Rated 4.42 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Portable and Easy to use
I have been using a dept brand gel pot eyeliner but I hate having to clean out the brush after each use and pencil eyeliners need to be sharpened or the lids always seem to break off me.
One of the things that brought my attention to EL was that it had dual tips.Which I like. For best application I have to relax my eye so I get a straighter line but the color is great.Stays on all day and removes easily.The only thing I noticed is if I leave it standing up in my brush vase the color seems to run to the other end so I have to shake it to get it to flow again. Now I just lay it flat to avoid this but I love that I can just throw it in my purse when I'm in a hurry.
Most Helpful Critical Review Ok Eyeliner
I have a problem with this eyeliner - the thin end doesn't work whenever I want to draw a precise line. And I have +10 years of experience using eyeliners. It looks like the fluid/ink doesn't come to the very end of the tip.
If I want to have a thicker line it works perfect. I'm disappointed with this eyeliner.
On the good side it doesn't smudge and it's easy to wash. I also like that it is mat.
Reviewed by 96 customers I am in love!
Enda from Maple Grove, MN
I tried so many eyeliners from cheaper to high end brands. I have hooded and sensitive eyes, when I found this eyeliner and put it on, I am impressed and love love this! It's so easy to apply, stay on and last longer. No more drama with my eyes. Beautiful packaging too.
Best Eyeliner on the Market!
Indigo from Tacoma, Washington
I have used countless eyeliner brands trying to find the best eyeliner. I will look no further! I like the choice of the thin or thicker line. Looks great & stays on the entire day! I love this product!!
Christy from Spanish Fort, AL
This liner is a game changer. I struggle with wrinkly eyelids and this liner makes application a breeze and stays put! The dual ended tip gives you options depending on what look you want to achieve.
skincare guru from muscatine, iowa
I was disappointed when the automatic duo eyeliner pencil was discontinued. the estee lauder consulant told me to try the little black liner, and I love it. It works in 3 ways.
I Love this Product!
Kim from Clay, WV
I love this eyeliner. It is so easy to apply, and it doesn't flake or come off until you remove it! I will definitely buy this product again!
KF from Los Angeles, CA
Was really hoping this product would compare to the discontinued Double Wear Zero Smudge liquid eyeliner, but the formula is sorely lacking in quality, especially for this price. This eyeliner smudges very easily and does not have a very smooth application. The black isn't as bold as the Double Wear, and requires a few applications to achieve a clean, matte look. Disappointed to say that I've tried drug store liquid eyeliners that have proven better quality.
Cris from Mission, Texas
Horrible eyeliner. It's nothing like the liquid eyeliner. It's too sad to know it was discontinued to give promotion to a eyeliner that does not meet my standards. Because of it I'm in search for a different brand now.
My new go to
IrishEyes from Pocatello, Idaho
Lasts all day but washes of easily. Does smear or stick to my contact lenses. Best eyeliner I have EVER used.
KC from New Tazewell, TN
I hate this liner. It's nothing like the double wear liner that was discontinued and this is the only other liquid liner they have to try. It doesn't last very long at all and dries out within seconds of being opened. Currently looking for a different brand.
My go to eyeliner
Est from Brooklyn ny
I have been using this eye liner for a couple of years now and would never change it!!! Easy to use and stays on all day!
Would always recommend this!
Ani from Georgia
This is the best liner I have ever bought. It's very comfortable and easy to use.
The best liner
Ana from Pittsburg, KS
I have used eye liners from other companies but after using the one from Estée Lauder will not use anything else. It glides well and has two sides, one for the fine line and one for the thick line. Would strongly recommend the product.
I've tried many liquid liners and this is my favorite
Molly from Hilton Head
I've tried many liquid liners and this is one of my favorite. I like the thick end for upper lids and fine liner for lower lids. It goes on smooth and gives a solid line. It last all day without any smudging. I have used estee Lauder cosmetic for years and this eyeliner is as high quality as I have come to expect.
Old School from Burbank, California
I'm not sure why Este Lauder got rid of their double wear zero smudge liquid eyeliner and replaced it with this pen. The pen doesn't glide that well and it pulls on my eyelid when applying. The double wear liquid eyeliner didn't have a great applicator either. However, I was able to use another brush to apply it. The eyeliner itself is great. It doesn't irritate my eyes. I just wish Este Lauder could come up with a better applicator.
Love it but
Shawndale from Celina Ohio
I love everything about the eyeliner except that I seem to be ordering every couple of weeks. It doesn't last very long.
DP from Cromwell, CT
Will you be coming out with a Little Brown Liner for those of us that don't use black? Wish you would since I have to get another named brand that does have it.
Accessorized from Lindenhurst, IL
I have been using gel eyeliner for quite some time and was ready to order more. Very surprisingly, the gel seems to be gone and this seemed to be my only option other than a pencil. I didn't really expect to like it, but ordered it anyway. I love it! It's easy to apply and I'm no spring chicken, so my eyelids aren't smooth as satin. I put a red dot of nail polish on one end so that I would easily know which end was the thicker line. No more grabbing the reading glasses! I definitely recommend this product.
MORE COLORS PLEASE!!!
Liz from Ohio
This is a really great product that makes liquid liner easy to use for anyone. I would LOVE to see more colors available, especially a purple and a gray!
(Would also love a deep blue and a deep green!)
J from Issaquah Wa
I love this eyeliner. Had tried others and nothing compares to Estee's little black liner. All day wear and the two size brushes make it so perfect to add drama or go lighter for day!
StarLove from Purcellville, VA.
This was my first time purchase of eye liner from Este Lauder. I am glad I did. The liner has two different sizes for thin and thick lines. I mostly use the thinner line. I love how smooth the liner is. It draws on beautifully and stays on all day until I wash it before bed. The intensity of the color is just right. It is not too harsh or shiny looking. I don't like the ones that are too glossy because the liner end up getting the most attention and I don't like that. This liner has just the right amount of gloss and color intensity. I love it.
KC from Green Valley, AZ
This is a great product. It lasts all day, even when playing sports. Easy to apply, and love the two size brushes. The ONLY reason I gave it a 3 star rating, as it would be great if it was offered in a brown black. This is "very" black. I like a little less impact, so a brown black would be better. Not sure I will buy this again, just because of the color.
mjab2003 from STL
I use liquid eyeliner every day and had high expectations for the Estée Lauder liner. However, on the 2nd day the fine line end appeared to be drying up and was so bad I couldn't use it. Maybe it was just a fluke, but I won't be buying it again. And it's still in my makeup drawer to see if it somehow works again but I doubt it. Just disappointed.
Only tried the Ultra fine so far, but
Paula from Bartlesville, OK
I tightline my upper lashes with this to make them appear fuller. I haven't tried the thin or thick side yet, but I am so happy with the ultra fine side. Heavy eyeliner doesn't look good on a woman my age. I just need a little definition. This does the job, stays on for about 8 hours before beginning to show a tiny bit of wear at the outer corner of my eye.
Excellent long wear liner!
Excellent long wear liner! from boston ma
Excellent long wear liner! Perfect for the day when you up for some extra activity - sports or dancing all night long. It really lasts! Easy to apply. Both brushes come handy when you try to achieve different line thickness.
AR from Plainsboro NJ
I'll start with the reason it doesn't get 5 stars -- it's not that easy to use. It's not a soft touch, but more like using a fine pen or sharpie, so it took me a few weeks to get used to it. Also I can't think of when I'll (or anyone) use the thicker side. I would have preferred the fine tip with a liquid soft tip on the opposite side (yes... please make that). The other issue I have is that it's black, I would prefer a more brown black for daily use. You can't get a subtle look with this. The good: it's dramatic and stays all day.