Rated 3.66 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review First time leaving a Five star review
I have never found a product that works as well as this. I have gone through at least a hundred. I am obsessed with eye makeup, especially eye lashes, they are to me the most important part of my makeup routine. So I am always trying to find a mascara that gives length, volume, and curl. This was it. I will never buy another mascara. Out of fear of this getting canceled I bought ten tubes.
It is absolutely fantastic. I have naturally long lashes, not extremely long but longer than average. After one coat of this stuff I looked like I was wearing fake eyelashes. After two coats my eye lashes look dramatic and amazing. I can't rave enough about this product. I was not too happy with the False lashes mascara from Mac and it almost ruined me on Mac products. Then I went to the store and they did a makeover and used this stuff. I was in love. If you are looking for that mascara that will really make your lashes look long, almost fake, and doesn't clump or flake, then look no further.
Most Helpful Critical Review Love It but...
I love this mascara honestly! I like how it makes my lashes look so dramatic however there needs to be a waterproof formula. When my eyes do water it makes my eyes burn so bad and it wipes right off
Reviewed by 308 customers Great product
rachel from nyc
I purchased this mascara last night and I am very pleased with this. it makes my lashes appear darker and longer. I will purchase this product again. I like it a lot!
Sarah from Iowa
Let me first say that I love this style of mascara in WATERPROOF. The waterproof formula is 10/10, excellent. I got this formula in a holiday bundle thinking I would give it a try (and save a few bucks by bundling). It was not worth the money saved. It smudges under my eyes by noon on a normal day. If water splashes my face or my eyes water at all it is game over. I love the way it looks and how easy it is to apply but the staying power makes it a "no" for me.
Kristen from MI
I beat breast cancer 3 years ago and lost my hair/brows/lashes. Everything grew back but my lashes are now fine and I need to apply 2-3 coats normally to define. This mascara is amazing in that I apply 1 coat and each lash has bold color/volume without clumping. I feel beautiful! Thank you!!
Tracy from Arizona
MAC 3D Black Lash is the best!! I've tried so many mascaras on the market, and by far the MAC 3D Black lash is the best out there. I don't even waste my time trying others anymore because they don't compare. I love how bold and full this mascara makes my lashes.
Not The Best
Echo from Springfield, OR
It defined my lashes and made them look longer but it flaked while just sitting at home
Jing from Fort Worth Tx
My first time to use this product since it was %40 off at Ulta..I'm glad I did.. it made my lashes stand out!..easy to apply and separate..no clumping, sticky or too much product on the wand..simply put I love it 🥰
Worst Mascara Ever
has from charleston, sc
The wand is the worst I've ever used. It's practically worthless. All clumps when I tried to apply it, zero definition. Awful. MAC used to have a great mascara and they discontinued it - why!?!?
Do not buy
Marcie from IN
I read other reviews that is mascara gets clumpy after a couple weeks and it absolutely does. Really bad clumps. Can't even really use it on my wispy lower lashes it looks so bad. The old maybelline from cvs is far better. Really bummed about this purchase.
Good formula, HORRIBLE BRUSH
sash from utah
I had previously had the mascara that was discontinued, and from what i remember the brush and application was far superior to this option. I do find that when it works, it works really well, however it's extremely difficult to use and the results are so inconsistent. When i pull out the brush, there is an excessive amount of product on the brush and when i try to apply a horrific amount of product clumps onto my lashes. I really want to love this mascara, but i just can't. I wish i had purchased another because i would love to not scream every time i put on mascara lol
Sarah from Phoenix
Instantly fell in love with this mascara!! Coats well and evenly applies to the lashes. A lot of separation and definition. It is perfect for my downward facing top lashes and sparse bottom lashes.
Sarah from Phoenix
Instantly fell in love with this mascara!
ann from Phoenix
new favorite i love the way it makes my lashes look
Kara from Land O Lakes, FL
My favorite mascara! I personally love how easy this comes off in the shower and with just makeup remover wipes
Dee from Houston,tx
This formula and brush is perfection. Brush separates but you can use the tip tobuild volume at root.
Summer from Connecticut
This is the best mascara for a natural look. It highlights every single lash and is never clumpy.
So far, so great
Kate from PA - Pennsylvania
Only used this a few times so far but I love it. I can actually see that I have eyelashes
ok, but there are better
Kristina from 34954
it does separate lashes well but is disappointing when it comes to volume. benefits bang mascara and lancome hypnose drama are both better. I have short and somewhat thin lashes so I need a mascara that can do more than darken them
The brush puts too much product on at once
Claire from Ireland
I hate the brush on this mascara! Bring back plush lash pleassseeee!
Well Done MAC!
Kels from Denver, CO
This is NINJA LEVEL mascara! I remember the days when MAC was known for everything BUT mascara. I got a sample of this stuff and I must say, HATS OFF MAC! You did it! It wears very well, is soft and comfortable to wear, doesn't flake off under my eyes, and comes off easily. Great volume and the thicker brush really takes it to next level thickness. I went ahead and ordered more - I hate running out and I absolutely hate it when products I love are discontinued (please don't, please don't). Cheers to everyone and your beautiful peepers.
Shawn from Md
Best mascara on the market.. long lasting.. doesn't get hard and caked on... realistic looking lashes..
Sb from Seattle
Mac has discontinued Haute Naute non-waterproof mascara and this is not a substitute. It is not at all as thick and does not lengthen the same.
Sb from Seattle
Mac has discontinued Haute Naughty non-waterproof. This is not a substitute. It is not at all as thick and lenthing.
i will definitely buy it again
laura m from dallas texas
best mascara ever
Empress66 from Bahamas
I am in LOVE with ALL my MAC products, I recommended to my sisters,mom, family and friend. To day we all only wear MAC nothing but the best!
Like fake lashes in a bottle
MotorCityKitty14 from Detroit
This is the best mascara I've ever used. It's full coverage to the point it almost looks like I'm wearing fake lashes. I love the wand, especially the ability to use the round end to get my tiny lashes. I did not get the waterproof version, but I did a 20 mile bike ride with it on, full sweat, and it didn't run at all. Highly recommend!