Product Reviews Rated 3.96 out of 5 stars
2654 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review YES! This is the mascara of my dreams. I use to use the better than sex mascara but it irritated my eyes, flaked, was hard to remove, and was $24! I've been on the hunt for a mascara that could replace that one and after almost two years, and dozens of failed mascaras I have found it. this one is the best mascara I have ever used. Yeah, I said it. It lengthens, separates, adds volume, doesn't clump, and holds the curl of my natural lashes! The pictures i'm posting are literally ONE COAT! One! I'm in lash paradise! :D
Most Helpful Critical Review Great for full long Lashes; BAD shelf life! I usually buy Voluminous but it's been transferring under my eyes (even with waterproof) so I decided to try this. The result on my lashes were OUTSTANDING! I get so many compliments. And ZERO mascara under my eyes with non waterproof. I bought black waterproof and 2 tubes of black non waterproof. Why so many? I'll tell you. This mascara has a shelf life like I've NEVER seen before. Maybe a month and a half OR LESS then it's totally dried up! Had I not gone online and read reviews, I may have kept thinking it was somehow me?! I love this mascara but cannot waste anymore money on new product drying up so PLEASE FIX THE DRY OUT PROBLEM. So disappointed.
Reviewed by 2654 customers Yes 5
Elaine from Stow
Last all day, no smears under eyes
Pretty great 4
EC from SWFL
I wish I could add pictures. Pretty solid product. Great formula. Doesn't turn into raccoon eyes at the end of the day. Volume and length.
AVOID 1
Kay from Santa Rosa
This product is awful. So clumpy, the brush does not distribute the product evenly. Just the worst. Just a waste of money. You can find something better. I will never use it again
Maybe I just got a bad tube 2
Lanie from Birmingham
I'm pretty experienced with mascara, but this one left me unhappy, which is harsh, because I have never had an issue with a L'Oreal product of any sort. I will give it one plus: it does live up to its color description. Sadly, I have to work it and work it with a lash comb to get it to look anything nearly like it's supposed to. Too much work, and I had just bought the tube. I did so many things: used it fresh from the tube, applied it with a lash comb, tried it with the primer and without, tried it having cleaned off the brush before use, tried to loosen it up by placing the tube in my armpit to warm it up, dropped in a couple drops of brand-new Visine, nothing worked. It goes on like it is vintage-new stock. Maybe I just got a bad tube. The best one they had that was SUPPOSED to be clumpy was the Miss Manga Rock and L'Oreal went on and discontinued it, and that one was amazing.
I love it 5
Georgi from Yonkers, NY
I apply a few coats and that's all I need. Very lengthening.
Go to 5
Gina from America
Best mascara and only one I have used in 4 years!
So many compliments 5
Crissy from Gainesville, FL
Love my lashes with this mascara! I get so many compliments on my lashes when I wear it. The volume and length I get from this mascara is the best I've found. And the price makes it even better.
Used it for almost 5 years now 5
S from OR
Again and again I repurchase this mascara because nothing compares at this price point. Honestly, even higher end mascaras don't compare... I tried a higher end one recently because I received it as a gift... and I used it and ended up tossing it in the trash. Hard to find a comparison for this one!
Love it!! 4
Evee from Duncanville Tx
My go to mascara! :) It keeps my lashes up and makes me look away in the mornings!! STRONGLY recommend it! :)
New formula? 3
beena from Spaghetti
I've used this Mascara for years and loved it. However, my most recent purchase has been awful. It's clumpy and smudges. I'm not sure if I just got a bad bottle, they changed the formula, or maybe I kept it for too long? Such a shame. I'll try again soon
The New Classic 5
Tris D from Kansas City
I usually gravitate towards makeup products that are more proven classics instead of what's trendy and bold. This mascara is the perfect blend of both! The results give me a classic black feathery and flirty look, but with a little extra pop of drama to make my lashes stand out! No clumps and it's easy to add layers. Plus, it's pretty easy to wash off and doesn't leave smear marks across your eyes!
Not for me 1
EPZ from San Diego
Tried it and hated it. Didn't hold a curl and smears within a couple of hours. Flakes too- got some in my eye and OMG worst pain ever. Not for long straight lashes in hot climate.
Love it 5
Pie from Palatine
A worker suggested this product & I love it & will buy it again
I RECOMMEND 100%!! 5
Kristina from Florida
This mascara is amazing! After like 2 coats it gives my lashes so much volume!! The only bad thing about it is that when putting the wand back on the top, the mascara does get clumpy at the top but I usually just wipe it off. Every other mascara that I have tried does do that so I'm use to it. But overall I would definitely buy it again!!
Dries out! 3
Lacking lashes from USA
I have bought this product a few times hoping I had maybe received a bad product, maybe left it open a bit, or something!! But unfortunately, it's the product, each tube only lasted a couple weeks. Hopefully they can change the formula so it will last longer.
Best mascara ever!!!!!! 5
Nicky mother of 12 from Lafayette
I'm 50 years old and my 18 year old daughter asks to use my mascara!!!
This is great! 4
Slahm from Lincoln, NE
I love this mascara. Works great and is like the luxury brands.
I would buy this again and again 5
Luna from Crystal lake
I would compare this to better than sex! It's great and affordable
I would buy it again 5
Luna from Crystal lake, IL
I would compare this one to Better than sex mascara if you're trying to buy a mascara on a budget.
By far my favorite mascara for fullness and length 5
Alexis 0327 from Washington
By far my favorite mascara for fullness and length I was blown away. I used it in conjunction with the primer and my lashes were double the size. I am very impressed. I have non existent lashes so this is amazing.
New HG mascara 5
Jackie from Ohio
Love this mascara, I use it every day now! Doesn't flake, clump, or cause spider leg lashes. And super affordable!
needs layering 4
natasha from chicago
i usually do two coats of my regular mascara to get it some what okay looking, but this one i used three only because it was such a smooth application. builds nicely and not clumpy or as flaky as what i usually use, definitely my new favorite. it seems like the kind of tube to dry out fast and not last as long as other higher priced mascaras, but for the price it's perfect
Best affordable mascara 5
Erika from Dallas
I love this mascara. Makes my lashes look long and super affordable.
nope nope nope 1
al3621 from Iowa, United States
my eyes normally don't burn after putting on/removing mascara, but it looks like we have an exception with this stuff. several eyelashes gone while trying to remove this stuff. i have absolutely no desire for spider eyes miss l'oréal
One of two ride or dies for me 5
BatNurse from Michigan
This is one of my top two mascaras ever. I always have one, and if I'm out, I get it again ASAP. It can be low-key or dramatic; it just depends on how many coats you use. It builds on itself pretty quick, so it can get dramatic quick if you want that. I like that it doesn't smudge for me, and it lasts for my 12-hour shifts. So yeah, it meets all my needs. My favorite drugstore mascara.