Rated 4.25 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Amazing!!
I was looking for a long wear matte lip cream and was directed to this. The salesgirl was super helpful and told me that Patina was a shop favorite so I tried it and loved the color right away! Patina is a great neutral color, like a dusky rose. Anyway, I wore it today to my family's early Thanksgiving dinner and it lasted all day!! I drank water and beer & ate a full turkey dinner. I am truely amazed by this lip cream. It isn't drying at all and it's been on for 8 hours! I will definitely be trying other colors!
Most Helpful Critical Review Zero stars was not an option; HATED this item!
We purchased this item to use for competitive cheer after explaining we needed a red matte color that would stay in place during long days of cheer competitions because the sales clerk said that it would stay in place and "won't come off without a good makeup remover." A few teammates purchased it for the same reasons. This did not end up being the case for us. It smeared all over faces, clothes and anything that even brushed across their lips. It DID however require a lot to get the color the smearing caused off. It wouldn't let me give zero stars, so 1 star it is.
Reviewed by 3269 customers I would buy this again in different colors
kc from CA
Overall I like the product and did try some other colors. What I would say for sure is that once I apply the product the color becomes much darker looking. I still like the color and it does last well just keep in mind that it does look much darker when applied. I still recommend the product.
It Gets Everywhere
Tiffness from Nevada
I was looking forward to a dark lip color that stayed put, didn't fade, and didn't transfer (all claims by Stella). This lipstick is none of those things. I let it dry for a considerable amount of time and didn't apply anything on top of it. It was on everything. My mask, my face, my drink, my napkin, my hands. The color lasted enough to be annoying. Since it was everywhere I eventually tried to wipe off the remainder and not worry about it. But when I tried to remove it, a dull and lifeless color was left behind.
B from Michigan
I have purchased several stila stay all day liquid lipstick and for whatever reason this color does not stay on as good as my others. It constantly came off onto my drinking cups and whenever I happened to touch it or kiss my fiance. I LOVE the shade but wish it would STAY ALL DAY.
HollyG from Arkansas
It truly stays on and didn't rub off on my mask! But it applies much darker than anticipated.
I love this!
Maggie from Ohio
This is one of the best liquid lipsticks I've ever used. The color is vibrant and does not move, and it doesn't dry out my lips (which is amazing because I usually have very dry lips)!
I would buy again! Perlina Shimmer color
Kait from Atlanta
Perlina shimmer color is beautiful and long lasting. I cannot speak on the other colors because I have only used one but I will definitely be trying others. It is not too drying but all matte lipsticks can be drying. I love it so much I wear it almost every day
Love the color
Kelley from Philadelphia, PA
I got this in Beso and love the color! The application is relatively easy. I think it's pretty long lasting, but it definitely transfers. Since it's a great color and looks good on the lip, I don't mind if I have to re-apply.
Stila did the job right
Sally from IL
After trying countless of red's, different brands, and looking for the perfect red lip I finally found the one with Stila. I am using the color Fiery. Credit goes to the girl at my Ulta who helped with recommending this top prestige brand. I have never tried the Stila brand until now. I love the color Fiery. It isn't too bright, there is warmth to the color, it is very comfortable on the lips, it is semi long lasting, and not difficult to remove. I used a makeup wipe at the end of the night to remove the color. I also liked that it wasn't super matte. Seems to me like there is a balance between matte and satin. I mean it is matte, but not like caked on to your lips. All in all I am happy with my purchase and can't wait to try other colors when the time comes.
Not a hater
SofiaB from Chicago, IL
You know I can't hate on this lippy. I hate traditional lip stick, hair sticks to your lips and smudges easily, so on and so forth. This actually stays on long enough for me to not have to keep checking on it, may need to re-apply at least once especially during dinner parties.
oohhlivie from Ca
I had to reapply after eating or drinking but I finally found the perfect nudey color I've been searching for in caramello
ULTA fan. from Wisconsin
I use it for cheek color. It lasts all day.
Would not buy this product again
Karo from Durham, NC
I asked a store consultant what would be a good transfer-proof, long lasting lip. This product was recommended. I applied this product about an hour before dinner. It wiped off on everything; my mask, napkin, hand—a mess. Def not transfer-proof. I let it dry 30 minutes before wearing a mask. I did not apply anything over it. When I got home there was barely any color on my lips. The color is beautiful & vibrant, however.
Jim from SD
Love this Liquid Lipstick, the best brand EVER!
Perfect nude Liquid Lipstick
Jim from SD
I love this shade, the formula is great. I ate & drink it stayed on like the camp it is!
Jim from SD
I love this Red, it's been a tough journey but I finally found my favorite Red Liquid Lipstick!!
Tip : Go brighter than you think.
Nik from Sterling, Virginia
I looked like death warmed over with this color and will be exchanging it for something darker.
Cindy from MA
Comfortable and pretty. Disappointed that has some transfer.
Didnt even stay on through my morning coffee cup
Mmgpumpkin from Orlando,FL
Not a stay on at all lipstick. Very disappointed.
Game Day Proof
Libby from Michigan
I bought this in the shade Fiery to wear on game days (I'm a member of a college marching band), and this stays on for the entirety of 13 hour game days, no matter if it rains or snows. It can be a little drying, so use chapstick before applying!
Did not like it
Myrtle from Waynesboro
Took it back for refund
My only lipstick
Tuthgal from Green Cove Springs
I love this stuff. The colors are great, I have a full range of the brand colors. I love that this is a long lasting, color saturated lipstick. I use a lip mask at night to keep lips moisturized and never have a drying issue.
MrsMoof from Minnesota
I love this lipstick. I always get compliments on the color. In the days of COVID, slapping some of this lipstick on makes me feel pretty, even if I'm in yoga pants and sporting a ponytail.
This is a mess
Kate from Arkansas
I usually line Stila products. This stuff was sloppy and got on everything near my lips; teeth, face, cats..
Love, but new colors are off
Audreyepperly from San Antonio
I have been a huge fan of Patina for a long time, so I recently decided to add a couple of new colors to my inventory. I was super excited to try Parma and Verona based on the swatched images and color description, but sadly they were much deeper brown and far from the descriptions of the shades. Otherwise, the lipstick is fantastic and has great staying power!
I would definitely buy this again
Bea from Nebraska
I have been looking for a deep red for a long time. I love this color. In fact it reminds me when my mom would wear this color.