Product Reviews Rated 3.25 out of 5 stars
315 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Works for My Long, But Fine and Stubborn Lashes I bought this directly from Colour Pop a few months ago and just got around to trying it out. I was pleasantly surprised with its performance. I have fine, thin lashes, long lashes and rarely hold a curl for more than ten seconds. This mascara does a good job of building up some volume and visibility, but does not help keep a curl. It can clump if I try to add too many layers at once, but I usually do one coat, let it dry, then a second coat. If I feel real spicy, I'll add a third coat after my eyeshadow. The results are good for my every day look. My favorite mascara is the It Cosmetics Superhero lash, but this is a good alternative for when I'm tight on cash.
I'm surprised by the negative reviews because I haven't had problems with smudging or flaking (two things my oily, hooded, down-turned eyes are particularly prone to), but that's makeup for you. Products work differently on different people. I'd say if you are looking for a good bargain mascara, it's worth the try but remember it's just mascara, not magic.
Most Helpful Critical Review Great Lower Lash Line Mascara This is a nice mascara, but applying it is tricky. I wouldn't bother using it on your top lashes without a waterproof primer because alone it will not hold a curl. It will also flake if applied on the upper lashes, with or without a primer, so contact wearers beware. I didn't test it with a overcoat, so that may be a way around it. I personally use these on my lower lashes and they work great in that regard. I wipe most of the product off wand onto my hand in order to make applying it way easier and it always comes out clump free. If you go in with too much it will clump up immediately. It's slightly water resistant, but if you cry it will most likely be gone once you calm down. That being said, I like these and will continue to buy them (if they don't discontinue them). I don't like to put eyeshadow under my eyes, so adding one of these mascaras really helps give me the oomph I need to the lower lashes. The purple one is my favorite so far. Definitely not as bright and pastel as I thought it would be. More of a mid-toned lavender, but still beautiful!
Reviewed by 315 customers Disappointing 2
makeup enthusiast from CA
I was really excited to find a red mascara, and one that isn't too expensive, but this mascara is just awful. It's very dry and you have to apply at least 3-4 coats in order to actually see the color. I even tried it with a lash primer and it still sucked.
Too Runny 3
Em from nah
This is the worst mascara I have ever used. It is so runny and clumpy. Personally, the wand holds way too much product and gets all over my lids with one swipe. I have to always be really careful when I wear this. If I
touch my eye area it immediately smudges. Do not recommend!!!
Make up lover 5
vern from westminster,CA
love the shade
Changed my mind ! 2
An from Monroeville
When I first got this I thought I loved it ! As the day went on I had product all over my eyes and it dried up very fast in the tube ! Also clumpy was not happy overall.
This is not it 1
Sara from Texas
I love colourpop products so much but this mascara is not good. It's super dry and almost feels like nothing is going on your lashes at all. Would not recommend
Worst mascara I've ever tried 1
Jo from CA
Please, please do not waste your money on this mascara. It bleed so much and flakes so bad. Bits of mascara will literally be falling into your eyeball all day. Just no lol
Great Product 5
Kelley from Buena Park CA
I love how the wand has two areas so that you can get full coverage.
Streaky panda eyes 1
Laurie79 from Indiana
Tried it for 2 days, ended up all over my face both days. My eyes are sometimes a bit watery, but I've never had a mascara end up streaking like this if I wasn't out and out crying. There's a difference between being not waterproof and dissolving at the faintest hint of moisture.
LOVE!! 5
Savvy from Connecticut
This mascara is so so amazing I love it so much! It truly lengthens and volumizes my lashes and it is honestly my favorite I threw all of my others away. The one downside is that it is really not at all water proof (which isn't doesn't claim to be so that's fine) but it's like any drop of water smudges your mascara everywhere so you do have to be careful.
Good but not great 3
Mimi from Milwaukee, WI
So far I've only used this product on bare lashes. It takes about three coats to really see the color, but it is very pretty once applied. The mascara lasts quite well, although the second time I used it there were a few flakes that came off towards the end of the day. Overall, I'm satisfied, but as it is a colored mascara, I expected it to pack a bit more of a punch.
My new favorite! 5
Haasndoss85 from OH
I love this! I use it everyday! It goes on smooth, lasts all day, looks great and comes off easy!
Not that great 2
Ali from Rhode Island
Was disappointed, I love colorpop products, but this mascara fell flat. Its formula is like a dried up clay, which just spreads clumps on your lashes. If your looking for a cheap mascara, just go for Great Lash or something, this one was no good.
Clumpy 1
Mya from Ohio
Very very clumpy and dry😬!
Pigmented! 5
Josi from Miami, FL
Gotten so many complements when used this! Very pigmented when you layer it (use a good amount), very pretty!
Dry and Flakey 3
Izzy from Maine
Pretty dry when I first used it and took a couple layers for anything to show up. It looked fine but then after like 3 hours I looked in the mirror and realized I looked like a panda
Great Lower Lash Line Mascara 3
Rachel M. from Santa Fe, NM
This is a nice mascara, but applying it is tricky. I wouldn't bother using it on your top lashes without a waterproof primer because alone it will not hold a curl. It will also flake if applied on the upper lashes, with or without a primer, so contact wearers beware. I didn't test it with a overcoat, so that may be a way around it. I personally use these on my lower lashes and they work great in that regard. I wipe most of the product off wand onto my hand in order to make applying it way easier and it always comes out clump free. If you go in with too much it will clump up immediately. It's slightly water resistant, but if you cry it will most likely be gone once you calm down. That being said, I like these and will continue to buy them (if they don't discontinue them). I don't like to put eyeshadow under my eyes, so adding one of these mascaras really helps give me the oomph I need to the lower lashes. The purple one is my favorite so far. Definitely not as bright and pastel as I thought it would be. More of a mid-toned lavender, but still beautiful!
no..... 3
tori from colma,ca
Doesn't do much. No curl, just volume and length. Might want to use a primer under that curls your lashes.
Super Disappointing - Clumpy 2
Al from California
Doesn't come with much product and the wand doesn't apply well with the consistency of the product, the brown color is nice though. Wouldn't buy again.
I would not buy this product again 2
Dani from Texas
Too thick and too much fallout
Very good mascara 4
Peaches from Miami, FL
Love the wand. Love the brush. Good coverage for a cheap price. Wish it was waterproof for the beach or pool.
Best mascara out there 5
Breanna from Jacksonville FL
I LOVE THIS MASCARA. So much so that I bought it in three different shades. The blue one really makes my eyes pop and brings a sense of boldness but not to bold. My only complaint is that they don't make a waterproof version. Other than that it's great!
Flakes 2
Itscyndo from Los Angeles, Ca
I got this as a gift and on the first try I made up my mind that I would never wear it again. It rubbed off on my eyes so I looked like a raccoon 🦝 and there was flakes everywhere. It reminded me of that horrible better than sex mascara. This might have been better than that mess but still bad. I wanted to like it because it reminded me of my middle school days where colored mascara was popular.
Do not recommend.
High hopes 2
EA from Boston
I really wanted to love this but I couldn't. Didn't give length and the red was stubborn to show. Some of the other colors pop more but even then the quality is compromised for the color.
Not for contact wearers 2
Biscuit from Iowa
I had high hopes for this product, a beauty youtuber I follow said that it is one of her favorites. I don't know why she said that, this mascara flakes all over and gets into my eyes and contacts. It also smudges, even after it dries, and the smudges even smudge more. I need to constantly clean it up all day. I like the shape of the brush (similar to Too Faced Better Than Sex and Loreal Lash Paradise), but I don't feel like it picks up enough product and I have to put on a bunch of layers. It does not clump. I will not be repurchasing this, I am not sure if I will even be finishing this tube; the smudging and flaking is rather disruptive to my day. There are better mascaras in the same price range
Bff Mascara Black on Black 2
Yalian from Puerto Rico
I loved how it made my lashes look but it will smudge on your lower lash line even though you don't apply nothing on your lower lashes and without any type of moisture. It had never happened to me with any mascara, very weird.
