Rated 4.42 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review NYX epic wear liner sticks AMAZING PRODUCT
I was super excited to receive this voxbox and had very good reason to be excited. This product is cruelty free which is a plus. The packaging was very cute and nothing was damaged the box was wrapped in nice packing with a nice shade of grayish purple. It said it could be worn for 36 hours so for the sake of science I wore it for 36 hours. Luckily I received the color black. It was so easy to apply it just glided right on to my skin and had a smooth matt finish. For the first 8 hours it did last even through my sleep proving that it is indeed smudge proof. I worked out with it on and it lasted through the workout,sweat, and cleaning my face. And to test it's water proof abilities I showered with it on and it held up through the 40 minute shower letting the water it my face on the shower head strongest setting and the eyeliner was still on. It didn't even smudge or smear onto the towel when I dried. It lasted through 2 whole nights and of course started wearing as the 36 hours were coming to an end but who in their right mind would wear eyeliner for more than 8 hours at a time lol. This was an awesome product and I would buy another one and the other colors. The only thing I noticed was that people didn't know how to get more product when the first portion ran out but a lot of people said you can sharpen it so maybe that could be made aware of. Other than that 10 out of 10. And full disclosure it did start patching and smudging a bit but after about 16 to 30 hours of wear that is expected.
Most Helpful Critical Review Smudged on me
I really wanted to like this eyeliner. I love that it's cruelty free and reasonably priced. However, it was not long wear. I lined my upper lash line at 9:30am. An hour later, it smudged a little, but was easy to clean up with a cotton swab. An hour after that, it smudged a lot more and I removed it so I wouldn't look like I had black eye shadow on. I tried this over 2 days and on both days, it smudge a lot within 2 hours. To be fair, I do have an oily t-zone and the asian monolid and I have not found anything that stays an entire 8 hours. Even gel and liquid liners smudge on me (including Stilla and Kat Von D). I gave it one star for being cruelty free and one star for the price, but I will not re-purchase.
Reviewed by 388 customers Love!
A from Usa
Stays on for a long time. Never smudges or leaves my waterline!
Exactly what I was looking for!
katiee0960 from undisclosed
I have been searching for a high quality (but not excessively high in price) eye liner for a long tine, and I have finally found it! It applies easily, gives a nice fine line, doesn't run or smudge, and lasts all day. I would definitely recommend this product!
krystal02 from undisclosed
I love the new nyx epic eye liner. It glides on smooth and stays on all day. Just one swipe on your water line and your good to go. You dont have to run over your water liner 3 or 4 times to get a desired amount like most eyeliner but this one is creamy and glides on perfect.
adriannarpalmer from undisclosed
I received this liner in a VoxBox, and I love it! it glides on so smoothly, and lasts so long. Great deep black color. However, I wish it had a finer point, and a way to keep the tip at a fine point.
Easy to use and lasts all day
stace_stagram from undisclosed
I received this item free through influenster. I prefer a gel liner VS liquid, so I was excited to try this out. The turquoise color is really beautiful and it was really easy to use. I would definitely say it's long lasting and smudge proof! Almost to a fault. I struggled with removing the liner at the end of the day, so thats really the only con. I'll definitely be getting it in other shades!
angeld307f from undisclosed
this is a great product. such a smooth and lasting formula. as well as an easy application. i wouldnt change anything about the product. i would definitely recommend this to anyone especially for its price range
Glides so well!
jennifers86 from undisclosed
This eyeliner glided so easily. It was like butter. The pigmentation was great as well and I felt it lasted all day. The turquoise color I got to try (I received this product for testing complimentary of Influenster) was beautiful but not something I would wear everyday. Id love to try this in black or brown for everyday wear. Would purchase and recommend.
kwatsonbeauty from undisclosed
I received this liner complimentary of influenster for an honest review. I absolutely love this liner and have reached for it multiple times since I got it in the mail. Its super rich in color which I absolutely love. Definitely recommend it to try!
hannahcbcff from undisclosed
over all this is a great liner. super pigmented for it's color and super easy to apply. I wish it worked better on the waterline but most colored liners don't, so that was expected. I will definitely be purchasing other colors from this line!!
Siobhan from Maine
Really love the color of the teal liner stick, but for the price and what this product has been marketed as, I'm frankly disappointed. There's no way to sharpen it as it's not a pencil and you would be sharpening plastic, and the visible product that was sent to me was broken/melted by the time it got to me. If this came in an actual pencil or a liquid form, that would be a better investment for folks.
Bop or Flop?
jlikesmooses from undisclosed
honestly, i had high hopes for this product. when i first used it, it was difficult to apply and had a chalky affect on the skin. not to mention, the cap is loose and falls off all the time and it doesnt give that great of a color payoff. granted it is cheap so youre getting what you pay for. perhaps as i continue using it it will get better. i was not impressed.
this was amazing
natalier0e55 from undisclosed
Overall this product was super easy to apply because it was so creamy, but did not smear throughout the day. The color seems very bright when swatched on the hand and I was weary about the color, but after putting it on, this color is very wearable even with everyday makeup! The color does seem to be a little more muted once on the eye, I tried the waterline. I will definitely try out the black and white ones and try on my eyelid but I definitely recommend for waterline. I received this product free in exchange for my review from Influster!
gets the job done
mackenzier5 from undisclosed
This eyeliner was easy to put on and had a really good color. I used it probably about 5 times a week. My only complaint is that in the summer, it would smear by the end of the day and not look as sharp
Glides so smooth!
matthewk9 from undisclosed
So let me start by saying as a guy, I only wear foundation. But as a gay male on TikTok I also wear fun colors and eyeliner for fun and acting.
This is super rich in color, it is easy to apply. And does not rub off or smudge. If you like color, this shade looks good with any skin tone. My first ever product from them and can honestly say it's great if you use it often! But also good if you just want a dressed up youthful look.
ashleyb16 from undisclosed
This is seriously one of the best pencil eyeliners Ive used. Ive been using the Stila Stay All Day liquid eyeliner pen for years (it once held up to 24 hours of air travel, plus a long layover in Dubai). This pencil is a serious competition though. It stayed on with no smudges while I was moving apartments on a 100* day in humid DC. Glides on smoothly and looks great. Will definitely repurchase. Photo attached has this product on the left, Stila on the right.
Great Wear, But Try Not To Sweat!
shes_an_autumn from undisclosed
Disclaimer: I received this product free in a VoxBox campaign.
Overall, I love this product- it's affordable, it's pigmented, and it goes on really smoothly. Not many pencil liners do that! The only thing I would say is that it claims to be "smudge-proof", and mine ended up smudging.
But keep in mind that I have super deep eye creases and am prone to heavy sweating, so those factors may have contributed. Thumbs up!
Quarantine Cat Eye
lyndseycamille from undisclosed
This products work extremely well to help me get a crisp and clean cat eye. I love just a simple flick to give my Zoom make up look a little more umph. This product pairs well with other brands and eyeliner pencils that I typically use. The price is also great and I can definitely see myself continuing to use the product.
One of my favorite eyeliners
esme_fi from undisclosed
Starting off by saying that the formula is very nice, it goes on smoothly and without any hassle. I've been given the shade 'Periwinkle Pop' and it is a nice color payoff. When using this specific eyeliner, it lasted all through the day with no smudges whatsoever. I've had no problem using this and it is very easy. I would recommend it to everyone and will plan on buying more.
annap83 from undisclosed
I was really excited to try this eyeliner pencil as it claimed to be high in pigment and easy to use. I received the light purple one so I was a little skeptical of how pigmented it actually would be. I was disappointed that it took multiple layers to build up any color payoff. One layer of this only showed the sparkles and no color. I will say that it had very good staying power for an eye pencil. Although I received this product complimentary, I probably wouldnt buy another one with my own money.
A little more than your basic liner
gabfoss from undisclosed
I always use a black liner in my waterline so Im always up to trying new ones. This one is definitely better than your average pencil liner as it truly doesnt fade and its super pigmented. The black shade is also very matte and a true dark.
The packaging, its your basic liner pencil that you have to sharpen but personally I hate that type of packaging. The liner itself is softer so you have to be careful when sharpening that you dont break it. The biggest issue I have with this liner is that it transfers from my top waterline to my bottom under eye. Now most liners Ive tried in my waterline will do this because of my eye shape but I was sort of disappointed as its another waterproof that still transfers for me. I will say that it didnt transfer as badly as other liners but the problem is that the liner is really smudge proof anywhere EXCEPT for the top water line. So when it does transfer to my under eye, its much harder to just wipe off with my finger. But even if it does transfer it still leaves quite a bit of product in my top waterline which is good.
So overall I might repurchase because it does stay and the transferring isnt as bad as others but if you have the same problem I do with the eye shape keep in mind it will still smudge. But all in all its a really good liner.
love the staying power!
lyssa3699 from undisclosed
I wore the black one to a fun day in the sun and we ended up all sweaty and the eyeliner didnt budge a bit! It went on super soft and creamy and stayed on for hours! I would definitely buy more colors in the future!
kerryd1 from undisclosed
This eyeliner is good! It goes on easily and doesnt smudge which is nice! The color is a good, true black. The only problem I have with it is since its waterproof I have a hard time getting it off at the end of the day.
Soo Smooth and Great color!
hannahe75 from undisclosed
This liner stick is so great! The color of the product is so vibrant and glides on so smooth! I think the ease of application is my favorite part of this product. I am so excited to add this to my looks and have some creative fun with it! I would definitely recommend this NYX Epic Wear Liner Stick to everyone!!
fencergirl816 from undisclosed
Ok so this was an awesome product that I cant wait to try it in other shades! It went on a LOT smoother than I thought it would AND it doesnt cake up like other eyeliner pencils Ive tried before. It also is awesome because it doesnt smudge and looks GREAT! Must buy!
jenb77 from undisclosed
Thank you for sending me this awesome linner !! it has a wax/ smooth texture! the price is also affordable comparing to high end brand!! It does have a long lasting if you use a primer because with oily skin it will smere throughout the day! I really like the product!