Product Reviews Rated 3.8 out of 5 stars
46 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review I finally found my go to mascara! I absolutely LOVE this waterproof mascara!!! I don't even have to cake it on, and I do look like I've got false eyelashes on!!! I don't come from a generation that used false lashes, so I hate working with them. The dark black is beautiful, it covers my lashes smoothly, and completely with minimal slight clumping, that you can get out very easily with a lash comb. I come while the mascara is wet for best results. The mascara is very buildable, and goe's on smoothly. I also found that I had only 2 little sots go on my skin, and this is never the case in my past! Finally, no mess mascara! I have literally searched for years, and now I finally found my go to mascara! THANK YOU MAYBELLINE!!
Most Helpful Critical Review Little smudgey I thought it was a little smudgey because I wasn't' letting my under eye concealer dry enough before applying, but I didn't put concealer on today and I still got smudges. Not the worse. We're talking about 6-8 hours of wear and no anything close to raccoon eye, but I'm trying to avoid any darkening of my under eye area. I have had better luck with the Snapscara, but I don't get the drama that this one will give you.
Reviewed by 46 customers It's great 5
MrsJcksn from Ca
Purchased this mascara after seeing a video on youtube. I have very straight and short eyelashes. I curl them and need to wear a waterproof mascara to hold the curl. This mascara held my curl very nicely. The best part is that it's easy to remove. I do use an oil cleanser first. I use the same facial oil cleanser and all my mascara comes off. Some mascaras I have used in the past are very hard to come off. Even with oil or eye make up remover. I will repurchase.
Adriana 4
Is awesome!!! from Laurel md
The better mascara !!! It keep the curl, I by mistake asked the color brown and you can barely look at the tab but it's work and I love it !!! Is what I was looking for except for the color
Hard to remove 2
Trista from Texas
I loved the regular falsies lash lift but this waterproof formula is terrible for my lashes. Its so hard to remove and it just clumps up.
I did buy again! 5
Dolly from Woodstock, Ga
It lengthens and curls and separates. Yay!
Highly recommend for lashes that don't hold a curl! 5
TB from Georgia
I have always had to curl my eyelashes before putting on mascara as I have straight lashes. Recently I noticed that no matter what mascara I put on, my eyelashes were falling straight even with them being curled. I decided to try a waterproof mascara as I had seen some YouTube videos of people saying that it helps. I bought this one and have been so impressed and happy with my lashes. The curl stays all day (even through a 12 shift at the hospital), there is no flacking or smudging (I have very oily eyelids so that was often a problem for me), my lashes are separated and lengthened, and I don't have any issues getting this off with a makeup removing lotion and face wash.
LOVE this mascara!! 5
Jessica from Michigan
This mascara reminds me of the better than sex mascara, except this one is less dry and flaky, it goes on a lot smoother, and is half the cost! T
his mascara defines my lashes so well, and the shape of this brush is the bomb!
Not for me 2
Blonde bomber from Illinois
Very clumpy and thick. My eyelashes stuck together. Hard to remove even with makeup remover. I wish I could return it for something else.
Love 5
Moeh from Philadelphia
I have spares, light, straight lashes. This holds the curl, natural open eye look. Great for daytime, waterproof doesn't budge.
Nothing Like a Lash Lift 3
megnena from Houston, TX
I have super straight lashes that only hold a curl with waterproof mascara. I've had a lash lift and the results of this is mascara is nothing like the real thing. This waterproof formula didn't even hold the curl like most do.
i would not buy this again 1
McBooker from New York
I have short lashes and this product did nothing to enhance them. I needed a waterproof black/brown mascara but i'm disappointed
pleasantly surprised 5
Christine from NJ
I had seen an add for this mascara and I'm always on the hunt for a good drug store brand mascara. This does the trick. As many older women, I have short thin lashes and this darkens and lengthens them. It fits the bill. I wasn't sure about the brush but it works fine building my lashes. It is waterproof and lasts all day. It's a keeper.
Excellent 5
SM from Madison, WI
Excellent. Lots of newer mascaras are thicker. A new look it seems. Those more expensive ones too clumpy. This is similar style but not clumpy. Looks good.
Didn't care for it 1
TT from Rosedale
Didn't stay on through my day
Natural looking and good price! 5
Ally from Massachusetts
Really good mascara overall! I'm pretty pleased, the only thing I wasn't fond of is how many layers necessary to get the desired result! Otherwise, if you are looking for an inexpensive and natural looking mascara, look no further:) also, it truly is waterproof!
Worth a buy if you want a decent product 4
Princess KC from Virginia Beach
This is good if you want a similar look to natural like fake lashes. I am terrible at applying lashes so I found this as an acceptable alternative. You do want to have a bit of layering when applying. And curl your lashes first for best results
Great Mascara 5
Taylor09 from Georgia
This is the mascara I wear for my 12 hour shift at the hospital. It holds my curl and doesn't flake, smudge, or transfer. Since this is waterproof, it is going to be harder to remove than a non waterproof mascara, but I use the neutrogena makeup remover lotion before washing my face and then use the granier miceller cleaning water for waterproof makeup after and I have no issues with getting it all off.
Not the best 3
Margie from Detroit, Mi
The mascara itself is fine. The problem is when you got to remove it. I expect non waterproof to come off with ease. This was not the case.
Flakes 3
Eve from California
Waterproof yes, black yes, flakes? Yes! After one hour wear. Won't repurchase.
Works wonders for your lashes! 5
Nat from Gilbert,WV
I absolutely love this mascara, I have tried many different mascaras and this has been the best one I have ever used! :) I love it so much and it makes my lashes look so long and full, and gives them so much volume, and plus it's waterproof!
I would buy this product again 4
Belen from Aurora, IL
The wand is perfect for a really full look
One of the best 5
cfletcher from Houston
I've used some of the higher end ones. But this one by far works the best. No smudges or clumping. Plus its way cheaper!
Did not lengthen 2
4greatcats from Montoursville, PA
Was hoping it would make lashes look longer, but no.
nice heavier coverage of lashes! 5
char from cleveland, ohio
I would buy again, for a bargain mascara, it is good. I got it in waterproof because that's all that was left, but it comes off easy with makeup remover
Waterproof Falsies Lash Lift Mascara 5
Layla from Washington State
The only mascara for me!
So good! 5
Heather from Cleveland
I have tried so many mascaras both high end and drugstore. I always end up going back to Maybelline. Their waterproof formulas are the best. I can't use regular because it never keeps my lashes curled. They always fall. But never with Maybelline! This one I love because it has the hourglass shaped brush like the Too Faced Better then Sex. Which I like very much in the waterproof. But this one is half the price! It makes my lashes full and long and most of all keeps the curl. This one is my new favorite!
