Rated 4.35 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review IN LOVE! OBSESSED! HOLY GRAIL!
I was only able to buy Believer due to the rest being sold out. I am completely obsessed. Yes, the formula is definitely sticky. HOWEVER, it's easy to get rid off. Just use a bit of translucent powder to set it or blot down with toilet paper. I am an avid lipsticks consumer, it's extremely difficult to impress me, this lipsticks is blowing my mind though. I am the kind of girl to wear a full face or just the basics. When I eat and am wearing lipstick it always wears off and gets all over my chin, it doesn't matter if it's my $5 or $22 lipsticks. This lipstick however has stayed through hot soup, oily food, water, alcohol, spicy foods. It's truly amazing. I can make out with my boyfriend and this stuff will not budge, we are both extremely happy. For how long wearing it is, it's definitely comfy to wear.
The application is decently simply, the formula is thin, but can get an even application when working from one end of my lips towards the middle.
For the price of these, I'm so impressed. Needless to say I'm buying the rest of the colors and will almost exclusively wear these for a while.
If you're looking for a lipsticks that will not move, will not dry your lips too badly, will wear all day, this is for you.
Most Helpful Critical Review So So....Not a Huge Fan
It seem it took me so long to try this product. I finally got to try it this weekend.
I was sent this product free and to review #superstaymatteink
Pro: I loved the color. The color matched my skin tone so well. It dried really fast and I did put 2 or 3 coats to make the color pop a bit more. The color lasted all night
Cons: after it dries and I put my lips together, it is SOOO sticky!!!!! I di not like the sticky feeling. WHY IS IT SO HARD TO TAKE OFF?? I understand the matte-ness bur i do not believe It should take so long to remove it. It took me almost 5 minutes to take the lipstick off.
I loved the color but the process to take it off.
Reviewed by 4972 customers Great Liquid Lipstick for the Price
Sophia from Orange County
I love this liquid lipstick! It smells so good but the scent isn't too overpowering. The applicator is soft and slightly angled. The consistency is more on the velvety side. The liquid lipstick actually stays on all day even after eating/drinking. It was a bit hard to take off and dried the lips a tad bit, but overall it is a great product especially for the price!
Go to lipstick!
Jennifer from Milwaukee, WI
Love this product! I've tried several other matte liquid lipsticks, but they just don't have the long wear stay I'm looking for. It can be a little tacky if too many layers are applied, or if applied very thick. I'm fair skinned with dark hair and Seductress is my go to shade. It's the a great blend of pink/brown and is super flattering while being more subdued. Amazonian is a close second when I'm looking for a more orange tone.
I would buy this Superstay lipstick again
Bren from Hiram Ga
I have tried several different brands and I always come back to Superstay. It works!
Stay power color
Tan from Oregon
All day lasting power. Doesn't rub off under the masks we should be wearing in public. Wished there was a visual board of actual color available.
great staying power
workinggal from New York, NY
I was searching for a lipstick I could wear under a mask without having it ruined or smeared. I came across this product and ordered it in a few colors, and it is GREAT. While colors are hard to judge on screen, I am happy with almost all of the colors I purchased. They do feel a bit sticky at first, but once it dries down you are good to go- eating drinking kissing it really does dry down impressively. I LOVE the color mover and am also very happy with dancer and artist. Savant and Lover are more pink than I expected. The Hazelnut color from the coffee collection is a great neutral since there really isnt a great mauve neutral in their line.
Savannah from Las Vegas
I loved the color (heroine) but this product was horribly sticky. I felt like I had just rubbed Elmer's craft glue on my lips :(
Very long lasting, great color!
SV from USA
I am amazed at this lipstick. I have some luxury liquid lips, but I thought I'd try out something a bit cheaper. This lipstick stays on for everything! Drinking, eating, kissing.
Yes I love this product
Debbie from TN
It does stay on for several hours and I truly like that .
Amy from Indianapolis, IN
I was looking for a long lasting red lip stain, but this didn't work at all. It didn't even stay on when I rubbed my lips together.
My go to Lipstick
BTT from Huntington, WV
This is my all time favorite hands down matte lipstick. It goes on smooth and dries at a good speed. It's forgiving but doesn't take forever to dry. It's very creamy and smells great. Stays on all day and I have to use make up remover to take it off at night. I will only use this for the foreseeable future.
I love this lipstick!!
Adrianna from Atlanta, GA
This is such a nice matte lipstick. It stays on for SO LONG and it's really pretty. The only thing that I didn't like about it was the lip applicator. It kind of has these weird indentions in them. I'm not sure if they're there for aesthetic looks or if there's an actual purpose for them. Overall though, I'm definitely going to be buying this product again!
Love this lipstick!
Beachgmom51 from Pennsylvania
Love the color! Stays on all day even after a meal or drink!
Survived a car crash
Crash from Chicago, IL
My car was totaled and towed away, but this color stay 😂🙏 10/10 would recommend
Love the Color and Longevity
apk Old Town from Old Town Alexandria
Perfect when I am teaching and zooming for 160 minutes straight.....
LeeLee from Utah
It was very pretty the only thing I didn't like was how sticky my lips felt. Almost like it takes forever to dry! But I'm in love with the shade.
its fine, not for me
anna from georgia
the smell is nice and sweet but a bit too strong. the formula itself is very very very sticky. it does come off when eating too. its also extremely hard to blend for a more natural look. so this lipstick is only decent for full lips.
It's moderately okay
Sparrowhawk from PA
I've never used this product before this so maybe I just have a bad color (I got globetrotter), but this product was very eh to me. I like the color and I like the smell of the product. The one major drawback I have is that it's very sticky. It stuck to itself every time I used it leaving small bare spots on my lips. I've tried letting it dry longer, but that doesn't seem to help much.
Really Stay all day
kpb from Florida
Katie from cincinnati
Used with a primer, it lasts forever! Color so pretty I hate to cover it up with my face mask.
I would buy more colors!!
Viv from Greenville South Carolina
I feel like myself again! Being able to were lipstick again especially under my mask. I walked into the store and told the sales person exactly what I needed and she took me straight to this product!! Thank you Thank you!!! Love this product! I have told every lipstick wearing friend I know about this great find!!
Sarah from Georgia
I love this product! It literally lasts all day long. The formula is not great because it is so sticky, but you get what you pay for. However, you can't beat the product since it stays on ALL DAY. Will buy again!
Love this lipstick
Diane from Appleton, Wisconsin
I am a red lipstick girl. Love the color and wearability. I get lots of compliments.
Lisa from Texas
A makeup blogger recommended this superstar matte ink by maybelline. Being a true lipstick addict, I purchased two colors. The colors are amazing but the formula was super sticky. I allowed it to dry, hoping it would set. It continued to be sticky. You get what you pay for.
Loved this product!
Doris from Pennsylvania
First time using a matte lipstick and was pleased with how long it stayed on. I also love the color!
Love This Formula!
KK924 from NY
I originally bought this in the color "Lover," and while it isn't the most flattering color on my skintone (fair, muted, warm-neutral-olive - the lipstick turned bright raspberry pink on me when it swatched on everyone else as a mauve, lol), the formula is amazing! I had heard that these last through wearing a mask so I had to try them. And I've tried SO many brands of liquid lipsticks that dry down, and I normally don't like them at all because my lips are already quite dry and liquid lipsticks tend to suck out every last ounce of moisture from your lips. But NOT these ones - these are comfortable! I apply a *very* thin layer of product to my lips (I wipe off about 85-90% of the product from the wand before applying) and within a couple of minutes, it dries to transfer-proof. If you put on too much product, the formula will dry down but will stay slightly tacky. It's pigmented, so you really don't need much. It lasts the entire day, including through wearing a cloth mask, eating, and drinking. The worst that will happen is a small amount from the very inside of my lips will come off if I eat a really oily salad dressing or something like that, but the color will stay on the rest of my lips. I need to use straight coconut oil and a lip scrub brush to get this off at the end of the day. Truly a magical formula!