Rated 4.09 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Works on UNDER EYE CIRCLES!
This is one of those products where I was initially happy and over time the slow burn of my love of this amazing pencil grew stronger and stronger.
Works great for:
Highlighting along lash line
Bridge of nose
Concealing under-eye circles!!! The peachy yellow fleshy shade and size is perfect to run that line right along the point where my undereye area sinks in. It STAYS PUT and it doesn't sink into creases. I also use it to mask redness in my nose creases and conceal the bridge of my nose where my glasses and nose strips tend to leave redness.
I have purchased a plethora of concealers and color correctors over the years and this has replaced them all.
The only con I can think of is it takes a little bit of effort to blend, but not too hard considering the staying power of this product.
Most Helpful Critical Review Good Color, but Didn't Last Long
I liked this because it is a great color to open up your eyes without being super noticeable, but I find that it does not last but maybe an hour on my waterline. I tried setting it, but it still disappears really quickly. I will keep using this product though because, well, I spent quite a bit of money on it as well as it is not difficult to reapply. It is one of those colors that won't ruin your eye look if you mess up on reapplying it throughout the day.
Reviewed by 125 customers I would give it 0 if I could
T from Rockwall, TX
Such a waste of $$! I couldn't get it to work. I even brush it on my hand pressing very hard and nothing showed up. Wish I could take it back but of course I opened it to try it. Huge waste
Jess from Vermont
A perfect skin tone color that's not to unnatural looking. I use this everyday and I love it
Truly has a sleepless night loop cure to look awake!
Sarah the sleep deprived lady from Gresham, OR
Love how this product eases my insecurity of looking half dead on sleepless nights and have had many compliments when I've used this product.
Second time repurchase
KimChm from Michigan
Love this! Completely used up one and purchased another so I don't run out. It really does makes a difference in me looking more awake. It is the perfect color because if it is too white or too peach it looks fake and sickly on the eye. This shade is perfect and the formula stays on all day in my waterline. I am usually a drugstore makeup buyer, but this is worth the higher price for me because it works so well. FYI, I never use the smudger tip, only the pencil end.
NiYo from Fairfield, CA
Long lasting and great color pay off. Just a little pricey.
Jill from Florida
Line inside of lower eye
It stays on all day and works!
Waste of money
Amy from Illinois
Minuscule amount of product. Does not spread. Waste of money.
Once I figured it out.....
New fan from Boston MA
The liner is a bit deceiving. The tip that is exposed is not the actual product. I tried and tried at first and will deter why not product was showing up. Well I was using the "smudged". You have to pull the top off to expose the highlighter inside. I read a couple of reviews now and it looks like others thought it was dried out or didn't transfer color. I'm sure they did the same thing as me and were using the exposed smudged and not the actual highlighter inside. Now I love it!
Not a fan
Hols from Annapolis, MD
I was super excited about buying this but was so disappointed when trying it. Trying to test it on my hand was a complete fail because the product would not transfer. Then when trying it on my eye, the product still did not transfer and the little bit that did almost immediately wore off. The goal of the product is great but the product itself is a complete waste.
Jangee from Harlingen, TX
does what it should but I'm not sure if the high price makes it anymore special than a lower priced nude color. I may try a cheaper brand when this runs out to make a decision if the price of this one is worth it.
Nickie from CO
This product has made such a difference in my morning makeup routine. Gives a more bright-eyed look with no effort!
Wow! 10 🌟 Rating!!!!
Vannah from MO
I simply do not understand how anyone rated this any less than 5 stars! It is ahhhmazing! I will never go without it! Instantly brightens and does not irritate my extremely sensitive eyes! I can't get over how good this product is! Honestly, Tarte never disappoints! It's so fabulous that my sister already rushed out to Ulta to purchase her own! Buy it!!! You'll love it!!
Lily belle from NYC
The material it is very dry and no matter how hard I press nothing shows up / rubs off this pencil. It barely shows up when I test it on my hand let alone on my water line.
The best thing since sliced bread!!
CNJ02 from Owasso, OK
I use this on my wet line. I hadn't even heard of the product until I watched a makeup tutorial on YouTube. My makeup bag will never be without it. I know some people mentioned having sensitive eyes but I am literally allergic to everything and have sensitive skin and I have no issues at all. I usually have to buy hypoallergenic eyeliner and I've had no reaction with this and I've been using it for about a week.
I can't see it!
Lynnie from Newark, California
I love send this as directed. No matter how much I tried, the desired effect was just not there. I hate returning during the pandemic, but this has to go back!
pleasantly surprised! Very natural looking.
D B from NE
I use this every day. After trying stark white, this one is so much more natural looking and works great!
I saw the product on a video tutorial and am glad i tried it!
NurseJomari from Utah
Love the wide awake look. Looks good with any makeup look.
Do not buy
Jess S from Arlington, Wa
The first tube I received did not work. I thought that it was just dried out but the 2nd tube did the same thing.
Best one ☝🏼
Jackietriz from Washington
I have purchased this eyeliner like 3 times already, I love it it doesn't irritate my eyes it looks beautiful and last a very long time 💯
Makeup Medium from South Carolina
This is something I tried on a whim and it's definitely a product I'm keeping in my makeup haul. It's am eye brightener I didn't even know I needed. It's that product that gives you the extra touch you couldn't put your finger on AND IT STAYS IN PLACE. No more eyeshadow getting in my eye from brightening the water line-- now I just use this and there is no complaint, con, or objection.
R from Mi
I love this highlight stick, it looks amazing around your eyes and adds a little pop!
Joy from Youngstown, oh
Best pen inner eye liner & don't have to sharpen. I love love live this product & don't know what I'd do without it. My eyes look bright & youthful & amazing !
Makeup critic from St Louis
The first eye highlighter I bought did not work. I thought it was dried out so I exchanged for another highlighter. Same thing happened. It doesn't work even if I apply pressure when I tried to test it on my hand. Dont waste your time or money buying it.
Pretty color, doesn't last long
Lorbethy from Texas
The color itself is really pretty and I've heard onto mine for a while bc it's good to cut that eyebrow arch every once and a while, but unfortunately the color doesn't last long. It also makes my eyes feel slightly itchy and watery which doesn't help the longevity either.
I'm not new to wearing eyeliner on my waterline so i know what to expect. But this for some reason just makes my eyes a bit more sensitive
ck from Mississippi
I had to apply it twice. once before doing my full makeup and then once like 20 minutes later .. but after I reapplied it it STAYED for 5 hours. amazing how this subtle change completely brightened my entire face. I was shocked and amazed. I tried this product on fb live and had so many comments saying they could see a huge difference between my eyes.