, and didn't even do anything.