Rated 4.32 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review I would 1000000% buy this again
Wow, I don't have enough great things to say about this. I found out that my boyfriend who I was going to marry cheated on me, so I cried for nearly 7 hours one day with this mascara on. To my shock, this mascara was still in place and only smudged a little bit. And when I say I cried, I mean I was in fetal position on the ground...and this mascara still held up. So y'all, go buy this thing because I will forever swear by it and if I could marry it, I would. Cause we all know it would be more faithful than my man could ever be. Solid 10/10
Most Helpful Critical Review Not at all impressed
How disappointing - I finally drop some money on a mascara and it didn't even compare to the CoverGirl LashBlast I normally use. My friend did like the look, but I like it when my eyelashes look long AND full. If you try to layer it, it just clumps up.
I even put They're Real on one eye and the CoverGirl on the other eye and asked a GUY at work which was better and he said, without a doubt, the CoverGirl eye was just as long but much more volume. So don't waste your money.
Reviewed by 10880 customers Best mascara
Maggs from San Antonio
Stays on without smearing. Makes my lashes long and thick. Won't use anything else
None from Utah
Every other day use
Great but Smudges Easily
Jammie from Texas
This is the first mascara I've bought that was over $10. Wanted to splurge and was looking for something that would give a natural volume. This product 100% delivered, I love it and I think it's worth the price. My only complaint is when I use this on my bottom lashes, it smudges very easily throughout the day.
I highly recommend!
Bernice123 from Appleton,WI
I love this product. It goes on flawless and and if you want more "POW"...layer it ! It defines , lengthens and separates the lashes with ease.
One of my favorites!
Kaley in Kansas from kansas
This is one of mine and my daughter's top two mascaras. We love how I'd doesn't clump, smear, and lasts a long time. My only con is I don't like paying quite so much since I always have to buy one for her and one for myself every time I shop!
ATL from San Antonio, Tx
Best mascara ever!!
Carmen from NC
Love this mascara! Makes my lashes look thicker and longer. The best part is, it doesn't flake off! Finally I found a great mascara that doesn't flake!
Reetee from Jackson, MS
Love this product! Occasionally hear of and try new (less expensive) product but always make my way back to this. So far, my go-to mascara!!
Jaz from Oregon
It's a not a miracle mascara but it's good and does it's job, made my eyelashes nice and long.
Benefit They're real.
Jbrn from Connecticut.
This is ok mascara. Not my fav, not the worst. Got in during 21 days so it was half off. It is def waterproof and not clumpy. I just need more volume.
Does not withstand humid environments
Darby from FL
I love the long, defined lashes I can achieve with this mascara. It has just enough volume too without looking fake. However, it took awhile to get use to the brush design. The brush tip kept stabbing the inner corner of my eye, so I had to adjust by using vertical strokes instead. Also this product doesn't seem to layer well past two applications without ruining the definition. It's hard to fix with a clean mascara wand as this formula dries fast. My biggest gripe with it though is that it smudges horribly underneath even though I don't apply mascara to my lower lashes. This would be a 5 star mascara if I didn't have to constantly fix it.
Purchased for the color
Bettina from Apopka, FL
As a very light blonde in summer I wanted a brown mascara because very black or black that all the great volume & lengthening mascaras come in looks ridiculously fake on blondes. The color is perfect! Wish BangBang came in brown or at least dark brown. Search continues.
Not Worth the Money
MyKaelah from Ohio
I bought this given all of the positive reviews, but overall it's nothing special in my opinion. It doesn't layer well or add the volume I was looking for. It's alright but not worth the cost.
Would not buy this again
Julesac from Farmingdale, NY
Probably the worst mascara I've ever owned. Before this I had been using Glossier's mascara which has a great brush, but just felt like trying something new. This brush LOOKS great but is actually horrible and creates lots of clumps. Sure, it adds length, but with clumps...would definitely not buy again nor would I recommend.
Maidenleigh from Fresno, Ca
My favorite mascara by far!!!! I have blond hair and light eyebrows. It's VERY hard to find mascara that comes on brown!!! If you are a natural blonde and don't want to look like you have black eyes.. lol This mascara is it!!!! Works best when you use the primer from same brand.... makes mascara last longer.
Kristin from Massachusetts
This is an ok product. I don't really understand the love for it. I didn't notice any difference in length and had to apply several coats. I tried it alone and with their tinted primer. I think I'll go back to the Better Than Sex mascara. I don't feel it's worth the price but at least I got it on sale during the 21 days of beauty sale.
My go to mascara
Shea from NJ
Love this stuff so much! Effortlessly long lashes!
It does it's job
MC from Raymore, MO
I like it overall, it definitely thickens but I don't feel like it lengthens like they claim. At least not on me! I do like it though, it's a good consistency and easy to apply.
cheryl h from MI
Beautiful & Natural
Duck from Midwest
I have naturally long eyelashes. Many other mascaras look chunky on me. This one is very natural & sleek. I love the wand! It's beautiful for everyday makeup or no makeup days. I wear this by itself most days. I bought brown, it has become my favorite mascara. When I run out of my previous black one, I want to try this version instead. You may not get the "falsies" look with this. That's not my cup of tea right now, so I haven't tried to multi layer. I usually use one coat of mascara. It looks very nice with my cool tone, pale skin.
Worth the Money! Please buy!
Marley from Avon
I have been using this brand of mascara for about a year and a half it's the best! One of them last me 6 months! It's great! Totally worth the money!
No I would not buy this product again
Wanda from St. Stephen, South Carolina
The color is awesome, the wand is too large, a large amount of mascara comes out with the wand that's not needed. It also starts flaking off during the middle of a nine hour day. It goes on great with another wand I have, I don't know that I would buy it for the price again with all the little things that don't sit well with me.
Best mascara ever!
Lash addict from Los Angeles
I'm a mascara enthusiast. I've tried just about all of the drugstore brands in my younger years and have tried just about all of the prestigious brands in the later. This is hands down the best mascara... I've purchased about 5 so far! This wand is everything! It separates my lashes like none ever! I have a few lashes that grow in odd, so that can be an issue for me. I've even used the old wands to help out after applying other prestigious brands. I have very sensitive eyes and this does not irritate/burn either. Recently purchased the accompanying lash primer and wow! I usually have bad experiences with primers because it can be hard to cover and have found some make my lashes clumpy, but it just made a mascara that I didn't think could get better even more perfect! I didn't think my lashes could look anymore long, full, and somehow still natural. They really do look like false lashes... but really nice ones
I think I have found my new go-to!
Moe from Ashburn, VA
I usually use the Roller Lash mascara (which I love and still love) but it only comes in black. I have light features, so using brown mascara really suits me. This one comes in brown and I LOVE IT! It's dark but not too dark and I love this brush. It definitely makes my lashes look longer and gives them a good curl. 10/10 would recommend.
Def will buy again
Bridgette from Brunswick, ga
Absolutely love how this mascara grabs every lash, doesn't flake and stays put all day. Not sticky. My lashes look beautiful all day!